Situated on a quiet street in Paris’ 9th arrondissement — about a 15-minutes walk from the quartier’s grands magasins and the Palais Garnier opera house — a Venezuelan couple is doing meticulous work to bring the world rare chocolate.

Among the first bean-to-bar chocolate makers in Paris, Andres Zakhour and Sabrina Trillos moved to Paris 14 years ago because of political unrest in their native country. Zakhour had trained as both a chef and pastrymaker in Venezuela, and had worked at Michelin-starred restaurants in London.

It was during a holiday in Venezuela, however, that he found his passion. His brother was working as a tour guide at the time, and the two siblings decided to travel to the eastern coast of Venezuela, where his grandfather grew up.

“We saw a lot of cocoa plantations, and different artisanal producers,” Zakhour recalled. “When I came back, I said, ‘I just want to work with chocolate.’”

Advertise with us

The magic of the Caribbean coastline and the different-colored cocoa pods growing in the tropical climate bewitched him.

“I fell in love with that,” he said. He likened it to a wine lover’s discovery of the multitude of grape varieties.

He quit London and went to work for two years for Franceschi Chocolate, owned by a family with a large cacao plantation in Venezuela. It was at this point he met Trillos, and they decided together to leave Venezuela, eventually both landing in Paris.

They founded their award-winning chocolaterie, Ara Chocolat, in 2015, naming it after the French word for “macaw.” The birds are ubiquitous in Caracas, their natal city.

Misconceptions

Trillos, trained as a language teacher, is the more outgoing of the married parents of two young children, and handles much of the company’s public relations. She lays out a small tasting for a visitor in the small, brightly painted shop.

Advertise with us

A new project for them this year has been to produce chocolate bars from French cocoa beans.

“This year, our objective is to show that we can have French cacao, that we can support French farmers and get great things if we work directly with farmers,” she said.

Trillos explains that cacao originated in the Amazon rainforest, and was only later introduced in other regions of the world, such as Africa, which has become the world’s primary source of cocoa.

It grows best between the two tropics, so a French cocoa bean can only be grown in French overseas territories. The couple cultivated direct relationships with farmers — in this case, farmers in Martinique and Reunion.

Rare cocoa beans from Latin America are what make Ara chocolate bars unique. (Sono Motoyama / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Reunion, located off the coast of Africa, is their only source that is not Latin American. The roasted criollo bean is light brown and produces a chocolate that is light in color. It looks like milk chocolate but Ara makes only vegan products, so they don’t make milk chocolate nor put cream in their ganaches or pralines.

Advertise with us

“People think that the darker the color, the purer it is,” she said, “but that doesn’t have anything to do with it.”

The Reunion bar is a work in progress.

“We think it's a cacao that has a lot of potential,” she said. “It has some nutty notes, a bit of honey of vanilla. There is a bit of astringency, the same you can find in wine.”

They’re trying to adjust the astringency with length of fermentation and drying, ordering a few kilos of the bean every few months to experiment.

The Martinique Amazonico bean (a variety different from the Reunion bean) is naturally darker in color, so the corresponding chocolate is also darker — even though both bars are 70% cacao and cocoa butter (and 30% sugar).

Advertise with us

It also has a completely different taste.

“Martinique is more floral, with a bit of nuttiness at the end,” she said. “It doesn’t have any astringency, and even though it’s dark chocolate, it still very — I don’t know if the word is ‘mild’ — but it’s not sharp.”

Just as you can’t say that a French or Italian wine has specific characteristics, Trillos says that chocolate from one country may have many different facets.

Bringing out personality

It is these differing notes that Ara is trying to showcase in their bean-to-bar production.

“Chocolate makers cannot invent new flavors,” Trillos said. “We try to show the personality of the cacao.”

Advertise with us

Like other bean-to-bar producers, they control the manufacture of their products from importing beans to the final product. (Most chocolate makers use readymade chocolate to formulate their confections.)

But Zakhour takes this several steps further in collaborating closely with farmers. He asks for photos of the cacao pods to see the different varieties, how the farmer plants, if they start from seed or buy saplings from a nursery. Because he is looking to highlight the characteristics of a specific variety, he pays more to work with farmers who will keep varieties separate. (Ara Chocolat also ensures that the farmers are paid a living wage.)

A ball mill refines the chocolate and gives it a smooth texture. (Sono Motoyama / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Zakhour attempts to fine-tune the fermentation of the pods and then the drying of the beans — both of which can have a huge influence on flavor.

During fermentation, the beans are put in a wooden box and covered with banana leaves. Heat will naturally start a fermentation process that allows different notes to develop. The farmer controls the process by regularly allowing oxygen to enter.

If the beans are underfermented, the chocolate with have cheesy notes; if it’s overfermented, there are mushroom-y notes. Each variety may have different requirements.

Advertise with us

Zakhour is in continual contact with farmers and they send him samples; he makes requests for more or less fermentation accordingly.

It is similar with the sun-drying process of the beans, which can give chocolate undesirable flavors if not done properly. When they can, the couple tries to visit the farms, but usually the work is done at a distance.

Sometimes this long-distance, long-term process can have unwelcome surprises, particularly when chocolate prices rise. Zakhour says prices have sometimes risen during a collaboration.

“If I don’t have all the money right away, I will lose the cacao,” he said. “That happened with a Colombian producer and also a Peruvian cooperative.”

Once the beans are in Paris, the couple roasts them. This, too, can affect aromas in the resulting chocolate.

Advertise with us

“If the bean, let’s say, has floral notes, well, Andres tries not to roast them very high so we don’t lose that aroma,” Trillos said.

Once they have the bean the way they want it, they use a machine to separate the husk from the bean, which also breaks it into small pieces. These are ground and then put into a mill with sugar and, if it is being used, cocoa butter until the mixture becomes a liquid. Leaving the chocolate in the mill a day or two can also develop different notes as well.

They temper the chocolate, bringing it to the right temperature to be made into bars or bonbons.

Cocoa beans of different varieties can have different colors, resulting in a final product of darker or lighter color. (Sono Motoyama / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The fruits of biodiversity

Ara’s French customers have come to expect a rotating roster of small-batch rare chocolate, though some have become favorites, particularly the Peruvian Chuncho bar. The couple try to keep it in stock as much as possible. (In Pittsburgh, Ara bars are available at Mon Aimee Chocolat in the Strip District for $17-$30.)

The bean-to-bar process is painstaking and sometimes heartbreaking, but for Zakhour, it is worth it, to conserve rare varieties. This is important not only to have a wide palette of flavors but also for the resilience of cacao in general.

Advertise with us

If we begin to rely heavily on just a few varieties, he points out, these could potentially be devastated by disease — with no backups.

“I think the only way to preserve something is to use it,” he said. “If we don’t buy or promote [a certain] cacao, maybe unintentionally, we will lose it.”