As an avid hiker who has trekked parts of the Appalachian Trail, Mike Zaccano has always been fascinated by the many species of mushrooms that grow wild in Pennsylvania’s woods — everything from traffic cone-colored chicken of the woods to honeycomb morels and funnel-shaped chanterelles.

The University of Pittsburgh alum got a growing kit for Christmas as a child, and occasionally foraged for them during high school and college, making sure to carefully double-check his finds with others to assure they were safe to eat. Yet, the Hanover native never considered turning his hobby into a business — until the COVID-19 pandemic.

Zaccano and Nick Wadding, who he met at a house party in 2018 and quickly bonded with over their shared love of fungi, opened Bounty Beneath mushroom farm in Armstrong County last November.

During the early days of the pandemic, the Springdale resident got to know Andrew Tepper, who owns Spork in Bloomfield. The restaurateur shared his passion for fungi and allowed Zaccano to plant mushrooms on some land he owned in West Virginia.

Advertise with us

The sawdust spawn he was growing was nothing fancy — just some garden giant wine caps, an easy-to-find mushroom with a distinctive burgundy cap that grows on wood chips and gradually expands and flattens out as it matures.

“It was mostly to fuel my curiosity,” says Zaccano, 27. “I told him I had this idea, and he was down with it.”

By fall 2021, he had his first harvest. It was just enough for a couple of meals. But, boy, did it ever light a fire in his belly. “I proved I could do it if I put the sweat into it.”

When Tepper purchased a former wool mill in Worthington in early 2022, Zaccano pitched him on the idea of using it as a mushroom farm. Wadding, who grew up in Kittanning and had worked at the Smucker’s plant in New Bethlehem testing peanut butter for bacteria and mold, was more than on board to help.

“We had similar aspirations,” says Wadding, 37.

Advertise with us

After setting up the grow rooms and buying equipment, they got to it. And in November 2023, they officially opened as a brick-and-mortar business. Their first customer — after a cold call, no less — was Jillian’s Restaurant in New Kensington.

Owner Philip Call laughs when he recalls how Zaccano showed up on his doorstep with a sample pack of lion’s mane and oyster mushrooms around the start of the holidays last year.

“It was mid-November, on a Friday night, during service,” he says — not exactly an ideal time to be sampling an unknown, unsolicited product.

“Then I tried one, and it was delicious.”

Call not only used them all up that night, but the next day started ordering between 15 and 30 pounds a week, depending on the menu.

Advertise with us

“If it’s not a foraged wild mushroom, I get them from Mike,” he says.

Tastes like chicken

Call is particularly fond of the farm’s chestnut mushrooms, which not only look “awesome” on a plate, but have an amazing texture.

“They keep their crunch after cooking,” he says.

Call, who hosted his first mushroom-themed dinner in January, also gives props to their fluffy lion’s head fungi, which can be compressed, shredded and broken into chunks. He often uses them in meatballs to crab cakes.

Word quickly spread among the chef community, and today, Bounty Beneath counts some of Pittsburgh’s most esteemed restaurants among its customers.

Advertise with us

Shadyside’s Lilith — which hosted a second mushroom-themed dinner in June — gets about 30 pounds of chestnut and blue and Italian oyster mushrooms each week.

Chef/owner Jamilka Borges uses them in everything from a vegan farrotto to spaghetti sauce and beef Wellington. The farm’s fan-shaped oyster mushrooms also star in the restaurant’s famed “scallop” dish.

“They have an amazing texture and flavor, and we just love that Mike is so knowledgeable about different kinds and is so passionate,” says Borges.

You’ll find the farm’s lion’s mane ’shrooms — charred and topped with beet Bordelaise — at EYV in Deutschtown.

At Cobra, a yakiniku restaurant in Bloomfield, chef Sorcha Murnane braises their dense and meaty black pearl king mushrooms in a mixture of soy sauce and butter and then roasts them in the oven to get them ready for grilling.

Advertise with us

“The texture and color and how they treat and transport [their mushrooms] with so much care is essentially what has held my attention,” says Murnane, who buys a mix of oyster and pearl mushrooms twice a week.

Other regular customers include Spoonwood Brewing in Bethel Park, Round Corner Cantina in Lawrenceville, Senza in Etna and Pino’s in Point Breeze.

At Talia, Downtown, Wadding recalls how a customer was so convinced that her breaded lion’s head sandwich was made with chicken that manager Melissa Maffei had to bring the chef out to show her it was a mushroom.

“We like to partake with chefs that are creative and we know can make our mushrooms shine,” says Wadding.

Bounty Beneath also sells their mushrooms to home chefs in pre-packaged 4-, 8 and 16-ounce boxes at two farmers markets: Robinson on Mondays and Oakmont on Saturdays. Prices range from $13-$25, and because they go direct from the grow room into the kitchen, they can keep in a cooler for up to three weeks.

Advertise with us

“We started with these two big-ticket items,” says Wadding with a smile, “and they’ve been selling themselves ever since.”

Flavor and nutrition

Zaccano knows there’s lots of mushroom haters out there and even understands why someone could be turned off. Their earthy smell can be off-putting, especially for varieties grown in the soil, and people can also have issues with their meaty or creamy texture.

There’s also the whole toxicity thing. Some species of mushrooms can cause nausea, vomiting, diarrhea and stomach pain, which is why fungi that grows wild should never be eaten.

In extreme cases, they can even potentially kill you because symptoms don’t appear until it’s too late for an antidote (Here’s looking at you, death cap and destroying angle mushrooms!).

Which explains one of Zaccano’s favorite sayings, which he recites with a grin: “There are old mushroom hunters and bold mushroom hunters, but not old, bold mushroom hunters.”

Advertise with us

Bounty Beneath’s biggest selling point is that their mushrooms are clean.

In the wild, mushrooms are often found growing in clusters on living trees and decaying or rotting wood.

At Bounty Beneath, they grow in tufts or clusters that are either cultivated in grain or a sawdust substrate that’s been sterilized and disinfected in an autoclave. Then it’s inoculated with spores of the mushroom species they want to grow.

Because they’re not grown in compost or manure, “there’s no earthiness,” says Wadding. “It’s cleaner and tastes a lot fresher. You get that umami.”

You don’t even have to dab them clean with a damp paper towel before use.

Advertise with us

“Just cut the bottoms off, and you’re good to go,” says Zaccano.

As for the chewiness or slimy texture that some find unappealing, it all boils down to preparation. If you slice them thin and fry them in oil, they’ll crisp right up.

Anything they can’t sell is dehydrated into product that can be sold whole, or ground into a powder for tea or a tincture.

Both men wear gloves and foot covers whenever they enter a grow room so not to introduce any bacteria — Trichoderma mold, which is in soil, could easily be tracked in.

They also wear masks to prevent breathing in spores, and prevent any bacteria in their mouths from contaminating the product. Mushrooms are visually inspected on a daily basis for any discoloration (which could indicate bugs) and immediately disposed of in the trash if the fruit becomes contaminated.

Advertise with us

Usually, the tents are timed so they don’t all harvest at the same time, which takes some planning on Wadding’s part. Oyster mushrooms can be ready to pick just a week after fruiting while lion’s mane mushrooms can take up to three weeks. They know they’re ripe when the cap is still curling under just a little at the edges.

Taste is not the only reason customers love them. Mushrooms are low-calorie, low-sodium and super nutritious. Nearly every variety is full of fiber, protein and antioxidants that support a healthy immune system.

Multiple studies have shown that eating just two medium mushrooms a day may lower your risk of cancer by as much as 45%. Lion’s head mushrooms, which have been used for centuries in Chinese medicine, are thought to improve brain health by promoting the growth of nerve tissue, which is important for those with Alzheimer's disease and other brain diseases.

“My mother has Parkinson’s, and eating lion’s head mushrooms really helps with slowing the progress,” says Wadding, who developed a pierogi recipe that pairs the fungi with crab meat for her on Mother’s Day. He’s also used it to make various tinctures.

Specialty mushrooms, says Zaccano, allow you to be an adventurous eater.

Advertise with us

Fried, baked, sauteed or tossed in pasta, “They open doors to experiencing foods in a different way,” he says.

Lions Mane and Crab Pierogi

PG tested

Nick Wadding first made this dish for his mom, Victoria, on Mother’s Day. Not only is it tasty, but lions mane mushrooms are thought to have a variety of health benefits.

“If you like mushrooms and/or seafood and pierogi, you’ll love this,” he says.

This recipes makes a lot of filling — enough for at least two batches of pierogi dough. So I halved it. Bounty Beneath was out of lion’s mane mushrooms on the day I visited, so I substituted blue oyster at Wadding’s suggestion. I also cheated with a package of Bob Evan’s refrigerated mashed potatoes.

Advertise with us

My go-to recipe for pierogi dough uses sour cream and comes from Casey Barber’s 2015 cookbook, “Pierogi Love,”

For dough

1 large eggs

½ cup sour cream or plain Greek yogurt

3 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted and slightly cooled

Advertise with us

1 teaspoon kosher salt

2 cups (8½ ounces) unbleached all-purpose flour

1 tablespoon water

For filling

12 ounces fresh spinach

Advertise with us

2 medium shallots

3 cloves garlic

8 ounces fresh lion’s mane or blue oyster mushrooms

8 ounces fresh or imitation crab meat

5 ounces crumbled feta cheese

Advertise with us

6 ounces cream cheese

5 cups mashed potatoes

Kosher salt and pepper, to taste

Prepare dough: Whisk 1 egg, sour cream or yogurt, butter and salt in bowl. Add flour to large bowl. Gently stir wet ingredients into flour. The dough will initially be very dry and shaggy, but have no fear: Keep stirring and it will pull itself into shape.

Once dough starts to come together, press and smash it against the sides of bowl with your palms, picking up dough bits and essentially kneading it within the bowl until it forms a ball.

Tip dough and any remaining shaggy flakes onto a clean work surface. Knead until smooth, about 1 minute. Cover dough with a bowl and let rest at least 15 minutes.

Cook spinach in a pan with some butter and a pinch of salt until wilted.

Place cooked spinach, shallots, garlic, mushrooms and crab meat into the bowl of a food processor, and pulse until well combined. (You may need to do several batches.)

Place mixture into a large bowl and add feta, cream cheese and mashed potatoes. Stir to combine well. Make sure filling is cooled completely before you start filling the pierogi dough.

Using a 3-inch round cookie cutter (I used a pint glass), cut out 6 rounds of dough. Resist the temptation to re-roll dough scraps for additional rounds. It seems wasteful but dough won’t be as tender the second time around.

Spoon a generous teaspoon of mashed potatoes and mushroom mixture into the center of dough rounds.

Fold dough over filling into a half-moon shape, then gently but firmly seal pierogi by pinching and squeezing edges together with your thumb and index finger. Transfer to flour-dusted baking sheet and repeat with remaining dough rounds and filling.

To cook, pierogi can either be boiled until they float (2-3 minutes) or pan-fried in oil or butter (2 minutes per side). Parboil pierogi before freezing them.

Makes 32 pierogi per batch of dough.

— Nick Wadding

Chestnut Mushroom Burgers

PG tested

Nick Wadding first made this hearty burger recipe on a whim, “and it was a big hit.”  It’s definitely filling, especially if you also add cheese.

I only had 5 ounces of chestnut mushrooms, so I reduced the ground beef to just a single pound.

8 ounces chestnut mushrooms

½ white onion

2 cloves garlic

1 pound 8 ounces ground beef

1 pound sweet Italian sausage

1 egg, beaten

1 tablespoon thyme

1 tablespoon parsley

Salt and pepper, to taste

Hamburger buns

First, take your chestnut mushrooms, onions and garlic and  pulse in a food processor until they are well chopped.

Add chopped mushroom mixture to a large mixing bowl with the ground beef, sausage, egg and seasonings.

Hand mix meat and mushrooms until thoroughly combined, then form into ¼-pound patties.

Grill or, if not using right away, place on baking sheets and freeze until solid. Stack with a piece of parchment paper between them, place in freezer bags and store in freezer for up to 4 months.

Makes 12 ¼-pound burgers.

— Nick Wadding