“I'm a huge pickle fan myself — consume them by the handful,” said Scott Baker, president and founder of 5 Generation Bakers.

Working a single griddle in the parking lot outside the bakery’s commercial location in McKees Rocks, Baker is preparing and perfecting his pickle grilled cheese “sammiches” to debut at Picklesburgh next month Downtown.

Grilling might typically be accomplished with a beer in hand, but briny times call for a different kind of drink. So Baker is sipping on a cup of pickle juice as he begins flipping slices of his company’s iconic cinnamon swirl bread.

During an hour-long Picklesburgh practice run on Friday, Baker sets out to make 80 sandwiches by himself and give them away for free to any customers stopping by. He wagers the bakery can grill up 10,000 in total over the course of the festival.

Advertise with us
Scott Baker prepares dozens of grilled cheese and pickle sandwiches during a pop-up shop giveaway at 5 Generation Bakers in McKees Rocks on Friday. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

After 149 years of the Baker family’s ties to the local bakery scene, this year will mark 5 Generation Bakers’ first time as a vendor at Picklesburgh. With this year’s fest adding a fourth day to its schedule — the event runs July 18 to July 21 — Baker plans to close up shop for the day so that his team can focus on its Picklesburgh operations. They plan to run two booths, each featuring three kinds of pickle grilled cheese sandwiches.

Back in the parking lot, Baker makes his two savory Picklesburgh options by layering jalapeño-American cheese on a California tomato-basil slice sandwich, and Swiss and American cheese on Parmesan-garlic-herb slice sandwich.

Flippin Pickles kosher dill pickles from Erie, which are thick and sliced hot dog-style, will add brine to 5 Generation Bakers’ two savory sandwiches. The bakery connected with Flippin Pickles, according to Baker, through networking group Green Apple Barter Services, which is headquartered in Pittsburgh.

For the sweet toothed, the bakery is also assembling a French toast grilled cheese with bread and butter pickles.

At Picklesburgh, the bakery will be a sponsor of a Li’l Gherkins KidsPlay Activity Area, and will be selling sweet goods nearby. Their main tent will be located on Boulevard of the Allies.

Advertise with us

Baker decided to apply for a vendor spot at the festival after hearing about his cousin Nick Mancini Hartner’s success selling thousands of pepperoni rolls for Mancini’s Bakery at last year’s event.

During the practice run, Baker works out the kinks of sandwich preparation for the festival. Baker is still considering whether to use gas or electric grills at Picklesburgh, especially after the propane tank fire that broke out two weeks ago at the Three Rivers Arts Festival. He is also deciding whether or not to switch from butter to mayonnaise for the big day, because mayo has a lower smoke point.

As he cooks, 5 Generation Bakers employees and customers weave in and out of the bakery’s entrance to buy “misfit” loaves from their monthly pop-up shop and try a pickle grilled cheese sandwich.

Aside from these pop-ups, the McKees Rocks location is only used for commercial purposes. 5 Generation Bakers sells goods in bakeries around the country, and has recently begun expanding into the grab-and-go industry with a “Jenny Lee Sammiches” series, although pickles are not yet on the roster.

Baker is also considering options to open a “Jenny Lee breakfast” restaurant or food truck in the city.

Advertise with us

A pickle purveyor from Flippin Pickles checks up on the grilling operation to make sure pickles are incorporated into the sandwich, which is a necessity for all vendors selling food items at Picklesburgh.

A life-sized doll sitting atop a vintage bread scale at the bakery’s entrance is also overseeing the lunchtime activities. According to 5 Generation Bakers employees, the doll is nicknamed “Jenny Lee” after the bakery’s original name, a take on the 1930s song “Sweet Jennie Lee.” She has been with the Baker family for generations, and originally sat in their first bakery location.

At the upcoming festival, however, the bakery will have to make do without sweet Jenny Lee’s supervision.

“We're just really excited to be a sponsor of Picklesburgh this year. I have no idea what we're going to find out on July 18,” Baker said. “But that's why we're planning as diligently as we can so that we're prepared for the 200,000 people that they expect to come down.”

Elena Eisenstadt: eeisenstadt@post-gazette.com.