For Susan Hornung Simpson, baking has never been just about producing delectable treats.
As a kid growing up in Chicora, Simpson bonded with her German grandmothers over bread making. She began entering baking contests as a teenager once her repertoire had expanded to include sweets like cakes and cookies. When she became a mother of four, Simpson would regularly throw homemade pizza parties for her children and their friends as a way to keep them home on Friday nights.
“They all know me as loving to bake,” the 63-year-old Harrington, Delaware, resident told the Post-Gazette. “Our four kids are all boys, and you know how boys love to eat.”
Recently, Simpson’s baking skills were put to the test when she was accepted to be a contestant on the latest season of “The Great American Baking Show,” which premieres Friday on The Roku Channel. It was a thrill for the seasoned and prolific baker to be judged on her kitchen prowess by “The Great British Bake Off” veterans Paul Hollywood and Prue Leith.
“It was like I was living in a dream,” she said. “Crazy, just crazy!”
Simpson lived in Western Pennsylvania from age 2-12. Though she has called a few other places home since leaving Chicora — including Delaware for the last 26 years — she still has fond memories of Butler County and keeps in touch with friends she made there more than a half-century ago.
Read More
“I loved the small-town feel of Chicora,” she said. “Everyone knew everyone. ... I feel like the slower pace in Western Pennsylvania was a wonderful place to grow up.”
She got her degree in elementary education from Bob Jones University in Greenville, South Carolina, and worked as a teacher for four years before settling into life as a stay-at-home mother. All her children are married, and Simpson now has five grandchildren to use as taste-testers for her latest baking experiments.
It won’t shock anyone to learn that she loves baking shows, particularly “The Great British Bake Off,” which aired in the United States as “The Great British Baking Show.” She’s a self-described “adrenaline junkie” who has always gotten a rush out of watching others bake intricate food items in relatively short amounts of time.
On a whim, Simpson decided to fill out an online application for the American “Bake Off” adaptation. She then had to go through an in-depth interview process, bring in something she baked for producers to sample, and go through a simulated “technical challenge” where she was given a recipe she had never seen before and had to make it while racing against the clock.
“I loved every bit of it,” Simpson said.
Filming for this season of “The Great American Baking Show” took place last summer outside of London. That five-week period was the longest she and her husband had been away from each other during their 40 years of marriage. Missing him didn’t help her get over the anxiety she was feeling about facing so many worthy adversaries.
“I can’t say my nerves ever dissipated,” Simpson said. “I thought I’d settle into a routine. But every time I was in the tent, I was on high alert. I like that feeling, though.”

Some may have felt at least a tinge of intimidation knowing the show was being hosted by Ellie Kemper (“The Office”) and Zach Cherry (“Severance”). That wasn’t a problem for Simpson, who had no idea who they were going into filming. She was very familiar with both Hollywood and Leith, though, and was a tad star-struck upon meeting them the day cameras began rolling.
For the uninitiated, each episode of “The Great American Baking Show” consists of contestants embarking on three baking challenges: a “signature challenge” based on that episode’s overall theme; a “showstopper” that requires a bit of artistry to their designs; and the aforementioned “technical challenge,” where bakers receive an entirely new recipe and must do their best with what they’ve been given.
Simpson is the kind of baker who likes to be as prepared as possible, so she found the technical challenges to be the most nerve-racking. She couldn’t reveal the specific baking tasks she had to perform or where she finished in the competition, but Simpson did say she was ultimately pleased with her performance despite her natural inclination toward culinary perfection.
“We never did as well as we hoped to just because we’re all very driven people,” she said. “You always want to do your very, very best. With the pressure, time constraints and being filmed, it was very difficult to do my best. Often I was disappointed in myself. But all of us bakers felt that way.”
Nevertheless, Simpson still believes that there’s a lot to enjoy in this season of “The Great American Baking Show.” She feels like it was “the most like the British show ever” thanks to Hollywood and Leith’s involvement.
Even if she didn’t always live up to her own lofty standards, nothing about her “Great American Baking Show” experience dampened her passion for one of her favorite pastimes.
“I bake for my family and lots of friends,” Simpson said. “For years and years, my friends have known that if they pay for ingredients, I’ll bake them whatever they want. I can’t see that stopping.”
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.