If you haven’t had a chance to check out the previous shows in the Pittsburgh Cultural Trust’s 2022-23 PNC Broadway in Pittsburgh Series lineup, don’t get caught waving through the window as the final one comes through town.

“Dear Evan Hansen” is set to take the stage at Downtown’s Benedum Center from May 2-7. Tickets for each performance are still available for $42-120 via trustarts.org. The winner of the 2017 Tony Award for best musical caps off a season of touring productions coming through Pittsburgh that also included “Frozen,” Hadestown,” “Les Miserables,” “Hairspray,” “Jagged Little Pill,” “Beetlejuice,” “Six” and “Tina — The Tina Turner Musical.”

The Post-Gazette caught up with Alaina Anderson, who plays wayward high-schooler and the titular Evan Hansen’s love interest Zoe Murphy, to discuss what this latest version of “Dear Evan Hansen” brings to the table and why the events of the last few years have helped this musical about how far one lonely kid will go to find the acceptance and community he has always wanted maintain its thematic relevance.

“It’s a show about the need for connection,” Anderson said. “It’s already the most human thing ever, but it’s even more salient than before.”

Advertise with us
Anthony Norman, left, as Evan Hansen and Alaina Anderson as Zoe Murphy in the North American tour of "Dear Evan Hansen." (Evan Zimmerman / MurphyMade)

Evan Hansen (played by Anthony Norman in the tour) is a 17-year-old with severe anxiety who has always felt like there was a barrier between him and his peers. His single mom, Heidi (Coleen Sexton), can only do so much for him. At least Evan has been seeing a therapist who recently tasked him with writing letters to himself about all the positive things he can expect on any given day.

One of those letters ends up in the possession of Evan’s troubled classmate, Connor Murphy (August Emerson). When Connor takes his own life, that note leads his parents (John Hemphill and Lili Thomas) to believe he and Evan were friends. Evan goes along with that assumption initially to provide Connor’s family — including his sister, Zoe (Anderson) — with some relief, but his lies quickly begin to spin out of control and hurt the people closest to him.

Anderson is a 24-year-old Long Island, N.Y., native with a degree in cognitive science from Yale University. She first auditioned for the “Dear Evan Hansen” tour during her junior year at Yale in 2020 and was cast as the understudy for both Zoe and go-getter classmate Alana Beck (Micaela Lamas).

The COVID-19 pandemic shutting down just about every form of live entertainment for a year-plus gave Anderson the chance to complete her studies before joining the tour when it re-launched. She was an understudy for about a year before taking over the role of Zoe full-time in June 2022.

As a high-schooler herself, Anderson discovered “Dear Evan Hansen” through “bootleg clips on YouTube.” That’s how she was able to watch Laura Dreyfuss as the original Broadway Zoe. She has also seen the 2021 movie adaptation of “Dear Evan Hansen” directed by Upper St. Clair native Stephen Chbosky, which starred Kaitlyn Dever (“Booksmart”) as Zoe.

Advertise with us

Her performance is “informed by all the different Zoes I’ve gotten to see,” but the most influential of all was original tour Zoe Stephanie La Rochelle, who played her with the kind of “chill indie girl energy” that Anderson thought the character needed and deserved.

“As somebody who’s never been chill a day in my life, this has been a really healthy experience for me actually, to take on that relaxed vibe and strong sense of self,” she said.

Anthony Norman, left, as Evan Hansen and Coleen Sexton as Heidi Hansen in the North American tour of "Dear Evan Hansen." (Evan Zimmerman / MurphyMade)

One of Anderson’s favorite things about “Dear Evan Hansen” is how non-traditional the soundtrack written by Benji Pasek and Justin Paul is compared to other Broadway musicals. They’re the kind of pop-adjacent show tunes that she said her parents, who aren’t usually into musical theater, didn’t mind listening to in the car with her.

“I love a big razzle-dazzle musical as much as the next person,” Anderson said. “But I love how non-musical theater this is in a way.”

It’s tough to describe most of the music in “Dear Evan Hansen” as fun, with the exception of the crowd-pleasing dance number “Sincerely, Me.” Songs like “You Will be Found” and “So Big/So Small” are seemingly designed to elicit strong emotional reactions. Anderson said that during the show’s final orchard-set scene, there’s a blue light emanating from a screen on stage that lights up the audience, and she’ll sometimes “take stock of how many people I see crying.”

Advertise with us

She acknowledged that Zoe’s “emotional track is kind of a downer,” but Anderson still enjoys acting out her overall arc where she continues “learning to open herself up” to others. Her one mostly upbeat song, an infatuation-fueled duet between Zoe and Evan called “Only Us,” provides Anderson with a much-needed chance “to relax into that” after some of the heavier material Zoe has to carry.

After a season that mixed fantastical stories like “Frozen” and “Beetlejuice” with historically inspired shows like “Hairspray” and “Six,” Pittsburghers will have the chance to feel just about everything one can during a musical as “Dear Evan Hansen” closes out the 2022-23 Broadway in Pittsburgh series with a contemporary take on forming deep connections in the social-media age.

“Come see this show,” Anderson said, “if you want to laugh, cry, listen to some good music and have a really human experience.”

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.