The date forged into the cast-iron mouth of the oven reads “1872,” making it 150 years old in 2022, and from it come the salty baked snacks that Pittsburgh has enjoyed millions of times over – no hyperbole.
The new year will mark the 95th anniversary of The Pretzel Shop on the South Side, and Aaron Bowen is feeding handmade and twisted dough, a dozen at a time, into that brick-lined oven from a 12-foot baking peel. His family took over the shop in 1980.
Mr. Bowen’s older sister, Jaimey Gallagher, has been here since 4 a.m. This is their busiest time of year, and despite the massive changes of the city and the neighborhood in particular — which has seen a monumental demographic change from a steel mill community of families to a nightlife district favored by young professionals and students — is doing as well as ever.

“Today we’ll make 3,400 pretzels. That’s a little down from what we used to make, but not much. New Year’s Eve, we’ll make 5,000 pretzels,” she said, and that includes pretzel bites and buns.
That’s in addition to the hundreds of jumbo-sized, doughy pretzels dressed with icing and jimmies specifically made as a traditional New Year’s good luck charm. That was brought over by German immigrants and has largely disappeared in America but remains a thing in Pennsylvania, and in particular at this tiny E. Carson Street storefront, where very little else has changed.
“The oven is gas-powered now,” she said. It used to be wood-fired.
She said the New Year’s pretzels are akin to the Pittsburgh cookie table at weddings in terms of regional traditions.

Ms. Gallagher’s father, Dan, was a carpenter, and frequented the shop and became friendly with the previous owners, the Baranowski family, who had owned it since the 1920s. Prior to that it was some sort of bakery, although the exact history is a little murky.
“My dad wanted to retire as a carpenter. He wasn't getting any work. Somewhere in their BS session, my dad thought it was a good idea to buy this place for my mother — who had seven kids — to have something to do,” she scoffed.

But the Bowen family was all in and they run it all together today, keeping tradition alive. Eighty-three-year old matriarch, Marlene, still comes in three days a week to help the team of siblings and nieces and nephews, where they also make a variety of other baked goods and treats, as well as breakfast and lunch sandwiches. The business was able to dodge COVID restrictions over the past two years because their business is considered manufacturing. And they have seen the same regular customers come in for decades.
In a 2014 essay published in the Post-Gazette, retired professor Richard Peterson waxed on his favorite flavor of growing up on the South Side.
“When I was in high school, I’d often pass, on my way home, a diminutive vendor with his wicker basket filled with soft pretzels. For a few pennies, I could buy cigar-sized pretzels we called ‘fingers,’ or, for a nickel, I could buy the traditionally shaped pretzel, called a ‘round.’” That vendor is now a fading part of South Side history, but you can still buy those soft pretzels at the South Side Pretzel Shop.
Barbara Rudiak is the president of the South Side Community Council and the retired principal of Phillips Elementary on Sarah Street. She grew up in the neighborhood eating these same pretzels in the 1950s and moved back to the neighborhood in 2013.
“We used to knock on the back door and get a big bag of leftover pretzels for a nickel, and we were happy with those. We have great memories of eating them around the TV,” she said.

“We as South Siders take great pride in the shop being here. So many people come from all over for pretzels and sandwiches. And, it's a family-owned business that has been here so long.
“It’s a Pittsburgh tradition,” she said, but it belongs to the South Side.
When businesses like this disappear, so, too, does a link to Pittsburgh’s past.
There’s no immediate worry of that as the business is as healthy as it’s been, but Ms. Gallagher said there’s no succession plan in place at the moment.
“Once we croak, I don’t know who’s taking it over,” she said, chuckling.
Dan Gigler: gdgigler@post-gazette.com; @gigs412 on Instagram and Twitter.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.