What makes for the best french fries — before ketchup, mayonnaise or any other condiment?

Texture and flavor are defining factors, dictated by what potatoes are used, how they’re cut and prepped, the frying oil used and how they’re seasoned.

I tend to like fries made from russets, skin-on, thin-cut but thick enough that there’s some softness inside, fried to a just-past golden exterior. Sea salt is all that’s necessary for seasoning — no Old Bay or gremolata necessary.

Finding great fries at a restaurant is one thing. Making them at home is another. A couple of gurus have some ideas.

Advertise with us

Harold McGee in “Keys to Good Cooking” (Penguin, 2012) offers two methods. First, cut potatoes then soak them in ice water for 30 minutes. Then blot dry and fry them twice: first at 250 to 325 degrees to soften them. Then cook them again at a higher heat until they crisp and brown.

If you really want crisp fries, he says, cook once in simmering salt water until limp, then let them cool and dry. Fry at about 340 degrees, until they just begin to color; and then fry a second time at a higher heat until brown.

“I would have confidence that whatever Mr. McGee says to do would work well,” Trevett Hooper, chef-owner of Legume and Butterjoint in Oakland wrote to me in an email. At his restaurant, he uses local Kennebec potatoes in season (which is why their fries are short in the winter) and Idaho russets the rest of the year, although “almost any all-purpose potato that makes good mashers will make good fries.”

His staff rinses potatoes multiple times then soaks them for at least 24 hours in the fridge before blanching them. “I don’t know why but this seems important.”

When it’s an option, his staff fries in animal fats.

Advertise with us

But there’s no tried and true single way to make french fries.

“If I were crazy enough to make fries at home, I would probably approach it very differently than how I do it at the restaurant,” he said. “But really, I think there are a million ways to make a good french fry.”

Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart.