Which restaurant serves the best fries in town? Rather than relying on a listicle, a group of Pittsburgh friends set out on a three-year quest to find out.
Since 2012, a group of 8 to 20 tasters visited several stops within neighborhood — South Side, Shadyside, Oakland, Lawrenceville and Bloomfield — as part of a data-driven assessment to determine who serves the best french fries.
The group was founded by Cara and Andy Gaslevich, before they moved from Shadyside to Sewickley and had a child. Andy, who is in sales, grew up in Oakdale. Cara, a speech therapist, hails from Philadelphia and went to Duquesne University for graduate school.
The first couple they recruited were Jazmine and Paul Boatman of the South Side, the data geeks of the group. They’re both from Texas, although they met in graduate school at the University of Oklahoma in Norman, Okla., where they got doctorates in industrial/organizational psychology. They moved to Pittsburgh in 2006 and 2007, when Ms. Boatman got a job with Development Dimensions International in Bridgeville.
The Boatmans came up with a 1 to 5 scoring system to rank fries according to presentation, flavor, texture, aroma, aftertaste and creativity that were averaged to find the day’s winners. They used the same set of ratings for every round.
“We brainstormed the various factors that contribute to a person’s overall enjoyment of french fries. We considered changing the rating categories — or at least excluding some from our analyses — midstream, but we found that an average across the categories yielded results that seemed right,” Mr. Boatman said.
Read More
They started with a long list of contenders they gathered from an informal poll of friends. Three years later, in March they had whittled contenders to a short list of 10 to include The Library, Fat Head’s Saloon and Winghart’s Whiskey and Burger Bar, all on the South Side; Silky’s Pub and Angelo’s in Bloomfield; Park Bruges in Highland Park; Gus’s Cafe and Franktuary in Lawrenceville and The Original Hot Dog Shop and Hemingway’s Cafe in Oakland.
Restaurants knocked out in earlier rounds were Primanti Bros. in the Strip; Houlihan’s in Station Square; William Penn Tavern, Bites and Brews, Mad Mex, the Elbow Room (now closed) and Buffalo Blues in Shadyside; BRGR and Station Street (closed) in East Liberty; Union Grill, the Porch at Schenley, Five Guys and Fuel & Fuddle in Oakland; Dive Bar and Industry Public House in Lawrenceville; and Caliente Pizza & Draft House, Lot 17 and Bloomfield Bridge Tavern in Bloomfield.
That they didn’t visit some of the newer restaurants Downtown that are now considered some of the best representations of how Pittsburgh is changing. Back in 2012 “we simply couldn’t come up with enough restaurants we wanted to include to justify a Downtown day,” Mr. Boatman said.
“Logistics and safety also came into play,” he wrote in an especially formal way to sum up their alternate goal: to get a little drunk.
“Given that we knew we would be drinking quite a bit of beer during our tours and taking city parking availability into account, we tried to visit only restaurants that we could walk to. Butterjoint [on North Craig Street] would have been quite a ways from the rest of our Oakland stops, so it also missed the cut.”
For the final round, they took the crew for a best-of school bus tour to determine winners in two categories: plain and dressed fries.
Some of them thought that the O’s fries would win for nostalgia alone because so many in the group came of age eating fries at the Original Hot Dog Shop.
What they actually discovered is that Pittsburghers are passionately divided as to what makes french fries great, whether they’re traditionalists who prefer twice-fried potatoes, or free spirits who prefer battered fries, waffle fries or chips.
”Some people had strong expectations about what constitutes a proper french fry,“ Mr. Boatman said, ”And they would provide lower ratings for fries that fell outside of their expectations — like poutine fries at Park Bruges, potato bites at the Porch or short rib-topped fries at Hemingway’s. Others seemed more inclined to judge the fry offerings for what they were.”
Despite their efforts to quantitatively analyze fries, as the night wore on, the fries got better. “Because of booze,” said Ms. Gaslevich.
Her husband pointed to other variables that affected ratings. “It’s tough to judge a restaurant, or its fries, based on one tasting,” Mr. Gaslevich said. “For example, two places — Gus's in Lawrenceville, and Fat Head's — rated highly during the neighborhood events and earned a visit during the final fry day. However, both rated fairly poorly in the end. How come? Was it an off night? A new employee in the kitchen? A server leaving fries for too long under a heat lamp? It's tough to know, but for me, the disparity in the rankings for the places that we visited twice made me realize how difficult it must be for restaurants to do a great job, day in and day out, down to most minor details.”
In the end, Park Bruges won for the best plain french fries (3.76 out of 5) and Winghart’s truffle fries won for the best topping (4.17 out of 5).
“I came into the competition thinking that Winghart’s has the best fries in Pittsburgh, and I still feel that way,” Mr. Boatman said. “So the competition didn’t change my opinion of my favorite fries, but it did add some restaurants to my radar. For example, as South Siders, Jazmine and I have been to the Library quite a few times but had always ordered items other than the fries. Yesterday, we went to the Library just so we could experience their fries again since the group seemed to enjoy them so much.”
Here’s what else they learned: Why we love what we love isn’t something that can be easily quantified, even when it comes to food.
Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.