Jameson Buckley, who developed his style through thrifting, runs Twisted Vintage, where he has handpicked every piece. On a recent afternoon inside his Oakland shop, the Lincoln Place native, 25, wore a navy blue sweatshirt with a sprezzatura that made it feel as refined as a perfectly tailored suit.

“I have always been thrifting,” Buckley said. “When I was younger, all I did when shopping for myself was thrifting. I didn’t shop anywhere else. And I would just make cool outfits.”

These days, the Central Catholic grad’s store is located right in the heart of the University of Pittsburgh’s campus and just a mile or so from his alma mater.

Buckley’s store is among the recommended stops for holiday shoppers hunting for gifts with personality.

Advertise with us

“It’s stuff you can’t find anywhere else,” Buckley said, noting that thrifting also saves items from landfills and preserves it for younger generations.

The allure of thrifting, for many, comes down to unique pieces and good prices.

“What I love about thrift is that it appeals to so many different people,” said Bonnie DeMotte, executive director of Second Harvest Community Thrift store in Sharpsburg. “The people who want to thrift are treasure hunters and looking for that unique piece or antique, and the people who need to thrift are looking for a $5 pair of jeans.”

Twisted Vintage

“The vintage clothing is made to last, and the quality of it is the best,” Buckley said.

Every wall of Twisted Vintage, which he opened in spring 2024, is lined with vintage and current clothing, by color. In the front space are graphic tees, a ramp inviting guests down, the space is filled with gold accent lighting to the left on a tinted mirror.

Advertise with us

The small details, like the decor, create an upscale, pleasant shopping experience. In the background, music like Kanye West’s “Runaway,” plays, though it becomes an afterthought amid the hunt for great finds, like a leather messenger bag, Ralph Lauren sweatshirt and Architect leather jacket — all things that typically sell for $250 and above, at a third of that price. The brown Architect jacket was priced at $50.

With items on wooden hangers and arranged in careful curation, the shopping experience is imbued with a gallery-like feel. And the store’s two floors offer plenty to discover, including Nike Air Force 1s carefully posed on a wooden ladder shelf.

For Buckley, thrifting and finding personalized pieces is all about trial and error. When it comes to finding that really great gift, he suggests asking a staff member for help. Staff are trained to recognize every style from the late 1980s onward.

It’s all clothing he has been collecting and saving throughout his life. And when things sell, he restocks quickly.

“You are never really seeing the same thing here,” he said, noting the store will have a Black Friday sale.

Advertise with us

3717 Forbes Ave., Oakland; open noon to 8 p.m. Monday-Thursday, 11 a.m. to 8 p.m Friday-Sunday; tinyurl.com/twistedvintagepgh

Repurposed for the Thrifty Shopper in You

Repurposed, on McKnight Road in Ross, counts Gen Zers among its biggest clientele.

Elizabeth Echevarria, founder and CEO, started the nonprofit in 2012 after a trip to India, when she became aware of the prevalence of sex trafficking. The store donates all proceeds to its parent organization, Living in Liberty, which supports sex trafficking victims.

“We are a faith-based organization and we have a lot of people that shop with us because of that,” said Gary Volz, store director at Repurposed.

With some of the best thrifting prices in Pittsburgh, the store offers an array of items. On a recent trip, wares included a wood hutch made by a grandfather, full dining sets and vintage lamps sold at $9.99. The store also offers a diverse selection of jewelry, pearl necklaces to heirloom rings

Advertise with us

“We do have some very unusual things that come through here. It’s like, ‘Whoa, where did that come from?,’” Volz said.

The store also has sections for wedding gifts and party gifts, and the extensive book section often features sales of 10 books for $4.

“A good gift would be something in brand-new type condition that you are getting for a fraction of the price,” Volz said.

For Repurposed’s pricing, they often look up items on eBay or Google Lens and find a price it recently sold for, then decrease it substantially. Donations are extensively vetted.

On the second floor, shoppers can find clothing and bedding.

Advertise with us

“We have had Gucci bags, a vintage uranium glass from the Great Depression, authentic furs and a vintage parlor set,” said lead manager Maggie Thoman. “We get some really cool stuff.”

With Pittsburgh’s active arts scene, many of the shop’s clients include those buying props, as staff said was the case for the upcoming biopic film “Hershey” and many productions that have shot in the area.

Notable sales include 40% off clothing the first weekend of each month, and those ages 55 and up get 20% off Thursdays.

7805 McKnight Road, Ross; open 10 a.m. to 7 p.m. Monday-Saturday; repurposedpgh.com

What’s Good?

Another thrift store in Oakland, this one near Carnegie Mellon University’s campus was founded by Jessica Erceg.

Advertise with us

Erceg believes finding a great gift at a thrift store takes patience and persistence, having a focus and not panicking. And when that doesn’t work, there are always gift cards, which she mused can make for quality bonding experiences.

Like Buckley, she sources all the pieces her shop has to offer, which includes clothing for adults and children.

Originally from Regent Square and now living in Stanton Heights, Erceg also spent a few years living in Queens, N.Y. That New York City vibe — and edginess — is reflected in her selection, from purple leather skirts and a leopard print blazer to fire-engine red jackets.

“I’ve been thrifting since the 1900s,” Erceg said with a laugh. “Back in the day, the grunge-era, the worn flannels and grandpa sweaters were the style. There was a time when thrifting wasn’t so cool. More people are aware and retail prices are out of this world, so to buy something new is astronomically expensive.”

She takes pride in her items being pieces not seen in Pittsburgh every day.

Advertise with us

Erceg calls it “elevated thrift,” not necessarily vintage.

“I look for name brands, fabric content, a little bit trend driven. Every piece is thoughtfully selected,” she said.

The presentation also feels upscale (there’s free coffee) and there are also some streetwear elements in her collection. Two racks at the back of the store feature $5 sale items and items at half-price.

“Giving people clothing is my love language,” she said, “I have found incredible items for myself and for the shop, continuing to thrift. It’s a bit-by-bit process.”

“Thrifting allows you to try something new and different trends at a low risk.”

Advertise with us

406 S Craig St., Oakland; open 11 a.m.-6 p.m. daily except Wednesday; tinyurl.com/whatsgoodthrift

Second Harvest Community Thrift Store

Second Harvest, which opened in 2021, is uplifting to walk into, reminiscent of a blend between a Pottery Barn and an Anthropologie. The lighting is vibrant, it’s spacious and the displays are intentional.

“We pride ourselves on being bright, clean and modern,” said DeMotte. “We have a curated sales floor.”

The store is also a nonprofit, with all of the proceeds directed to grants for the surrounding community and living wages, with health benefits, for employees.

“We say to our donors: ‘We turn your goods into community good,’” DeMotte said.

Advertise with us

During its “Twelve Days of Thriftmas” promotion in December, Second Harvest highlights different item categories with coinciding sales, “to normalize secondhand gift giving because it is so good for the planet and your wallet.”

When taking donations, the store emphasizes quality condition.

While DeMotte recognizes the interest in vintage jewelry and high-end brands and meets that demand, in her community, there is a big need for furniture, she said, which comes in twice a week.

Other items include jewelry, some priced as low as $2.99, and you might spot a pair of Hunter rain boots for a fraction of their retail price. Home decor and appliances can be found for under $10. And the store also offers a variety of clothing, including a large selection of men’s ties.

Second Harvest is great for gift giving, according to DeMotte, because the staff is deeply knowledgeable about what is on the floor and everything is organized.

Advertise with us

“We want all of our customers to shop with a sense of dignity in a beautiful space,” she said.

Staffers also offer gift-wrapping ideas, like the Japanese technique furoshiki, wherein the gift is wrapped in a decorative scarf. It’s like getting two gifts in one!

624 Clay St., Sharpsburg; open 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday-Tuesday, 9 a.m.-8 p.m. Wednesday and 9 a.m.-2 p.m. Saturday; secondharvestthrift.com

Clothes Minded

Owner Josh Fedorski, a North Side native, opened Clothes Minded in Bloomfield in June 2012. His store offers an extensive range of luxury and designer brands, both vintage and current styles.

The secret to finding something great at a thrift store, he said, is to “actually look.”

Advertise with us

“In a used shop, the key is to look at everything,” Fedorski said.

Thrifting has changed drastically over the last 15 years, he noted, with stores offering more curated selections and styles. Clothes Minded’s buy, sell and trade model has helped the store keep an inventory of clothing that is rare, but affordable.

”At Clothes Minded, we buy sell and trade current and vintage clothing/accessories,” reads the store’s website. “We prefer items in good to excellent condition. We are always in search of luxury/high-end handbags and other pieces from brands such as Chanel, Hermes, Louis Vuitton, etc.”

4740 Liberty Ave., Bloomfield; noon to 7 p.m. Monday-Saturday, noon to 5 p.m. Sunday; clothesmindedpgh.com