If hell hath no fury like a woman scorned, imagine how a scorned woman who loves to shop feels!

In a very bad case of adding insult to injury, a postcard Saks Fifth Avenue sent to its cardholders last week has managed to inflame more than one customer with its insensitivity. Signed by Jennifer de Winter, executive vice president of stores for the chain, it assured shoppers that "great consideration" went into "the difficult decision" to close March 17. After thanking customers for their patronage, Ms. de Winter added that Saks "would like to extend an invitation to our Beechwood, Ohio, store just two hours away."

Note to Ms. de Winter: And just two hours back!

Basically, Saks is asking us to drive four hours to give them money they no longer care to collect from us here. The postcard points out that we can also shop at the OFF Fifth store at Tanger Outlets in Washington, Pa. (don't bother, mostly junk) and at Saks.com (gee, really?). What it fails to consider is the very real possibility that we might be miffed. As long as we're going online we can shop anywhere and probably will, out of spite.

Advertise with us

Call it the first wife syndrome. Pittsburgh gave Saks 60 great years and now is being dumped for younger, sexier ... Beechwood, Ohio?

Note to Ms. de Winter: We hate Cleveland.

But apparently we love New York, where Western Pennsylvania ZIP codes reportedly rank high among out-of-town shoppers at the flagship Saks Fifth Avenue. (Saks management would not comment on customer demographics.) That confirms two things: The Saks customer base is solid in this region, where many of the store's Diamond clients (who spend a minimum of $25,000 a year at Saks) live in small towns on large incomes fueled by coal, steel and gas. Second, the decline in sales can be attributed in large part to poor management and a failure to stock the merchandise local customers are buying elsewhere.

Certainly Nordstrom, Tiffany's, Louis Vuitton, Burberry and other high-end retailers wouldn't have opened branches here in the past few years if they felt there was no market for luxury goods. And even Saks isn't claiming its Downtown location was the problem. The store itself was in need of renovation -- and the city should have offered more, tried harder and worked on that parking problem. But although Saks executives explored Ross Park Mall several times, the fact is that the majority of Saks shoppers have city ZIP codes, followed by Fox Chapel and Upper St. Clair.

These are sad days indeed, watching a once-beloved store in the death throes of liquidation. Tacky neon orange sale signs are plastered inside and out, the work of the liquidation firm that is now running the store. It's kind of like "Invasion of the Body Snatchers." Everything seems familiar, and yet ...

Advertise with us

Many longtime Saks salespeople are still there, greeting their customers, accepting condolences and saying goodbye after 30 odd years in some cases. The reality of a poor economy and high unemployment hangs in the air, reduced to a simple "good luck" or a polite "do you have plans?" But there are also new employees brought in to help, for the great irony is that business at our Saks has never been better.

We all know that Pittsburghers love a good sale. But something else is going on here. Suddenly there are racks of designer merchandise we've never seen before -- Alexander McQueen, Stella McCartney, John-Paul Gaultier, Burberry Porsum coats marked down from $3,500, Pucci and RED Valentino. "Maybe if we'd had these things before we wouldn't be closing now," several salespeople lamented. And they're right. The pleas of Pittsburgh fell on deaf ears, for we were permanently pegged as Podunk.

That much of the "new" sale merchandise is coming from Saks.com and is marked down "up to 60 percent" is our consolation prize. There are some great deals to be had on the second floor. The third is closed as things are consolidated, and the first is a hodgepodge. Cosmetics and perfumes are not included in the sale. The better handbags and shoes including Prada have been shipped elsewhere. The better jewelry is gone, too. Most of the original Saks merchandise is now 30 percent off, and every Thursday it's reduced another 10 percent. Gifts and home items are 40 percent off.

Picking through the carcass, feeling rather like vultures, one of the great dichotomies of human nature kicks into gear. We're angry and hurt and disappointed that Saks is leaving. On the other hand, that Jimmy Choo handbag is a terrific bargain. Add guilt to the shopping cart of emotions.

In a way, the most unforgivable thing about Saks' decision to close is the damage it will do to the image of Pittsburgh. Brilliant surgeons and corporate whiz kids may not want to move here and buy that lovely home, or a fast car for its driveway, when their wives discover there is no Saks. Our once prime retail corridor is looking more like Death Valley, and visitors who wander one block from the Omni William Penn might wish they had just stayed home.

Advertise with us

Worst of all, we may have to forfeit our title of most hip city, as we were recently anointed by the Washington Post. We've also been chosen as America's Most Livable City, just like Portland, who we pushed into the Post's "out" column.

Portland lost its Saks a year ago.

Note to Ms. de Winter: Do you sense a trend here?