Penn Brewery appears headed for closure or a change in ownership, according to documents released earlier this week by the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania.
On Aug. 12, Judge Carlota M. Böhm signed an expedited dismissal of the Chapter 11 bankruptcy reorganization petition filed earlier this year by Penn Brewery owner Stefan Nitsch.
“The Debtor has reviewed its circumstances and determined that it has no reasonable likelihood of rehabilitation and is unable to propose or confirm a plan of reorganization,” an Aug. 3 filing requesting dismissal reads.
“The Debtor is not seeking additional financing, has no source of replacement premises, cannot satisfy lease obligations, has no committed purchaser, and lacks sufficient unencumbered assets to fund a plan. The only remaining path is liquidation of substantially all assets.”
The filing marks a striking reversal from an April 2 social media post by Nitsch, in which he described the bankruptcy filing as a move that “allows us to reset, reorganize and move forward.”
“Our gates to the biergarten here [on Vinial Street in Troy Hill] remain open, and operations continue as normal,” he wrote.
Read More
In a subsequent interview with the Post-Gazette, office manager Lisa Vogt said that the brewery was “in a hiring phase” and noted that the restaurant had recently begun opening seven days a week, up from four days a week.
But a month after the bankruptcy filing, the lot containing Penn Brewery, along with two adjacent parcels, was put up for sheriff’s sale. Arkham Realty — Nitsch’s property management firm, listed as Arkham Asylum as a defendant on the sheriff’s sale notice — had failed to pay outstanding debts to First Commonwealth Bank.
Penn Brewery subsequently reduced its hours and ended food service. It had previously closed its satellite location at Pittsburgh International Airport, in April.
The sheriff’s sale was pulled in June. At the time, Donald R. Calaiaro, the bankruptcy attorney representing Arkham Asylum, told the Post-Gazette that buyers were “circling around,” with at least three groups expressing serious interest. But, he said, “no one has gone so far yet as to deliver a credible offer in writing.”
A receptionist at Calaiaro’s office said the attorney was on vacation this week, when the Post-Gazette reached out for comment. Penn Brewery did not immediately return a request for comment.
According to the bankruptcy court documents, First Commonwealth Bank foreclosed on the property earlier this summer. The filing states that “FCB has incurred the burdens associated with preserving the value of its collateral and has worked cooperatively with the Debtor to identify potential purchasers [of the property].”
As of July 1, Penn Brewery still owed more than $5 million, with the bank holding collateral valued at about $3.3 million.
Because of the size of the outstanding debt, the filing states, “there is no bankruptcy purpose that would be advanced by maintaining this case solely to facilitate a sale that is already being pursued outside of bankruptcy.”
First Commonwealth and Nitsch are jointly pursuing potential purchasers of the brewery, according to the filing, along with “ongoing discussions with interested parties.”
The dismissal means that the brewery’s “unsecured creditors” will not receive compensation for outstanding debts.
Nitsch requested an expedited ruling on the termination of Chapter 11 because, according to the filing, “The remaining value of the enterprise is largely dependent upon preserving its going-concern status and avoiding operational interruption.”
That includes beer currently being brewed, preparations for Oktoberfest — the brewery’s biggest annual money maker — and potential damage to equipment. As of press time, there was no public record indicating a buyer for either the real estate or the brewery business.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.