Last month, Stefan Nitsch, owner of Penn Brewery in Troy Hill, announced his company filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy to restructure the business.
“We want to address this directly and transparently before any speculation begins: Penn Brewery is not closing,” Nitsch said in a letter at the time.
But according to Allegheny County records, its creditor, First Commonwealth Bank, has put the property containing the historic brewery up for a sheriff's sale on June 1 in a listing updated on May 8. Three lots are listed with a total opening bid of $2,720.09.
Tom and Mary Beth Pastorius founded Penn Brewery and released its first beer, Penn Pilsner, in 1986, well before the craft brewing trend swept the nation. In 1989, it opened a restaurant in the historic Eberhardt & Ober brewery, the first in Pennsylvania to use a brewery license since Prohibition.
Ownership of Penn Brewery passed through several hands after the Pastoriuses divested to a minority interest in 2003. Nitsch purchased the brewery and its property in 2022.
Arkham Realty — Nitsch’s property management fund listed as Arkham Asylum LLC as a defendant on the sheriff’s sale notice — did not immediately return a message. The Post-Gazette also left a voicemail message with Penn Brewery.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.