In some ways, beer and whiskey are silly and serious siblings.

While breweries invent zany, irreverent names for their beers — Purple Monkey, Even More Jesus and Robohop, for example — distilleries typically project an austere, aristocratic atmosphere. In whiskeyland, it’s the old fashioned that’s hip.

But this month, two Pennsylvania distilleries are partying like the craft breweries; they're releasing a collab.

Washington County-based Liberty Pole has partnered with Dad’s Hat Pennsylvania Rye Whiskey, a distillery in Bristol, Bucks County.

Advertise with us

Liberty Pole founder Jim Hough had been talking shop with Dad’s Hat founder Herman Mihalich for years. Mihalich grew up over a bar in Monessen, and the two men like to compliment each other as the best whiskey on each other’s side of the Allegheny Mountains.

This past summer, Hough shipped sample flasks by UPS of Monongahela Rye of three differently aged barrels to Dad's Hat, and Herman sent three west to North Strabane.

Each mixed three with three of their own to make nine combinations, then blind tasted each one.

Amazingly, both distilleries agreed on the same combination: a nearly 6½-year-old barrel from Dad’s Hat, and a 4½-year-old one from Liberty Pole.

They made two barrels, or around 400 bottles, of the joint venture. Each distiller got 200 bottles. It retails at $79.99 per bottle, and will be sold on site at both distilleries.

Advertise with us

When I drove to the Liberty Pole campus to have a look, Jim’s two sons, Kevin and Rob, were finishing up labeling the bottles.

Each bottle reads: “A Collaborative Rye Whiskey — from East & West.” No silly name. They’re only taking this imitating breweries thing so far.

The project, however, is meaningful, because this is Pennsylvania and Pennsylvania is rye whiskey territory, inheritor of one of America’s two great whiskey traditions. The other's in Kentucky.

In colonial times, rye was a forage crop that grew readily in tough soils. Early Pennsylvanians made rye whiskey with it, and the drink was a hit nationwide. In a young nation without a central money supply, rye was even used as currency.

But Prohibition wrecked the business. Rye whiskey is strong and grainy, and Americans lost their taste for the heavy stuff.

Advertise with us

In this century, the tradition has been rebooted, thanks to distilleries like these two, along with Wigle in Pittsburgh, New Liberty in Philadelphia and Stoll & Wolfe in Lancaster County.

Hough is a former hobby distiller who quit his investment career to make whiskey.

“In my forties, I was looking to move away from beer,” he says, “and drink something I could enjoy without getting bloated and heavy.”

Hough opened a distillery with his wife, Ellen, and two sons in downtown Washington in 2016. In 2023, they moved to a new space, off the I-79 highway next to the Meadows horseracing track complex, which includes the Hollywood Casino.

The modern distilling hall includes a Whiskey Rebellion flag. Their rickhouse, as a wooden whiskey storage facility is known, stores 3,600 barrels. A Kentucky-based company called Buzick, which built rickhouses for Maker’s Mark, Beam and Buffalo Trace, built it, and it’s the only one of its kind in Pennsylvania, says Hough.

Advertise with us

Like Pittsburgh-based Wigle, which is named after one of the leaders of the Whiskey Rebellion, Liberty Pole likes to traffic in the symbols of revolutionary America. It’s named after the symbolic pole erected in protest during the Rebellion, when distillers rebelled against a tax on their alcohol. In its shop and tasting room, there’s a portrait of tax proponent Alexander Hamilton upside down.

Liberty Pole was hoping the racetrack would bring customers their way. Instead, says Jim, cellphone data from a marketing company suggests they send more whiskey tourists to the casino and the racetrack.

I tasted the collaborative rye. The 119.6 proof whiskey has a complex, grassy taste with notes of maple and caramel.

The Dad’s Hat “is a little more oaky” and the Liberty Pole “is more grain forward,” says Rob Hough, like his brother a former engineer. “They balance together in a beautiful way.”

For comparison, I bought a bottle of Liberty Pole's Monongahela Rye and took it home with me to taste that evening. It’s strong, so I added a drop of water to draw out the taste.

Advertise with us

It was not as sweet as the collaboration, but had a satisfying dry herbal taste with a citrusy finish.

The more sugary notes of the collaboration whiskey come from the oak barrels, the Houghs say. The wood releases sugars that sweeten the whiskey.

Reached by telephone, Mihalich agreed.

“The barrel we picked from our side was a couple years older, so that’s why you have the oakier taste, and we use a bit more malt.”