We’re not guzzling beer like we used to.
In May, Anheuser-Busch InBev, the world's biggest beermaker, again warned that sales of lagers and other traditional beers have been declining.
Drinkers, said CEO Michel Doukeris, now want zero sugar, gluten-free or low-alcohol beer, which means producers must overcome “barriers for consumers to interact with” traditional beer. The company’s best performer is now the low-calorie Michelob Ultra, which recently added an alcohol-free version.
I wanted to check in on a place in Pittsburgh where consumers currently “interact” with beer, so I spent a morning at Liberty Beer, at the top of Liberty Avenue by the Bloomfield Bridge, talking to manager Paul Shelly.
For years, I’ve noticed how expertly Shelly curates a selection of over 800 beers while managing to hold down prices. He’s organized the store thematically, with a shelf for foreign imports by the window, a wide range of craft beers from all over America and a special shelf in the back cold room for locally brewed beers.
In the winter, Liberty is where I buy my favorite cold-weather beer: Colorado-based New Belgium’s Trippel. It’s an 8.5% alcohol by volume ale with notes of citrus and cinnamon that’s a cheaper — but almost as good — version of the Trappist classics brewed by monks in my native Belgium.
Shelly could pass for one of the tech bros programming self-driving cars down the hill in Lawrenceville. The 31-year-old from McKeesport wears shorts and wood-color glasses, plays golf, cheers for the Pirates and is married with children ages 2 and 3. When I dropped in, he was catching his breath right after a busy Fourth of July, when Liberty served over 700 customers. In the beer business, summer is the busiest season.
Shelly started his career at age 17 slinging Iron Cities and Budweisers at a store in McKeesport. He did a short stint in college, at Community College of Allegheny County, but decided the debt he might accumulate wasn’t worth it. Instead of studying further, he leaned into beer.
Liberty Beer, which opened in 2016, snapped him up in 2020. The owner told him he’d be responsible for choosing the beers in the store. Pennsylvania’s byzantine laws governing the sale of alcohol give small beer stores a chance.
Shelly conducts research by visiting brewers, talking to vendors, getting to know his customers, and reading articles and social media posts online. After collecting his information, he does all his orders on Tuesdays. Distributors deliver beer every other day of the week.
At the beginning of his career, beer lovers were drinking Belgian imports and hazy IPAs. The explosion of craft beers in America expanded people’s options and palates.
A bigger disruption was the COVID-19 pandemic. Like schools, churches and other social institutions, beer bars got hammered by lockdowns.
“The college kids weren’t texting their friends to go get a beer after class, so they lost the habit,” said Shelly.
According to medical researchers, sales of beer declined while sales of wine and spirits increased during the pandemic. Liberty Beer’s sales of vodka-based sodas have been booming. With fewer carbs and more alcohol, they’re perceived as both healthier and more potent.
While I was talking to Shelly, almost every person over 40 who came in bought beer. Every person under 40 bought White Claw or some other non-beer drink.
Overall, Liberty Beer still sells more beer than anything else. Shelly estimates that roughly two-thirds of Liberty's sales are still beer, and two-thirds of the beer sales are craft beers. There’s still a social romance to beer that a Smirnoff Shorty Ice Pink Lemonade can’t muster.
The top-selling beers at the store are classics like Bell’s Oberon Wheat Ale and Iron City Light Mango. This summer, customers are really into lime-flavored beers.
Bloomfield, said Shelly, “is a melting pot. You have college kids, people who have been here for 50 years and it’s an arts district.”
When I complimented his beer choices, he responded, “You have to give people the drinks they want. You’re not going to open a Ferrari dealership in a middle-class neighborhood. You’re going to open a Ford dealership.”
Non-alcoholic beers are selling better than ever.
“Ten years ago, the NA drinker was a drinker who drank for 40 years and then a doctor told him to stop,” said Shelly. “Now it’s kids that are having one or two traditional beers, and then they’re switching because they don’t want to get too drunk.”
One of the first things he did when he was hired in 2020 was set up a special shelf in the back cold room for local breweries such as Dancing Gnome, Hitchhiker Brewing and Cinderlands. Most of the big refrigerated room is taken up by packs of 12 and 24 cans or bottles from mass market staples like Miller Lite, Iron City Light and Old Milwaukee.
“We’re lucky that Pittsburgh has one of the greatest craft beer markets in the country,” said Shelly. Every Friday, from 4-6 p.m., Liberty holds tastings so customers can sample new beers.
The best-selling local beer this summer at Liberty has been Cinderlands Lil' Cinder Lime. I picked up a four-pack of 16-ounce cans for $9.99, and that night enjoyed one on my porch.
At only 4.2% ABV. Lil’ Cinder Lime is light and a bit watery, but tasty with a balanced lime flavor and corny malt finish. It’s a beer to love at a certain time and place — like Pittsburgh in the summer.
John W. Miller (jmjournalist@gmail.com) is a Pittsburgh-based writer.
Correction July 18, 2025: An earlier version of this article misidentified Cinderlands Lil' Cinder Lime.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.