Syrupy. Fusel. Bubblegum.

These are a few of the descriptors likely to pop into your head after tasting Jannamico Super Punch for the first time. Stick with it – it’s the kind of drink that grows on you.

While the Italian spirit isn’t as widely known across the region as some of our other iconic foods, such as Ohio Valley-style pizza and Primanti Brothers sandwiches, it’s been a fixture in Western Pennsylvania's Italian immigrant community for more than 40 years.

The first time Bar Marco bar manager Jason Renner tried Super Punch, he’d just finished a shift at Nico’s Recovery Room. He and a co-worker went for a nightcap at the nearby private social club Bloomfield Liedertafel when someone poured him a shot from a 1-liter bottle with fire engine-red, all-caps lettering over a black keystone backdrop accented with lime-green flames.

Advertise with us

“I’d never seen it or heard of it. It felt like motor oil going down my throat. My brain was confused,” Renner says. “Then that pink bubblegum flavor came in. And, wow. This shot hits you like a wild ride.”

Super Punch is part of a subset of amaro (a family of Italian after-dinner liqueurs) called punches. While most amari lean into bitter and tannic flavors, particularly in Northern Italy, punches from the central Abruzzo region tilt thicker and more saccharine.

“It’s a life goal of mine to get to Abruzzo and get to the bottom of the story of punch as a category of amaro. There isn’t a lot of literature about it,” Renner says.

"My brain was confused," Bar Marco bartender Jason Renner says of the first time he tried Super Punch. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

D’Andrea Wine & Liquor Imports, based in Penn Hills, is the sole importer of the spirit to the United States. The family’s history with the beverage is deeply intertwined with its niche popularity in Pittsburgh.

Company founder Joseph D’Andrea grew up near the distillery that makes it, Distilleria Michele Jannamico, in Lanciano, in Italy’s Abruzzo region. His family ran the only bar, restaurant and store in their small town, and Joseph’s job was to bring goods, including Super Punch, back to stock the shelves.

Advertise with us

“It was one of the staples of the store. The punch was the big one,” says his son John D’Andrea.

Joseph D’Andrea immigrated to Pittsburgh in the 1950s. One of the first moves he made when he launched the family’s import business in 1982 was to apply to the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau for approval to bring Super Punch into the United States. Federal approval for the formulation came in March 1983, and the rest is history.

“If you’re from Central Italy, you know it, and you purchased it from us to have at your home,” says John D’Andrea.

For a generation, Super Punch largely remained a niche spirit enjoyed by the region’s Abruzzi communities. The family considered discontinuing imports several times, but felt an obligation to those who cherished its ties to their Italian heritage.

“And then the bartenders embraced it,” D’Andrea says.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh-area bartenders caught wind of Super Punch, first produced in Italy in the 1880s, during the craft cocktail wave of the early 2010s. They created a slew of cocktails at now-shuttered bars such as Embury and Tender Bar + Kitchen and served shots of it as a nod to guests.

“Those mixologists, they loved to experiment with something different and they still do,” D’Andrea says. “It motivates people to be creative with it. You can see the gears turning in their minds when they get their hands on something like this.”

Super Punch remains a fixture at Pittsburgh bars, though more as a bartender’s handshake than a signature cocktail menu offering. It’s yet to achieve the big-time notoriety of another polarizing, hyper-regional spirit, Chicago’s Malört (which is now having a nationwide moment), but the beverage has broken free of its Western Pa. bonds. D’Andrea says approximately 65% of sales are regional, compared to 80% a decade ago.

The drink is more challenging for the general public to come by right now. Two years ago, the federal government approved D’Andrea’s request to import Super Punch in 700 ml bottles (the size it’s sold in Italy) rather than the specially made 1-liter glass. However, the shift resulted in the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board moving the spirits off shelves and into its Special Liquor Order category. This means customers have to order the beverage via the commonwealth’s Fine Wine & Good Spirits website.

“It’s been in and out of the stores five or six times over the years,” D’Andrea says. “Maybe with the switch in key personnel at the LCB, we can get it back in there next year.”

Advertise with us

How should you enjoy Super Punch?

The bottle’s back label offers some instructions: “You can enjoy it straight or as an aperitif. With ice and soda, it’s refreshin [sic]. Moreover, it is unequalled in flavor when combined with ice cream when sprinkled on” ... ice cream, likely, though we’ll never know the ending to the unpunctuated sentence that concludes with a preposition.

D’Andrea says he loves a 50/50 mix of espresso and Super Punch, and it’s tasty mixed with a 5-to-1 ratio of soda water and a pinch of salt.

Renner serves it as the last taste in an amaro flight at Bar Marco and, from time to time, makes a cocktail with it. He did a play on a Penicillin, swapping in Averna for a blended Scotch with a Super Punch float, though. “It’s really more like a submarine. It sinks,” he said. So you get the Super Punch after a few sips rather than peaty Scotch up top.

Super Marco

2 oz. Averna

Advertise with us

¾ oz. fresh lemon juice

½ oz. ginger syrup

¼ oz. honey syrup

¼ oz. Jannamico Super Punch

Shake all the ingredients except for the Super Punch.

Advertise with us

Double strain into an iced rocks glass.

Float Super Punch on top of the drink prior to serving.

— Courtesy of Jason Renner