Frank Cafardi cracks the tiniest of smiles as the 120-year-old freight elevator creaks to a stop in Pennsylvania Macaroni Co.’s cave-like basement.

At the far end of the stone room, past boxes of paper products and bulk spices, dozens of carboys stacked on pallets and filled with jewel-colored wine await the amateur oenologist as he gingerly crosses the threshold.

Some of the bottles the Green Tree resident has been carefully monitoring over the past week fizz with tiny bubbles, showing early stages of fermentation. Others are ready to be racked for the second or third time to remove dead yeast and other sediment that has settled on the bottom over the previous weeks or months.

All wear neon-colored, star-shaped labels marked with the dates they’ve been siphoned during the aging process. They’re plugged with one of the most important pieces of equipment in the volunteer winemaker’s toolbox:  a clear, S-shaped airlock to allow carbon dioxide to escape while keeping out “dirty” oxygen and bacteria.

Advertise with us

“They used to use grapes, crush them and then let them sit and ferment in a hopper,” said Cafardi, 63.

Today, the grape juice comes in 6-gallon buckets, mostly from California in the fall (with some from Italy) and Chile in spring.

Two years ago, Cafardi might have sprinted from the elevator to this dimly lit space under the joists, eager to get started with what’s become his passion and made him a Strip District icon — creating the wine Penn Mac hands out to customers during the holidays.

But a stroke in June 2023 has slowed down the winemaker mightily; it’s still difficult to raise his right arm and he uses the electric wheelchair co-owners Dave and Ricky Sunseri gifted him during his rehab more often than he’d like.

“It’s in my right side and of course I’m right-handed,” he says ruefully.

Advertise with us

On a recent Saturday, however, he quickly switched to a cane once he got close to the carboys in this, his favorite corner of the world.

After the wine is done fermenting and aged for a year or two — and Cafardi deems it drinkable — it’s bottled so it can be carried upstairs in the weeks before Christmas. Cafardi and others dole it out in tiny cupfuls to customers waiting in the Italian market’s (very long) line for cheese.

To know Cafardi is to also know this: He’s not just a great winemaker and beloved presence at Penn Mac (who’s never actually been on the payroll). He’s also one hell of a fighter.

“He’s too stubborn for that, to quit, ” says his son, Frank Cafardi III. “He’s got too much to do.”

Italian roots

Cafardi is hardly the first in his family to make wine at home. Both of his grandfathers, who immigrated to the U.S. from Gamberale in Italy’s Abruzzo region, kept wine presses in their basements and delighted in making vino the old-fashioned way.

Advertise with us

The youngest of four children growing up in Brookline, “Joe,” as close family called him because there were too many Franks in neighborhood, witnessed the process time and again.

He also drank the fruits of their labor. One time when he was maybe 10 or 11, he was dispatched to his grandfather’s cellar to refill a carafe.

“And that’s where they found me,” he recalls, laughing. “I couldn’t even walk!”

What his grandfathers made depended on the fruit they got in. His paternal grandpa, Henrico, was especially fond of Concord and muscat grapes, “which he turned into ‘dago red’,” says Cafardi with a chuckle, referring to homemade Italian wine made from a blend of dark red wine grapes.

His father, Frank Sr., who made “all kinds” of wines, preferred ruby cabernet, a dry, medium-bodied red wine that was popular in the 1960s.

Advertise with us

Each year, the men would start fermenting grape juice in late September and drink the wine by Christmas, “which is the wrong way,” Cafardi says, shaking his head. “But they couldn’t wait to tap that barrel,” even if the wine inside wasn’t particularly good.

“It was a family tradition,” agreed his sister, Julie Cafardi of Brookline.

Married at 19 and a father a few years later, Cafardi  — who became a mechanic after graduating from Brashear High School in 1979 — made wine on his own throughout his 20s. But he didn’t get serious about it until more than a decade later, when he and a group of friends decided to learn to make wine “in the old way” of their Italian ancestors.

Drinking coffee one morning in the early ’90s at the former Fortunes Coffee (now Allegheny Coffee & Tea Exchange), Cafardi asked the guy behind the counter when grapes were coming in. “And he said, ‘Don’t ask me, ask that guy,’” he recalls.

The man he pointed to told Cafardi to be there the next morning, and when he showed up just after dawn, “we drove to McKeesport,” where they started making wine in a warehouse. Eventually the group of amateur winemakers grew to include seven men.

Advertise with us

“We didn’t know much as a whole, but we learned,” Cafardi says.

In 2001, he was again drinking coffee at Fortunes with some buddies that included long-time Penn Mac cheesemonger Adam Ehrlichman, who had made wine with the group a couple of times before.

“Somehow my name came up” in a discussion about the wine made in the basement to give away to Penn Mac shoppers between Thanksgiving and Christmas.

“And Dave [Sunseri] said if I wanted to [make it] here, I could,” Cafardi recalls.

He did, and soon changed the process so the wine could age significantly longer than the technically drinkable but way too young wines his Italian nonnos enjoyed.

Advertise with us

Today, with Cafardi on hand to offer advice, Penn Mac sells anywhere from 200 to 800 buckets each year, says manager Greg Tenaglia. Muscat, sauvignon blanc  and white zinfandel are the most popular choices, though they also sell a lot of ruby cabernet and Sangiovese, Italy’s most planted grape variety.

Customers love him because “he [pays] a lot of attention to detail, and how things are traditionally made,” says Ehrlichman. “He’s helpful and happy to share.”

Stubborn wins

Cafardi was in bed when he suddenly didn’t feel so good on June 25, 2023.

Not only was he having trouble breathing, his girlfriend Debbie Cumberledge recalls, but he also had trouble walking as he stumbled toward the door, dropping the glass of water he was carrying in the sink. She immediately called 911 and minutes later an ambulance was rushing him to Allegheny General Hospital, where he was diagnosed with a massive stroke. Cafardi spent the next six weeks there, including four in intensive care.

“He was on a ventilator twice, and he also got pneumonia,” recalls his sister, Julie, tearing up at the memory. “They wanted to put him in a nursing home.”

Advertise with us

When family members told doctors they wanted him to go to rehab instead, “it was like, ‘Good luck with that!’” she adds. But they got their way, and he spent six weeks at a rehabilitation center in Sewickley after being discharged.

His doctors didn’t expect Cafardi to make much progress after such a serious stroke, notes Cumberledge. “But he had the determination to get better.”

Frank Cafardi III had “no doubts” his father would recover.

“He is stubborn like a honey badger, or maybe just a regular badger or wolverine,” he says. “When he has his mind made up about something, nothing is going to stop him.”

Cafardi agrees his iron resolve fueled his grueling rehab, which is still ongoing. He has had to relearn how to walk, talk “and all that fun stuff” — extremely difficult for someone who was always so busy working, hunting or fishing that he was never home.

Advertise with us

When he woke up in the hospital, “I really didn’t know what was happening,” he says. “But I have determination.”

The thick stack of cards, flowers and countless prayers he got from well-wishers and Penn Mac employees certainly helped.

Manager Gregg “Fatty” Livengood was at the hospital just about every day, he says, and David and Ricky Sunseri gifted him the battery-operated wheelchair he still sometimes uses. But it wasn’t until he was back in Penn Mac’s cellar in April 2024 that he really felt better.

“It was just good to see everybody,” he says. “I couldn’t wait to get back.”

He was slow, and reluctantly had to accept help. It came not just from his son, a millwright at U.S. Steel, but from friends and fellow winemakers like Mark Stulga of Fox Chapel, who works at Penn Mac during the holidays, and Dana Stephens of Penn Hills, whom he met standing in line at Allegheny Coffee.

Advertise with us

Cafardi is admittedly cranky about having partners. “You get people to help you and they want you to do it their way, but I’m doing it the right way. I’ve done really well so far.”

“You don’t want to be on the opposite side of Frank if things don’t get done right,” agrees Frank III.

Eighteen months later, “it’s still hard” to rely on assistants, Cafardi says, but at least his leg is regaining strength and he only occasionally has to use the wheelchair.

He’s even resumed another Italian culinary tradition dear to his heart: teaching wanna-be charcutiers how to make prosciutto at the American Italian Club in Aliquippa. The next class begins in January.

The winemaker’s process

While making good, drinkable wine isn’t as difficult as you might think, there is definitely a science to it. The key is quality ingredients, clean equipment, attention to detail and perhaps most important of all, patience.

Advertise with us

That’s because wine is made “when it wants to be made,” Cafardi says, and not according to a rigid schedule.

The first step after hauling the buckets of juice into the basement is making sure all equipment — including the winemaker’s hands — is clean and sterilized prior to use.

The next step is “pitching the yeast” — dissolving yeast in warm water, adding it to the grape juice and stirring it up “real good” to initiate the fermentation process.

“It’s kind of like making bread,” says Frank III.

Almost immediately there is visible, sparkly activity as bubbles and foam appear on top of the liquid.

Advertise with us

Next, he measures and records the specific gravity (density) of the juice with a hydrometer to establish whether it has the right amount of sugar to ferment and produce an alcohol content appropriate to style.

Since sugar is heavier than water, the higher the hydrometer floats, the more sugar there is in the batch. It will float highest at the beginning of the process and lowest at the end, when most of the sugar has been converted to alcohol.

Frank III spins the thin glass tube as it goes into the liquid, and it quickly bobs up and down. After taking a reading and jotting it down in his father’s recipe book — it’s 1.000, or potentially 10% alcohol — he puts the lid back on to prevent oxidation.

“The yeast is very active during this time, and as such that’s when they produce the most carbon dioxide,” says Frank III. “The CO2 creates enough of a buffer between the juice and the open air that contaminants are unable to take hold.”

Five or so days after the initial ferment, when the juice has reached 0.998-1.000 on the hydrometer, it’s racked, or transferred, into a sanitized 6-gallon carboy with a sanitized pump-style siphon and tubing at the top, and corked with an airlock. A pinch of sulfite goes into the carboy to make sure the wine does not spoil.

Advertise with us

Cafardi racks the wine once again to a new, sanitized carboy in another 6-8 weeks, and then the wine is aged for 6-9 months. A final hydrometer reading lets him calculate how much alcohol the wine contains.

Finally, he draws a sample from a long tube known as a wine thief to determine if the wine is drinkable.

“Before I got sick, I did all of this myself. No one helped me,” Cafardi says with a sigh, gesturing around the room.

“The cellar was definitely off-limits before he needed us,” notes his niece Thea Hampsay of Baldwin Township, who joins him upstairs later for a bit of sampling. “We just got the product on holidays!”

Cafardi estimates he’ll hand out “a whole bunch” of samples of his wine over the course of the holiday season. He keeps thousands of the 2-ounce plastic cups neatly stacked on a folding table in a back room near the grocery’s walk-in cooler.

Advertise with us

Depending on the day or hour, it could be a fruity Grenache, or maybe carmenere, a full-bodied wine made with Chilean grapes he feels is especially good this year.

“Whatever I’m feeling, and what’s two years old,” he says.

To say it’s a cherished tradition with customers is something of an understatement; a T-shirt sold at the store reads, “I survived the Penn Mac Cheese Line ... because of the wine.”

“Frank’s such a figure here, an icon,” says Stulga. “He’s engaging, very kind and thoughtful, and you can feel his gentleness reflected in the quality of his wine.”

“He is just the best, kindest person you can find,” says Livengood, who has worked at Penn Mac for almost 50 years. “Plus he’s so knowledgeable.”

Advertise with us

Many of the amateur winemakers who buy grape juice at Penn Mac aren’t willing to put in the care it takes to make good wine, says Cafardi. So when customers try his wine and love it, “it is an accomplishment.”

“You gotta keep going or die,” he says. “I’m still here. I’ve done it so long, and I like that people drink it.”