“Zehn, neun, acht, sieben …”
A countdown in German preceded the traditional tapping of the Oktoberfest keg at Penn Brewery late last month.
Owner Stefan Nitsch’s 7-year-old daughter, Elin, dressed in a peach T-shirt and denim shorts, cartwheeled across the floor during a Polkamaniacs set.
When the band took a break, Nitsch, tattooed and in a black T-shirt, faux lederhosen and a backward-turned Penn Brewery trucker hat, grabbed the mic. After apologizing for late-arriving food at the special event, he growled, “Let’s hear it for free beer!”
In a conversation a few days later at the North Side brewery, Nitsch admitted that while emceeing activities that opening Oktoberfest weekend, he partook of the free beer at his establishment. Just a little bit, he indicated with a thumb and forefinger.
He was told, he said, that he scarfed a snack of uncooked frozen pierogies amid the merrymaking — of which he had no recollection. The brewery’s Oktoberfest celebration continues through a family-friendly day Sunday, Oct. 6, with free carriage rides, face painting and balloon animals.
Read More
Being a fan of beer, and its ties to his Austrian heritage, is perhaps a leading reason Nitsch decided to purchase the historic brewery in 2022 from Sandy Cindrich, Corey Little and Linda Nyman. The site dates back to the Eberhardt and Ober Brewery, founded in 1848.
The owner of Arkham Realty, Nitsch became a tenant in the brewery’s mammoth brick complex after earning his broker’s license in 2017. Early on, he remembers pitching the owners: “Hey, if you guys ever want to sell, let me know.”
For Nitsch, this was not just any old real estate acquisition. The draw, he said, was “just being a part of this rich heritage and this being the OG of craft brewing here in Pittsburgh, and then just being in love with the beer.”
Since he was a tenant of the building, he came down often for lunch and dinner, and got to know the staff.
“Even before I was a tenant here,” he said, “I would always stop here at the end of the day and get a growler of Kaiser [Pils]. That’s the most authentic German-Austrian tasting beer that I've ever had here in the States.”
‘A true German lager’
He would know. Nitsch spent early childhood in the small Tyrolean town of Jenbach, before his parents’ divorce, then moved to Switzerland with his mother. At the age of 10, he joined his father, who was working as a plant manager at Oakmont’s Chelsea Building Products.
Growing up in Forest Hills, where he went by “Steve” rather than the foreign-sounding “Stefan,” he hazily recalls an occasion when his father brought him to Penn Brewery as a boy.
His father instilled Austrian culture in him mainly through his cooking.
“Every night there was either a wiener schnitzel or a goulash or dumplings or something traditional,” he recalled.
For Christmas it was schweinebraten (pork roast) or zwiebelrostbraten (roast beef topped with gravy and crisp, fried onions). Both goulash and schweinebraten are on the Penn Brewery menu.
Nitsch made frequent trips back to Europe, holding on to his Austrian cultural ties. In 2017, he attended his first German Oktoberfest, in Munich, with a childhood friend from Jenbach.
Penn Brewery also makes a point to hold fast to the traditions of German beer making. It goes through the cumbersome process of importing the malt and hops for its German-style beers directly from Germany, head brewer Chris Rudolph explained.
“You want a genuine German product to make a genuine German beer,” Rudolph said. “You’ll definitely see quality differences” compared to domestic malt and hops. Some products, such as dark roasted malts used to make the brewery’s Penn Dark and the seasonal St. Nikolaus Bock, are unavailable in the U.S.
The brewery also employs copper kettles to brew its beer rather than more modern stainless steel. Though it no longer uses them, the brewery even has lagering (or storage) caves that naturally remain a steady 55 degrees, ideal for creating lagers, which are stored for a month or sometimes much longer. (Today, the brewery uses modern refrigeration.)
Many beers we think of as American, a run-of-the-mill Budweiser, for example, are American-style lagers. But while modern breweries might rush the lagering process, “a true German lager,” according to Rudolph, requires time and patience.
Lagers need to “mature, age, clarify, crisp,” he said. “They just become better over time.”
Chocolate-peanut butter?
While Penn Brewery goes to great lengths to honor its heritage, it is also creating a raft of new beers.
Under community liaison Amy Huseman, the brewery has established creative partnerships with local businesses, like Kennywood amusement park (with which it created a strawberry funnel cake beer), Soergel Orchards (pumpkin shandy) and even an oyster-inspired stout with the Strip District’s Penn Avenue Fish Company.
“One of our very first collaborations was when we worked with Oakmont Bakery,” Rudolph recalled.
The bakery wanted to make a beer inspired by its seasonal filled Polish doughnut, paczki.
“I said the only real way I know how to make a beer based upon a doughnut is to throw the doughnut right into the mash,” Rudolph said. So that’s what he did — 50 pounds of them for a small batch.
An upcoming Sarris Candies partnership will produce a chocolate-peanut butter beer.
“We hope to have it out by Valentine’s Day,” Huseman said.
But before then, save the date: Dec. 6 marks the tapping of the keg, or firkin, for Penn Brewery’s seasonal St. Nikolaus Bock. Wintertime is also the moment to seek out the award-winning St. Nikolaus Brewers’ Reserve, a 9% alcohol, heavier version of the St. Nikolaus Bock (6% ABV).
But as for owner Nitsch, he’ll always hold a special place in his heart for the Kaiser Pils, which he said continually wows Germans and Austrians who come to the brewery.
“That just happened the other day,” Nitsch said. “There were some people from Düsseldorf that we met at the Steelers game that we brought back over here. They were just losing their minds over the beer.”
Pork Wings
PG tested
Even though they’re not considered a specialty item, pork shanks — a cut of meat from a pig’s foreleg, just below the shoulder — aren’t always in the meat case even in larger stores, at least in Northern New Jersey, where I tested this recipe. After several phone calls, I finally found them in a whole-animal butcher shop, where a worker cut them to size.
I added a little more horseradish to the bier sauce for extra zing. Leftover are great as a pretzel dip.
— Gretchen McKay
For pork
Pinch of kosher salt
Pinch of sugar
1 12-ounce bottle Penn Dark beer
8 4-ounce pork shanks
¾ cup oil
1 onion, diced
2 celery stalks, chopped
1 carrot, chopped
3 cups chicken stock
3 cups Penn Gold beer
5 parsley stems
2 thyme sprigs
2 tablespoons chilled butter
For bier cheese
1 pound super sharp cheddar cheese
4 ounces cream cheese
½ teaspoon kosher salt
½ teaspoon prepared horseradish
1 teaspoon minced garlic
¼ cup Penn Pilsner
Mashed potatoes, for serving
Prepare pork. Mix salt, sugar and Penn Dark beer in a bowl, then place in a non-reactive container (such as plastic). Add pork, and toss to combine. Refrigerate for 24 hours.
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Add a little oil to a large oven-proof pan. Add onion, celery and carrot and saute until onion is translucent. Drain brine from pork. Discard brine. Add pork to pan with vegetables. Add chicken stock, Penn Gold beer, parsley and thyme. Cover with foil. Roast for 1 hour 15 minutes.
While pork is roasting, prepare bier cheese. Grate the cheddar cheese on a box grater, then add to bowl with cream cheese. Mix on medium speed until well blended. (I used a hand whisk.)
Add salt, horseradish and garlic to bowl, followed by the beer. Mix until smooth, then set aside. (Note: More or less beer may be added depending on the consistency that you want.) Keep warm on stove.
Remove pork and carrots from pan. Strain the liquid into a saucepan, and cook over medium heat until liquid reduces to 1½ cups. Add chilled butter, and as it melts, stir to combine.
Mix 1 cup of bier cheese to 2 pounds of mashed potatoes.
Place pork shanks and carrots on a plate. Top pork with sauce and serve with bier cheese potatoes.
Serves 4.
— Penn Brewery






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.