Stefan Nitsch saw opportunity in the old North Side brewery — and though he lacked experience running such a business, he “dove right in.”
“I’ve always realized the potential in this place,” Mr. Nitsch said of Troy Hill-based Penn Brewery, which he bought in 2022. “And the most important part was already in place, which was the amazing people that work here.”
Mr. Nitsch is among those who have taken the leap from employee to leadership or ownership status. Perseverance and the ability to adapt are crucial characteristics for those making such a move, Mr. Nitsch and others said.
“It was a huge learning curve because I’ve never really done anything like this,” he said. “You have to be able to adapt to everything. That’s huge — just being able to pivot.”
Mr. Nitsch moved to Pittsburgh from Austria when he was 10. He spent his first Oktoberfest in the brewery’s biergarten with his dad. He worked in real estate in offices upstairs from the restaurant, and for years joked with the owners about buying them out. After long work days, he would come down for a growler of Kaiser, the most authentic German beer he’s ever had in the U.S.
“I would sit here and have my Kaiser and it would take me back home,” he said.
Mr. Nitsch has always been an entrepreneur, from childhood when he would collect chestnuts in Austria and sell them to park rangers. But Penn Brewery wasn’t his creation, which changed things, he said.
“If I'm doing a (house) flip, the first thing I do is get rid of the wood or paint to make it look more modern,” he said. “But in this case, there’s something you have to preserve. It’s traditional German beers. I wasn’t going to all of the sudden have all IPAs and sours, and the same thing goes with the aesthetics.”
That doesn’t stop him from coming up with ideas to grow the business, from selling beer by the can to starting a Thursday cigar night on the rooftop patio. Personal touch is important when stepping into a business, he said — some of the cans have his own artwork, including a skull whose teeth make up the Pittsburgh skyline.
“I kind of have this thing to a fault where I’m like, ‘Hey tomorrow we’re doing this,’ and everyone’s like, ‘What?’” he said. “It really is just me coming up with some harebrained idea and then executing it.”
‘It’s part of our family’
For some, stepping into business leadership is a family affair.
Aleen Atencio remembers coming to work with her dad, helping him bake and sneaking small bites of hot bread. Now, Ms. Atencio is the human resources and finance manager at Pitaland, a Brookline-based Mediterranean bakery and market. Her father, Youssef Zaidan “Joe” Chahine, passed away in May, leaving the business to Ms. Atencio and her three siblings.
“We never expected that all four of us would be here,” she said, yet each sibling made their way back to the bakery after separate careers.
Ms. Atencio’s mother owns Pitaland, but the siblings run it. Pitaland has long been a welcoming location for Middle Eastern immigrants in Pittsburgh, Ms. Atencio said, connecting newcomers with county agencies, schools and housing.
“My dad loved talking to people about their background and helping them, because he was helped by so many when he came here in the 70s,” she said. “We know how important that is to my parents, and we will continue to do that. That will never change.”
Though her father’s death was sudden, the transition felt organic.
“It was, ‘This is what needs to be done, all hands on deck.’ That’s what happens with a family business,” she said.
When stepping into a leadership role, Ms. Atencio said, it’s important to ask questions and learn from the people who have been there.
“Think about how decisions will be made and what your role is going to be, so that you can avoid conflict,” she said. “Put on a hat of, we’re not related, we’re working together, and this is what’s best for the business.”
‘Truly fell in love with it’
Pitaland has found a new home for the company’s products at Giant Eagle, the Cranberry-based grocer founded in 1931.
Paul Abbott, the senior director of the Market District segment of the company that offers an array of specialty foods, has worked 34 years with Giant Eagle, starting with a summer job as a customer service clerk when he was 16. He’s one of many employees who have worked their way up to leadership positions after spending years learning the ins and outs of their company.
“I would never trade the experience I had to get to a leadership role faster,” he said. “It’s an invaluable experience to really learn in front of the customer, eyeball to eyeball every day, so you can really understand what they need and expect ... It went from just a paycheck to pay for gasoline to (being) so meaningful.”
His first higher level position was a night manager backup, a role that sparked his desire to make Giant Eagle a lifelong career.
“I took that job so seriously that it really made me excited,” he said. “Just taking care of customers and knowing how important it is to the community.”
Having been a low-level employee first helps Mr. Abbott to make decisions in leadership, particularly in a “customer-centric” company, he said.
“It’s a hard thing to learn without a little bit of real life experience,” he said. “You can certainly learn it, but it’s a lot easier if you’ve been around and seen it.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.