On Main Street in Sharpsburg, Love, Katie Distilling is black and white — an intentional void of color on both the inside and out.
Its simplicity and grayscale, says owner Katie Sirianni, are integral to the distillery’s purpose: to provide a space where love of all kinds can be the color in the room.
Customers, who Sirianni and staff call “family,” are met with a choice of fluffy chairs, couches and high-top tables, as well as an expansive drink menu featuring over 30 cocktails. Mid- to late-20th century music hits the speakers, and scenes from black-and-white movies project onto the wall.
“It’s black and white to not distract your eyes from something that’s fun and colorful. Everything’s just really so basic that it speaks volumes,” Sirianni said. “And so the idea is it’s my love letter to Jen [Procacina], and let it be your love letter. So it’s meant for whoever you come in with to share it as your love letter together.”
Where it began
In 2020, after leaving a decadelong career in health care followed by some time working in car sales, the Fox Chapel native, now 37, said it was time for a change.
Sirianni, who is a lesbian, began making and selling T-shirts and masks locally during the COVID-19 pandemic. By 2021, she was also selling Pride merchandise at the Steel City Craft Emporium’s Pride Art Weekend in the Strip District, where she met fellow vendor Heather LaPaglia, who ran her own art pop-up out of a horse trailer. Sirianni decided she wanted a brick-and-mortar setup for her T-shirt business, too.
A week later, she drove across the state, bought her own horse trailer and partnered with LaPaglia on a new business: Sips Mobile Bar Co.
Six months later, Sirianni bought out LaPaglia’s half of the business and began running it with help from her cousin, Brian Zalewski, setting up the mobile bar at distilleries. At the end of 2022, at a friend’s suggestion, she sold the mobile bar, bought a still for the distilling process and by St. Patrick’s Day last year, had the keys to her current location in hand.

“Nothing is ever just like, ‘We gotta think about it,’” Sirianni said. “I gotta jump in with two feet without testing the water with everything that I do.”
After doing nearly a full remodel of the space in just 48 hours with the help of Zalewski, Sirianni held a soft opening with family and friends on International Pride Day, June 28.
She opened the doors to Love, Katie Distilling to the public on Sept. 9, which she says is the first and only LGBTQ+-owned distillery in Pennsylvania.
More than anything, Sirianni says it is an “honor and a privilege” to say that she is a gay owner of a distillery.
“There’s always that fear in the back of your head, like, ‘Is this going to be a problem?’ Which, you know, is also just another reason why I keep [the design] in this respect: because I want it to be about love in all of its forms.”
Its name represents the sign-off of a love letter, just like the one Sirianni has dedicated to her fiancée, Procacina, on the back of the bottles she sells at the distillery.
“But it can be to whoever you want,” she said.

‘Showing ourselves what we’re made of’
Without any experience in the alcohol or distilling industries, Sirianni sought assistance from Zalewski, who had spent the last five years as a training center captain for Aldi employees across about 36 stores in a 30-mile radius.
Both said the opening of the distillery came at a time when they were looking for something new, offering a chance to start fresh and bond over personal struggles.
“We’re showing ourselves what we’re made of,” said Zalewski, 36, a “Swiss Army knife” adept in everything from maintenance to bartending.
“I want to show myself what I’m made of, and Katie’s doing the same for herself.”
Bartender Katie Meyers also has made Love, Katie Distilling a safe space to bond over a cocktail.
The 33-year-old didn’t have any experience in serving drinks when she exited an 11½-year career in healthcare and answered Zalewski’s call on social in summer 2023. The call asked if anyone wanted to come and help clean up the space before their opening; she’s been there ever since.
“I have met so many wonderful friends and new family, which has been super awesome,” Meyers said.
“People come in to check it out — might be interesting to check out the drinks and everything — and they come back for the friendships,” Zalewski agreed.
Brett Say, 41, of Sharpsburg said he stumbled upon the distillery while it was under construction. Once it opened, he came in to see what it was all about — and kept coming back.
“It’s nice to have that unique kind of small business community here in Sharpsburg that really kind of represents a welcoming nature of inclusivity and has good drinks and takes pride in creating something new,” Say said.
Curating cocktails
When Love, Katie Distilling opened nearly a year ago, the menu featured around eight drinks. Now, guests can choose from more than 30 cocktails and seasonal specials, with almost all of them containing a house-stilled liquor (vodka, rum or gin).

Despite being new to the distilling and bartending processes, each person’s strength has made for a great menu of mixed drink offerings, said Zalewski, a self-proclaimed safe and responsible “seasoned drinker.”
“We’ve enjoyed every aspect of learning about it, and everyone here is very particular to where we're not going to put out something bad,” he said.
As a “big flavor person,” Sirianni said the process of curating drinks that everyone could enjoy hasn’t necessarily been about bartending, but about finding flavors that work together.
“We all have a different palate, so when we can create a drink that we all like, we’re like, ‘This will cater to everybody,’ which is the ultimate goal.”
Together, the pair learned the process with help from other local Pittsburgh distillers, who Sirianni said have been incredibly supportive of her new business.
As a member of the LGBTQIA+ community, Sirianni wants to make sure that she is looking out for other folks in the community, too. One way she has done this already is through hosting drag race trivia. An outdoor green space is also in the works.
Procacina, Sirianni’s fiancée, said it has been amazing to watch the business blossom. “Nothing she does surprises me.”
Though the theme of love and the name come from Sirianni and Procacina’s relationship, it also was inspired by the deep love her grandparents had for each other.
At her grandmother’s funeral, Sirianni saw a black-and-white photo of the couple sitting together at a club — she with a cigarette and he with a drink in hand. Sirianni decided to frame the photo and hang it up in the distillery’s bathroom as part of the decor.
“I was like, ‘I always want to find love like that,’ and I truly felt like I found it with Jen. So I wanted to bring a space together that took the pressure off of love, whether it be with your friends, your family, your love life, and just kind of make it about love.”
One year since opening, Zalewski said they have met their goals.
“I think as far as spreading the love, we’ve done exactly just that — through the space itself, through our staff, our personalities, through the cocktails or the spirits themselves and stories that we like to tell all along the way.”

Allie Miller is a Pittsburgh-based freelance writer.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.