Spill the Wine Bar is part of a new way to try, learn about and buy wine in Pennsylvania, but it was inspired by the Old Country. It’s a story with some romance and passion and a setting that’s going to be busy this Valentine’s Day weekend.

On vacations to Italy, sweethearts for 40 years Jim and Robin Sattler went to wine shops where they didn’t have to pick bottles based on the prettiness of the labels or the price. The proprietors would pour them tastes and talk about different wines until the couple found one they loved enough to buy a case and pay to have it shipped back to the States.

That try-before-you-buy concept was something lacking for most consumers in Pennsylvania, who buy most of their wine for home off the racks and shelves of state stores. But as the state’s liquor laws have loosened, other options have opened up. For example, wineries started licensing satellite locations here. The first out-of-country winery to do so was Collefisio from Abruzzo, Italy, which opened the Wine Bar in Downtown’s Market Street Grocery in April 2015. Customers can buy a bottle to go or drink a glass with a charcuterie plate — nothing remarkable in Europe, but groundbreaking for Downtown. That store happens to be run by Mr. Sattler’s sister and brother-in-law, Mimi and Ron Falbo, a well-known developer.

Mr. Sattler, done with his career as an operations guy for businesses ranging from cleaning to trucking in various cities, did his research and planned to open, with Mr. Falbo, a similar wine shop in Lawrenceville, but that deal fell through. While having lunch at Lombardozzi’s in Bloomfield, Mr. Sattler noticed the empty corner storefront across the street. A lot of renovation work later, the Sattlers opened their wine store in the heart of Little Italy in April 2019.

Advertise with us

Almost a year later, “I don’t know why it’s been successful, I just know it’s been successful,” Mr. Sattler says from his post behind the bar on a recent night. Historic photos of the neighborhood are part of the bar in the back of the cozy 1,200-square-foot space, which has seating and tables for about two dozen.

The front has shelves holding 42 different wines from three wineries in three region’s of Italy: the aforementioned Collefrisio, Danimi in Campagna and Conte d’Attimis-Maniago in Fruili. These are small wineries that aren’t distributed by the state stores that a local importer brings in for Spill.

The store used to also carry an Australian line but dropped those. Mr. Sattler may add another winery or two, and maybe from a country other than Italy, but he believes 100 wines will be enough to please both palates.

The couple (living in Forest Hills until they move to Bloomfield) and their three employees aim to do that by talking with customers and guiding them through their offerings. Once they know if a customer wants a bottle to go or a glass to drink there, they ask about their wine preference: Do they prefer light, medium or full-bodied wine? Do they like a long finish (perhaps fruity) or a short finish (dry)? Customers are welcome to taste as many different wines as they like, then buy what they want, or not. Prices range from $14 to $61 a bottle and $6 to $16 a glass.

They Sattlers prefer the description of wine shop — “That’s how we’re regulated by the state” — with a tasting room over “wine bar,” having decided to not compete with all the neighboring restaurants by serving their own food. But soon after opening, one customer came in for advice on what wines to buy for a big dinner party at his house. Mr. Sattler invited the man to bring the group of 10 and the big Italian spread into Spill, where everyone could try wines paired with each course.

Advertise with us

Bring-your-own-food is completely legal and has caught on here. Mrs. Sattler curates a collection of neighborhood menus, from Italian to Thai. One regular brings in a Subway sandwich, which he pairs with their most expensive glass, because, as he put it, “I got a budget for lunch.”

The Sattlers promise no pretension, which is certainly a big part of the appeal of this place that he describes as “a neat little destination” — a third place people can linger before they go home. They’ve already hosted birthday parties, work events, book clubs and more, and Mr. Sattler says, “We’re 100 percent for proposals,” in that a surprised resident from West Penn Hospital said yes (even if she had to be prompted by her mother).

The ‘Burgh Bits and Bites food tour has made Spill its last stop in the neighborhood, so folks can linger over wine with a snack from Merante’s. Says guide Richard Domencic, “This is simply a great new business to visit.”

***

That’s the same neighborhood-gathering-place vibe offered by a similar new space that opened this past summer in the 2300 block of Carson Street in the South Side cleverly called 23rd & Vine. Here, too, you can try, savor a glass or walk out with bottles and cases of wines not otherwise available in Pittsburgh. Currently, that’s five labels of California and Italian wines including some from the Smokey Robinson Collection. The Motown legend started that wine venture with local wine fans Bob Buzzelli and Louis Caputo, the latter being the liquor attorney who got the license for the Italian winery to open in Market Street Grocery.

Advertise with us

“It’s a different, change of pace thing,” says Mr. Caputo, who notes the shop isn’t limited by how many wineries can use it as a satellite location. A winery can have up to five satellites, and can purchase another license to have more.

Mr. Caputo says those licenses also allow 23rd & Vine to sell Pennsylvania beers and spirits and other food products, all things that are in the works for later this year.

***

Saturday Feb. 22 is the second soft opening of another new business offering tastings, glasses and bottles of wine — this one in Homestead. The Forge is a partnership between R** Bandana winery in Leeper and Wines of America winery in Braddock. You can try and buy a wide range of their wines with some snacks and fondue and, that Saturday, if you get one of 90 tickets, listen to live jazz by Jessica Lee and Mark Strickland. A grand opening is next for this big venue. Wines of America will be making wine on site, as well. The place started offering tastings and bottle sales last year and held its first soft opening on Feb. 1. Customers are invited to bring photos of veterans (Wines of America’s Michael Lisovich is one) and first responders — marked with name, date of birth and service dates — displayed on a 25-feet-long “Boulevard of Heroes” wall.

They also will be welcome to go upstairs and have wine or coffee at sister business Steel Valley Roasters coffee shop (at 207 E. 8th Ave.), where they’ll be “experimenting with coffee and wine drinks,” says Mr. Lisovich. “It’s actually popular out in California,” which is one of the places he owns vineyard acreage. We’ll visit once the Forge gets fired up.

Advertise with us

Spill is located at 4800 Liberty Ave., Pittsburgh, Pa. 15224. It’s open 2 to 10 p.m. Mon.-Tues., 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. Weds.-Sat. and 1 to 9 p.m. Sun. For more information, call 412-888-9398 or visit http://spillthewinebar.com.

23rd & Vine is located at 2333 East Carson St., Pittsburgh, Pa. 15203. It’s open 4 to 10 p.m. Tues.-Thurs., 4 to 11 p.m. Sat. and noon to 11 p.m. Sun. Call 412-235-7447 or visit http://23rdandvine.com.

The wine shop Market Street Grocery is located at 435 Market St., Pittsburgh Pa. 15222 (with another entrance on Graeme Street). It’s open 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. Mon.-Sat. and 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Visit www.marketstreetgrocery.com.

The Forge wine bar is located at 210 E. 7th Ave., Homestead, Pa. 15120 and is to be open from 4 p.m. to midnight daily and for special events (on Facebook and 202-805-0918).

You can buy wine at state stores, wine bars/restaurants (such as 8th & Hays Wine Bar & Brick Oven, also in Homestead) and wineries, such as Giant Oaks Winery, which on Feb. 8 opened a tasting room in Finleyville, and R Wine Cellar’s new Cellar on Penn location in the Strip District. Other newer alternative places to buy wine include Mary’s Vine, which opened in a Rankin church last year, and Refucilo Winery, a satellite of an Argentinian winery that opened on the North Side at the end of 2018.

Advertise with us

And more are on the way. Mr. Sattler says he plans to open wine shops with tasting rooms in other neighborhoods.

Bob Batz Jr.: bbatz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1930 and on Twitter @bobbatzjr.