The year began with an early string of losses.

Among them, the shuttering of Oak Hill Post landed hardest. Christian Schulz and Rebecca Nicholson’s Brookline restaurant became a favorite for thoughtfully prepared takeout during the COVID-19 pandemic, then a popular breakfast and lunch destination at its peak and, briefly, a grand-slam dinner spot in the second half of 2024.

In the end, limited seating and the lack of a liquor license led the couple to wind down the operation. It continued as a takeout business until mid-March.

PileZ was a short-lived experiment in a contactless future, where food was ordered and retrieved without human interaction (genuine human cooks were still at work in the kitchen).

Advertise with us

PileZ felt distancing and jarringly sterile inside the former home of the original Mad Mex in Oakland, long a nexus of merrymaking and a foundational spot for many who would go on to be today’s leaders of Pittsburgh hospitality. Still, it delivered solid food at all hours of the night, something Pittsburgh could use more of.

Bae Bae’s Kitchen, Downtown, closed in January, only to reopen a few weeks later as a late-night spot. The idea was strong, but it failed to gain traction and closed again a few months later, reinforcing the city’s ongoing difficulty sustaining post-10 p.m. dining. Its sister restaurant, Bae Bae’s Cafe, closed in late November.

Etna Slice House ended a far too short run after head chef and manager Massimo Vozza parted ways with ownership when the sides failed to reach a new contract agreement.

The closure marked the loss of one of the region’s most promising young pizza operations. Vozza’s a talented pizzaiolo, so I hope this venture will not be his last.

Chris and Jennifer Bonfili opened Bonfire on East Carson Street in 2018 as a follow-up to Avenue B, their much-loved restaurant on the border of Friendship and Shadyside, which operated from 2009 to 2018. Bonfili said he chose not to renew Bonfire’s lease on the South Side after reassessing how he wanted to spend his time following the death of his father in 2024.

Advertise with us

Another South Side staple, Michael’s Pizza Bar, closed at the end of March. Michael and Dee Glowacki opened the Sarah Street pizzeria and bar in the 1980s. Bar Marco co-founder Kevin Cox and his sister, Mary Cox, purchased the business in early 2020. No reason was given for the closing.

June brought the loss of two local franchise outposts and another longtime South Side institution.

Meadville-based Voodoo Brewing Co. ended its Pittsburgh presence when its North Shore location closed early in the month, capping a three-year run.

The brewery, which continues to operate pubs in Erie, State College and Meadville, has rapidly expanded its franchise footprint in recent years, with Pennsylvania locations in New Kensington, Seven Fields, Washington County and Scranton, along with outposts in Ohio, Maryland, Kentucky, Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, Florida, Texas, Colorado, Idaho and Nevada.

The Primanti Bros. location on Penn Avenue in Garfield closed abruptly at the start of June after an eight-year run on the edge of the East End business district. A company spokesperson told the Post-Gazette that ownership decided not to renew the lease. Founded in 1933, Primanti Bros. now operates more than 40 company-owned and franchise locations in the region and in Florida.

Advertise with us

Nakama Japanese Steakhouse and Sushi Bar also closed at the start of June after more than 22 years on East Carson Street. Long known for teppanyaki, high-volume sushi and a raucous bar scene, its sudden closure, along with the 23-year-old Smiling Moose, underscored a rough first half of 2025 for the South Side business district.

Sometime during the summer, Nothingman in Bloomfield fade, faded away after operating for less than a year on Liberty Avenue. Troy Beck and Katie Peric’s neighborhood pub never found its footsteps, but the pair continue to operate the excellent Given to Fly in Federal Galley.

Raymond Mikesell, owner of Cafe Raymond in the Strip District until 2024, took over the Wild Rosemary space in Upper St. Clair, previously operated by Gloria Fortunato, who opened the restaurant with Lynne Bielewicz and Cathleen Enders in 2008. The effort was intended to reignite the intimate dining room, but shortly after reopening, Mikesell and his family navigated unspeakable tragedy with the death of his son.

“The truth is, it has been incredibly hard to carry on while grieving, and we know in our hearts it is time to step away,” Mikesell wrote on social media in late September.

Pittsburgh’s diner culture suffered a blow in October when Barb’s Corner Kitchen, known until 2010 as Barb’s Country Kitchen, ended a nearly 40-year run.

Advertise with us

Owner Bob Geraci decided to sell the Lawrenceville building following a confluence of events, including the death of his mother and original owner Patricia Geraci early in the year, shifting neighborhood needs and rising costs “on just about everything.”

The year ended as it started, with more difficult news for both legacy institutions and rather new restaurants.

Grant Bar, one of the region’s most historic establishments, closed after 90 years marked by repeated reinvention and resilience, including recovery from a devastating flood in 2004. Rising food costs, particularly the price of lettuce, ultimately proved insurmountable for the Millvale institution long celebrated for its scratch-made pies.

“It just boils down to money n’at. Everything is so high. Before we went into debt or anything, it was just easier to close it up and call it a day,” said co-owner Joe Roethlein.

Eat’n Park shuttered a 46-year-old location on the southbound side of McKnight Road in Ross. The nearby Eat’n Park at 7370 McKnight Road, open for 69 years, will remain in operation.

Advertise with us

Vietnam 9 Vietnam closed in mid-November after a short but compelling run in South Oakland. The owners are searching for a new location.

Carleen and Michael King closed their final Carmi location with the December shuttering of Carmi Express.

The couple debuted as the Catering Kings in 2009 and opened Carmi Soul Food on Western Avenue in Allegheny West in 2011. They relocated the restaurant to a larger East Carson Street space in 2018, and closed it in 2024, leaving Carmi Express, opened in 2020 on the North Side, as the center of operations. The Kings plan to continue their catering business.

The year ends with the departure of a Squirrel Hill staple, Murray Avenue Grill, slated to close Dec. 28 following a 39-year run.

“As we conclude this chapter, we do so with deep appreciation for the countless memories, friendships, and experiences shared over nearly four decades,” its ownership said on a social media post.

“Though the business is coming to a close, the legacy of these years will remain with us always.”