When you think of pickles, you might not normally associate them with cupcakes, or vice versa. But Patti Schvabenitz, proprietor of Patti’s Pastries, has found the right recipe.

An eight-year participant in Picklesburgh, Schvabenitz’s Dill Dilly Dillicious cupcake has become a fan favorite. Enrobed in white chocolate, its vanilla cake has pickles in the batter, it’s stuffed with dill buttercream and each one is topped with whipped cream and a pickle slice.

It sounds improbable, but it works. It’s sweet (but not too sweet), and a little sour and salty (but not too much).

Schvabenitz admits that it might not be your go-to on a normal day.

Advertise with us

“But if you’re at Picklesburgh, you’re going to give it a shot,” the youthful 65-year-old said. “We sell out.”

To become a vendor at Picklesburgh, Schvabenitz explained, you must have at least three products that contain a fermented product. Her other two are a Maple Bourbon Bacon Pickle cupcake and Death by Chocolate, using a “secret” fermented ingredient.

All must pass her strict taste and quality standards, honed over decades working in the kitchen of her home in Center, Beaver County.

“It has to be something that my palate likes,” Schvabenitz said. “And I demand the best ingredients.”

Though her jumbo-size cupcakes may look tooth-achingly sweet, in fact they are light and not cloying.

Advertise with us

Her most recent creation, a Dubai Chocolate Pistachio Cream cupcake, took many trials to find the right balance of flavors, but she was finally satisfied.

“The consensus from customers so far is they love this,” she said.

If you aren’t ready to try a pickle cupcake, never fear. The signature bright pink Patti’s Pastries truck will be carrying 13 flavors.

Patti Schvabenitz stands next to her signature truck, which has become an anticipated sight at local festivals and events. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Easy-Bake to pro baker

Cupcakes are only the latest iteration of the long-standing business. To recall how old her business is, she had to think.

“My daughter is 45, so my business is 45 years old,” she said.

Advertise with us

When she became pregnant with her daughter — Nicole Morris, now a trusted bakery assistant — she was working for an attorney. She wanted to find a way to work while taking care of her new baby at home.

“I always loved to bake — and eat, of course,” she said. “So I told my husband I was going to quit my job and do scratch ethnic cookies.”

Her mother was Greek and her mother-in-law Italian.

“So we had all the recipes.”

She began baking cookies for special events and weddings.

Advertise with us

“Lady locks were our number one seller,” she said.

She still sells her mind-bendingly capacious versions of the rolled, cream-filled confections, as well as a “mini” model, which is by no means small.

As she shows a visitor around her kitchen-workshop in a former basement space, she simultaneously takes a trip down memory lane. She still has her first pan, from a Kenner Easy-Bake oven that her parents bought her, stashed in a drawer.

Her paternal Slovak-Polish grandmother loved to bake. Schvabenitz displays her grandmother’s nut roll recipe, yellowed with age.

“I still have her cookbook,” she said, pulling old coupons and newspaper clippings from its leaves (3 pounds of peaches for 25 cents).

Advertise with us

In fact, it is from her father’s side of the family that she learned her love of cooking.

“My father actually taught my mother how to cook.”

Nicole Morris, left, and her mom, Patti’s Pastries owner Patti Schvabenitz, in their Center Township home workshop. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

A family affair

From such beginnings, it was a natural evolution that Schvabenitz would open her home-based business. Her husband, who was working in the declining steel industry at the time, would bring a list of cookies into the steel mill. The workers’ wives would order them, supporting the fledgling business.

Without ever having made a wedding cake, Schvabenitz began to cater weddings.

“I advertised that I could make wedding cakes before I knew how to make wedding cakes.”

Advertise with us

In the late ’90s, the business expanded to a storefront bakery-coffee shop in Aliquippa, which lasted a short three years.

“I’m a good baker,” she said. “I’m bad at the financial part.”

So she returned to her home commercial kitchen. In 2012, she decided to make cupcakes for an event and they were such a hit that she continued, to the point that they became the mainstay of her business.

She started taking her desserts on the road in 2014, setting up a tent, and inaugurating her trailer about three years later.

Through it all, she has leaned heavily on her family.

Advertise with us

“When we first started, our parents were the backbone,” she said.

Her father and father-in-law would help churn out cookies for hours. Her daughter and daughter-in-law, Michelle, currently help out in the kitchen. Michelle made her website and is in charge of social media. Her son, Nicholas, helped out with her online financial platform.

“Of course the key person in all of this is my husband, Daniel, who has been the strongest source of support,” Schvabenitz said of the man who introduces himself as “Mr. Patti.” He is also the official driver of the cupcake trailer.

“In order to have a successful business, you have to have family,” she said firmly.

The latest in her journey?

Advertise with us

“Patti's Pastries is honored to be accepted to participate in the 2026 NFL Draft Source Program,” she texted a reporter excitedly the other day.

The National Football League draft, which will take place in Pittsburgh next April, is expected to bring 500,000-700,000 visitors to Downtown, according to VisitPittsburgh.

But you don’t have to wait till next year to taste her inventions.

The pink Patti-mobile will be parked at Picklesburgh on July 11-13.Get in line early: Though she prepares more than 5,000 cupcakes, popular items disappear in a cream puff of smoke.