This is the second installment in our Class of 2015 series, about a slate of openings that changed the way the city dined and drank a decade ago — and continues to do so today.
Most of Pittsburgh’s dining public was at home by 10 p.m. on a Wednesday in April. The city has seen ebbs and flows of mid-week late-night dining over the years, but has largely remained early to bed. In 2025, most restaurant kitchens close by 9 p.m. and only a modest number of bars are buzzing on weeknights.
At the Butterwood Bake Consortium on Butler Street in Lawrenceville, just two seats remained empty. A group of graduate students gathered over board games. Couples on dates sat gazing and grazing at small tables near the windows. A solitary reader, absorbed in a paperback, occupied another.
Grouped or solo, they all dug into thick slices of cake, crispy-sweet hand pies and gooey brownies, sipping specialty coffee drinks and organic teas.
Neither restaurant nor bar, Butterwood Bake Consortium made it to the 10-year mark by offering an alternative: a cozy dessert destination with a Victorian-era feel.
When owner Ally Slayden opened in October 2015, Butler Street was just beginning to emerge as a dining and drinking corridor. She saw a chance to fill a gap — a place where people could go for dessert or a cup of coffee before or after dinner.
Read More
“I moved around quite a bit before Pittsburgh and wanted a space here where you can get dessert and hang out at a place that wasn’t a restaurant,” she says.
Slayden is a self-taught baker who began making cakes as a hobby in 2009 while living on the Caribbean island of Dominica. As she got better at the craft, her friends began to notice. Soon, people were asking if they could purchase them, and a cottage business developed.
Slayden hadn't planned to open anything formal when she moved to Pittsburgh in 2013 – she was working in nonprofit arts administration at the time – but she was still baking for fun, so when the opportunity arose to move into the space on Butler Street in 2015, she jumped.
“The space was affordable, so I decided to take a risk and go for it,” she says.
Early on, the menu showed a lot of spontaneity. She was the sole baker and let instinct guide her decisions.
“I’d just float in first thing in the morning and start baking whatever I liked. It was seasonal, but also whimsical,” she says.
As business picked up and she hired more staff, Slayden began to move toward more of a set menu.
“It was fun operating without a plan but it made it tricky to operate in advance,” she says.
Now, Butterwood introduces new flavors every few weeks.
Some are driven by the season, and others are inspired by Slayden’s travels. She saturated the menu with prickly pear following a trip to Sedona a few years ago, and there is currently a poppy and blood orange cake with date buttercream influenced by a recent journey to Palm Springs. There are always options for vegan dessert lovers, too.
Although Butterwood’s business is boosted in small part by custom orders for weddings and other events, Slayden says that from the beginning until now, the primary factor driving the dessert destination’s success is the mix of regulars and walk-ins who come by to enjoy a slice or two of cake and a warm, booze-free beverage.
“Remaining ultra-niche has really helped with our business,” she says.
And while Butterwood might be inspired by a bygone, analog era, operating in an age of social media helps, too.
“People love taking pictures of their desserts. We don’t have to do a lot of work in that regard,” Slayden says.
5222 Butler St., Lawrenceville; thebutterwoodbakeconsortium.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.