This is the first in a series. Over the next few months, we’ll look at a slate of openings that changed the way the city dined and drank a decade ago — and continues to do so today.
Scratch & Co. in Troy Hill was buzzing at a gentle hum on a crisp Thursday night in March.
A few guests shared sandwiches, one prepared with ultra-crispy chicken dressed in tahini Buffalo sauce and another a vegetarian number with cauliflower, greens and muhammara drawing from Indo-Persian influences.
Others were catching up with after-work cocktails with seasonal twists, Pittsburgh-brewed beers and curated selections from the establishment’s deep vermouth and amari lists.
The current weeknight “Tavern” menu, along with an expanded weekend menu — featuring composed dishes like salmon with miso polenta, celeriac, brown butter, capers and Calabrian chili at a higher price point — are the latest offerings from a neighborhood spot that has seen many changes over its decade of operation. Yet Scratch & Co. remains true to owner Don Mahaney’s founding vision:
“Scratch has always been about being a neighborhood gathering spot, and it always will be.”
Read More
Mahaney opened the restaurant, then known as Scratch Food and Beverage, in November 2015. The Troy Hill space was a bit more swish than its predecessor, the beloved Billy’s Troy Hill Bistro, which served the neighborhood for decades.
Mahaney’s ownership philosophy is guided by allowing himself the freedom to move on from ideas that have run their course, paired with the discipline to thoughtfully decide what follows.
“It's about finding the right response to what's happening around us, while maintaining a space that's uncommonly welcoming and centered on the guest experience,” he says. “It's never bothered me much to make changes to achieve that.”
In 2015, the front-room bar felt like a neighborhood pub complete with weekly trivia and karaoke nights, though the drinks list leaned into the bespoke, spirit-forward offerings of the peak cocktail-era that was the mid-2010s.
The food was more eclectic for the first few years, with elevated comfort cuisine giving way to the experimental — including one-offs such as an insect dinner in 2016 — as a number of chefs cycled through the kitchen.
The dining room began to find its stride in 2017, with Brandon Blumenfeld (now a private chef) and later Chris O’Brien (currently executive chef/owner of Hyeholde) drawing from their interpretations of the contemporary American canon; the bar continued to be a more boisterous side of the business.
All along, Mahaney has stayed rooted in his role as proprietor to the two-room establishment; he’s hands-on and ever-present, but trusts his kitchen and front-of-house staff to collaborate with him on the direction of the restaurant.
A key to Mahaney’s success is he leads like a host and not a headliner, tuning in to what people need instead of chasing what they’re supposed to want.
“It's a listening-first disposition, paying attention and really listening. Not just ‘How do you like everything?’ and they say, ‘Oh it's great,” and you just move on. It's paying attention to body language and asking real questions,” he says. “You do that every day and clear patterns start to emerge.”
Mahaney’s attentiveness placed him at the forefront of restaurant owners embracing adaptability during the early months of the COVID-19 pandemic. With the restaurant closed for on-site dining, he turned the space into a local market with prepared foods, meal kits, school lunches and even a few everyday household items.
He and the team then pivoted toward easy-to-love crowd pleasers, like a slow-cooker gumbo and sandwiches designed to be broadly appealing and hold up whether you were eating them in the outdoor dining area on Froman Street, transporting them to a picnic or saving them for dinner. The menu was built in components to make the most of each ingredient while minimizing staff contact in Scratch’s pea-sized kitchen.
“Our biggest asset is that we've always been so nimble,” Mahaney says.
That agility came to define the next phase of the restaurant. As the pandemic began to wane, Scratch hosted a rotation of pop-ups and residencies on typically slow weeknights starting in 2021 and introduced an all-day menu in 2022.
These days, Mahaney says, diners want a weeknight dinner that doesn’t feel like a splurge, paired with a more ambitious weekend experience.
“During the week people want burgers, sandwiches in an after-work chill spot. Then we see them on the weekends coming for date night, and at brunch with friends,” he says.
Now, a new shift is underway: a renewed interest in group events. Over the past few weeks, Mahaney has refurbished the dining room to suit larger parties. Updates include a custom-built bar, a plant-filled bump-out with banquette seating and flexible table layouts against warm, desert sand-toned walls.
Another secret to Scratch’s success: Mahaney is handy with a hammer and a paintbrush, and he’s overseen cosmetic changes to the space since its earliest iteration.
Mahaney suggested his son visit Basílica de la Sagrada Família on a recent trip to Barcelona, Spain. In his mind, the still-unfinished cathedral, under construction since 1882, speaks to the value of work that never truly ends.
“That's the thing, that's the idea. Every time a new architect is involved in the project, they put their stamp on it. It's a beautiful example of how a core thought can be expressed in so many different ways,” Mahaney says.
Scratch might not aim for the same centuries-long legacy, but it shares something with the notion behind the sacred space. Ten years in, Scratch is his own version of that idea — unfinished, intentional, shaped by many and open to more changes as the years roll by. All the while, however, its roots keep growing deeper as a destination that’s meant to be shared by everyone.
“You're in a place where you belong. You're in a place where you feel welcome. We're here for you as much as you're here to support what we're doing.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.