Pittsburgh pizza makers last year left the International Pizza Expo in Las Vegas with a heap of pride but also plenty of unfinished business.

Among the notable near-misses was Slice on Broadway owner Rico Lunardi, who felt the taste of victory after winning the preliminary round of the World’s Best Cheese Slice competition only to place fifth in the finals. This year, he sent his right-hand man Chris Ostapenko to compete in the contest, which tests the purity of pizza making with pies topped only with red sauce, cheese, dried spices (no fresh basil allowed) and olive oil.

Ostapenko placed third in the preliminaries.

When he didn’t hear his name called for the third- and second-place trophies, he and Lunardi braced for a repeat of last year. Since fourth and fifth places aren’t announced, they began drifting away from the podium rather than relive 2024’s disappointment.

Advertise with us

Then Ostapenko heard his name.

He was the official winner of the 2025 World’s Best Cheese Slice.

“Everyone was applauding. Loud. It was wild,” he says, back in Pittsburgh on Saturday. “It’s still just starting to sink in a couple of days after. I'm a humble person. This is just what I do every day.”

Other than a dusting of oregano and grated Locatelli Pecorino Romano cheese, and a finishing wipe of olive oil to add shine to the crust, Ostapenko’s award-winning slice starts with the same recipe prepared at Slice on Broadway’s Beechview, Carnegie, East Liberty, Robinson, Wexford and South Side locations.

“People think that you're bringing something totally different. We bring the same dough, same sauce, same cheese as we use here. It represents our brand and what we do every single day,” Lunardi says.

Advertise with us

“The biggest difference is you're not cooking in your element. There are all these different variables: It’s not your oven, you’re in front of a crowd, the judges.”

Meanwhile, the crew from Caliente Pizza & Draft House had their own score to settle in the World Pizza Games — akin to the flair bartending of the pizza world — in which pizzaioli compete in feats of skill such as Freestyle Acrobatic Dough Tossing (think Cocktail-era Tom Cruise, but with pizza dough instead of bottles of booze).

Caliente’s commissary general manager Matt Hickey, a gold medalist last year in World’s Largest Dough Stretch, has had his eye on the top prize in dough tossing since first competing in 2018. He came close to winning last year, entering the final round as the top finisher in the preliminaries. However, a lower-than-expected mark in dexterity for his St. Patrick’s Day-themed routine dropped him to second overall.

“After that happened, I had so much determination to win it this year. I was hungry for it,” he says.

He and Caliente president and founder Nick Bogacz decided to pull out the big guns for the 2025 contest: a years-in-the-making routine he called “Peel or No Peel.”

Advertise with us

Hickey says he practiced constantly, turning to dance instructor Kosha Dolan for help with choreography and music editing.

“I could feel it the whole routine. The crowd was into it and I knew I was nailing it. All that practice was paying off,” Hickey says.

Hickey bested his nearest opponent by 10 points.

Perry Bogacz — Nick Bogacz’s son — officially represented Caliente spin-off Dough Daddy Brewery, and had unfinished business too. In the last two years, the 22-year-old finished second in Pizza Triathlon, for which competitors fold a 12-inch pizza box, toss out a 22-ounce dough ball to cover a 16-inch screen and toss a 22-ounce dough ball to cover a 24-inch pizza screen. 

In 2025, he trounced the competition with a winning time of 36.084 seconds, a full 14 seconds ahead of the nearest competitor.

Advertise with us

“You get a feel for it and you know what you have to do to move forward,” Perry Bogacz says. “This year I went and did it.”

He credits his daily work ethic for his success.

“I don’t really practice, but when I’m in the stores I’m always doing everything as fast as I can. That’s what gives you the sense of how to do it,” he says.

With victory in hand for some, a new slate of Pittsburgh pizza makers has accounts to settle in 2026:

Iron Born’s Sara Boyer landed in the top five in the finals after placing third in the preliminaries of Non-Traditional (the anything goes class with no restrictions on styles, saucing or toppings) for a stepped-up version of “Vegas Pie,” a Detroit-style pizza that uses crispy potatoes in place of the pizzeria’s cheese frico and adds sauerkraut as a tangy topping flavor bomb. This was Boyer’s third year competing; she landed third overall in Non-Traditional in 2023 for the original permutation, but didn’t make the finals last year.

Advertise with us

Gus Franco’s owner Patrick Elston's top 20 finish in the Traditional division marked the high-point for Pittsburgh-area pizza makers in that contest; it was enough to earn him a winner’s plaque as best in the Northeast region, too.

Representatives from A Slice of New York, Mercurio’s, Yellow Bridge Brewing and Eddie’s Pizza 412 were among the other Western Pennsylvania competitors.

As for Ostapenko, the headlining title (along with a $5,000 cash prize) is something that he can celebrate as a validation of the professionalism he brings to his craft. He’s one of Slice on Broadway’s longest tenured employees: He started making pies at the original Beechview location six months after the pizzeria opened in 2010. For Ostapenko, and a lot of others, pizza making is a career, but one that all too often isn’t as respected as it should be.

“A lot of people think, ‘Oh, you’re just a pizza guy.’ And then I go to an event like Pizza Expo and it breathes a new life into me because I'm surrounded by thousands of other people who wake up every day, love what they do and are proud of what they create. So to be called the best in the world for the pizza I made by other people in the business, that's an incredible feeling,” he says.