Last week, we celebrated the Best New Restaurants of 2024. This week, we honor the ones that closed in the past year.

The first significant closing of the year happened in February, when Curtis Gamble decided it was time to shut down his 9-year-old restaurant, Station. Gamble operated the Bloomfield spot as an elevated gastropub with a modern American menu and a high-end cocktail program.

Gamble, an Ohio native, worked as a chef in Pittsburgh at Six Penn Kitchen and Café at the Frick in the early aughts, and returned to the city in 2012 as the chef de cuisine of Grit & Grace; in between, he earned acclaim in Chicago as the executive chef of Bread & Wine. He cited his family’s plan to move to Tennessee as the reason for closing Station. Nothingman, an easy-to-like pub, opened in the space in September.

The vegetarian restaurant Sia’s Garden Grown also closed in February after a short run in the former Union Pig & Chicken space in East Liberty. Reva Modern Indian, a Post-Gazette Best New Restaurant of 2024, took over a few months later.

Advertise with us

Blue Flame Restaurant, founded by Les George Sr. in 1956, shuttered in March. The Jefferson Hills restaurant was beloved by generations of diners, and known for its popular stuffed cabbage specials and murder mystery dinner theater events.

Fat Cat, the Deutschtown restaurant and music venue from Fig & Ash owners Cory Hughes and Alex Feltovich, closed at the end of February, too.

Read More

“One of the things you hear the most in the industry is that 50% of restaurants don’t make it a year,” Hughes said at the time. “But you never think that it’s going to be you.”

Hughes said that the ground-floor restaurant of the two-level concept never really took off, even if the music venue on the second floor was booking acts. The building remains active as a pop-up and fundraiser space and is currently serving as a long-term residency for the excellent Taqueria Acosta.

Pittsburgh saw its most controversial restaurant closing of the year in July with the sudden shuttering of 40 North at Alphabet City. Bethany Zozula, 40 North’s executive chef at the time, cited the desire of 40 North’s ownership to swiftly change the concept as the reason for the closure.

Advertise with us

Zozula earned a 2022 James Beard Award Best Chef: Mid-Atlantic semifinalist nod (her second) for her work at 40 North. Her menu spoke to Western Pennsylvania dining by drawing from Central and Eastern European foodways while showcasing the cornucopia of goods delivered by the region’s farmers and ranchers.

In its place is Cucina Alfabeto, an upscale Northern Italian restaurant. Alfabeto is now the fourth restaurant to operate in the Alphabet City space, which has also housed a performance venue and bookstore since 2017.

Longtime Pittsburgh hospitality industry linchpins Cat Cannon and Cecil Usher closed St. Clair Social in July, too. The duo, who also operate the consulting brand Mindful Hospitality, launched the neighborhood gathering spot in October 2020. Cannon said that on any given night, the bar was populated with locals who made up a rotating crew of regulars.

Cannon and Usher worked under a long-term consulting contract and served as proprietors of St. Clair Social, overseeing the day-to-day operations. The building and liquor license, however, are owned by an LLC belonging to real estate developer Ahron Freilich. The license is currently listed as “pending” according to the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board.

Two Lawrenceville establishments closed in September. Smoke Barbeque Taqueria, known for its fusion of Texas-style smoked meats and Mexican-influenced tortillas and salsas, ended an eight-year run on Butler Street following a 2016 move from its original Homestead digs.

Advertise with us

LeVia Trattoria in Upper Lawrenceville had a shorter run, opening in mid-2021 in the former Cure space. Brothers Christopher and Anthony Castine decided to close their easy-to-love Italian spot rather than renew the lease.

In October, Thai Place, the region’s oldest standing Thai restaurant, closed. The Pine restaurant was the final location for what once was a mini-empire of establishments run by Surin and Santi Thamwiwat. The couple opened the original Thai Place in Harmarville in 1989, later running spots in Fox Chapel, Oakland, Upper St. Clair and Pine.

The Thamwiwats, now in their 80s, felt it was time to retire after a lengthy run in the restaurant business. Their popular line of Thai sauces, however, remains for sale at six Giant Eagle Market District stores as well as Oriental Market in Ross.

Jesse and Amy Seager announced their decision to close Park Bruges, their 2011 Highland Park follow-up to their Belgian-inspired Point Brugge Café, at the end of the year.

“It’s been 15 years over there. We have some milestones coming up in our personal lives. I turned 50 this year. All three kids will be out of the house next year. Point [Brugge] is coming up on its 20th anniversary, so it felt like a natural time to simplify,” Jesse Seager said at the time. “I wanted to end it on my terms and feel good about it.”

Advertise with us

Angela Earley, co-owner of Penn Avenue Fish Co. and The Warren Bar and Burrow, plans to launch a new restaurant in the space in 2025. She’s planning on making the interior cozier and offering a menu of bar-forward food, craft cocktails and wine.

The Seagers, meanwhile, will turn all their attention to Point Brugge, which will celebrate its 20th anniversary next year.

The popular riverfront joint Farmer x Baker served its last sandwiches, salads and pastries in Allegheny RiverTrail Park in November. Jennifer Urich brought her food trailer, built from an upcycled shipping container, to the park in 2019, offering a dining option there for the first time.

She said that she and the board of trustees of the nonprofit that runs the privately owned park couldn’t come to terms on a new lease. Urich plans on reopening Farmer x Baker at another location along the Allegheny River next year.

Brian Forrester and Melissa Barth also closed their South Side restaurant, Sultry Food & Bar, in November. The couple originated the concept with the Galley Group in 2019 and moved to East Carson Street in 2022.

Advertise with us

“With heavy hearts, we share that we’re making the difficult decision to close our doors. This year has presented challenges that have become too much to bear,” a message stated on its social media channels.

Merchant Oyster Company, opened in 2017, closed in December. Dennis Marron’s Jersey Shore tribute helped spur the boom of eateries in Central and Lower Lawrenceville, offering the city’s best rotating selection of oysters, plus a fantastic menu of chowders, stuffies and foot-long hot dogs. Marron is holding out hope that he'll be able to relocate Merchant next year.

In December, Len Semplice announced the end-of-year closing of his beloved Mount Washington bar, Redbeard's Sports Bar & Grill. Semplice called the shuttering of the Shiloh Street spot a “semi-retirement” in a social media post. He also operates a Redbeard’s on Sixth in the Cultural District. That location, which he opened in 2013, will remain operational. It’s one of the few bars Downtown to serve until 2 a.m. nightly, with a kitchen that stays open until midnight.

Cioppino Restaurant & Cigar Bar will end its 16-year run in the Strip District on New Year’s Eve. In a social media post, its owners cited “the pressures of running a fine dining business have become increasingly untenable” as the reason for the closure. Cioppino’s sister space, the adjacent Osteria 2350, will also close.