Before he had his own restaurant, Brooklyn native Joel Bolden remembers seeking out barbecue for Thanksgiving.
“Holidays in New York, those are really great times to be in the city because nobody’s around, so you can maneuver into places you couldn’t go on a normal day,” he said. “There are still millions of people, but it feels like a ghost town.”
He and his business partner, Chris Morgan, would go for a “big feast” at Hill Country Barbecue Market, a Texas-style barbecue restaurant near the Flatiron Building in Manhattan. He was enthusiastic when the restaurant offered catering for Thanksgiving.
“Who wants to cook?” he said.
So when he and Morgan opened Morgan’s Barbecue in Brooklyn’s Prospect Heights neighborhood in 2013, they decided they would also offer takeout Thanksgiving meals. And the tradition continued when the pair sold Morgan’s and opened Walter’s Southern Kitchen in Lawrenceville in 2018.
In a spread that can serve up to 10 people, Walter’s holiday menu includes a choice of a whole smoked or fried turkey, or smoked brisket or pork butt, along with sides and dessert.
Read More
Bolden has his favorites.
“What’s better than a smoked turkey?” he asked. “A fried turkey! But we do both.”
Low and slow, Texas style
While Bolden was coming up in the Bedford-Stuyvesant neighborhood of Brooklyn – and going to visit family in Virginia during the summer to escape the crime – Morgan was growing up in Southeast Texas, on the Louisiana border.
Morgan’s family would serve barbecue for Thanksgiving and Christmas, but also gumbo; his family has Cajun roots.
Serving smoked meats was an ordinary occurrence, he said, since his family had a smoker, as did many of his neighbors.
“It wasn’t a featured item,” he said. “It was just something you kind of did all the time.”
At Walter’s, meat is cooked in the “low and slow” Texas tradition. The restaurant has two 20-foot-long offset smokers that it had specially built by East Texas Smoker Co. in Tyler, Texas. These cook with indirect heat, infusing the meat with smoke, which passes from the firebox to exit from the stack on the other end.
Morgan said the restaurant typically cooks a dry-rubbed 14-pound brisket for 14 hours, using oak to fire up the smoker rather than the region’s more plentiful maple or cherry – also a Texas tradition, because oak “burns hot and clean.”
Does Pittsburgh, a town that throws slices of deli ham into a frying pan with barbecue sauce and calls it “ham barbecue,” appreciate Texas barbecue?
“There’s an educational piece to it,” Bolden said of entering a new market. “And then you just have to trust.”
‘The craveability factor’
With his New York background, Bolden, too, had a barbecue learning curve. His eyes were opened when Morgan took him to Texas.
“Families, brothers, fathers, children, grandparents — they all go wait in line for an hour and a half, two hours, but they come to get the brisket,” Bolden said of Texas barbecue restaurants. Having grown up with New York “BBQ,” he was blown away.
“I understood right away, from bite one, why there’s a craveability factor to what barbecue is.” He thought to himself, “We can repeat that.”
In opening a restaurant, the two wanted “craveability” on their menu.
“Usually there’s an item or two in every restaurant I worked at that people would come for,” Bolden said.
Barbecue has the kind of crossover appeal a restaurant needs, the pair believes, whether it’s in Texas, Brooklyn or Pittsburgh. But Morgan said they did get a little Pittsburgh attitude at first.
“I think anytime anyone moves from New York, everyone’s like, ‘Oh, who do these guys think they are?’”
But the partners’ ethos is to build a homey, family-friendly environment in their restaurants. (Together and separately they have helmed five in New York and New Jersey; they also own Inkwell Coffee Shop in Lawrenceville.) After eight years, Walter’s has become part of the community.
‘Do it old school’
Both mention the TV series “Cheers” as an early touchstone.
“We wanted to create the ‘Cheers’ environment in a restaurant,” Morgan said. “It’s the same thing here. It’s kind of like a small-town vibe, trying to do it old school.”
Thanksgiving at Walter’s is an embodiment of that feeling. People come in to pick up their meal on Thanksgiving Day, and the restaurant plays music and offers cider, creating a pre-party energy.
“It’s a very diverse selection of people that comes in, which is kind of what barbecue is about,” Bolden said. On any given day, “you’ll see dogs, babies, older people and younger people. It’s all across the board.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.