Whenever the first few bites of a dish brought unexpected joy to my dad, he would curl his lips into a semi-serious smile, silently gesturing with his pointer finger toward the plate.

It eventually became a bit of a Paul Hollywood handshake and, since my father’s passing in 2021, a playful tradition between my brother, mother and me to celebrate his memory.

A dear pal of mine didn’t know this fun fact about Big Art when she made the same gesture after digging into the scallop ceviche at Lilith in Shadyside. (Her father attended the same high school in Queens, N.Y., as mine, so maybe there was something special going on in the cafeteria.)

The first bites of Lilith's scallop ceviche are almost electric, with a smooth, sweet finish. (Hal B. Klein / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Lilith’s ceviche is a refined take on a typical Central and South American coastal dish. Diced dayboat scallops, served in a shell, were ocean candy singing with a harmonious backing band of coconut milk, chili oil, lime juice and sliced peaches. Each bite had an electric zing on the tongue, later melting into a soothing, sweet finish. I’m sure my dad would have given it his famous finger point, too.

Advertise with us

Keep an eye out in mid-September for our next installment of Eat Pittsburgh. Lilith, at 238 Spahr St., is one of the restaurants we’ll highlight as we guide you through dining in Shadyside.

Moonlit Burgers — quick!

A trio of smash burgers served with shoestring fries and slaw at Moonlit Burgers' Uptown location. (Hal B. Klein / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Moonlit Burgers isn’t a typical fast food joint; it’s locally owned and, as of now, there are just two locations plus a food truck. Its streamlined menu features a few permutations of thin, lacy smashburgers, a plant-based burger, chicken strips and a handful of sides, as well as a bar.

When you visit Moonlit, you can expect consistency and fast service, similar to what you'd find at big-brand fast food places.

The difference between Moonlit and big national chains is that Moonlit does it exponentially better.

Here’s what made a visit to the Uptown location at 1023 Forbes Ave. stand out to me as my friends and I crushed a table of terrific burgers prior to the Springsteen show at PPG Paints Arena: Its owners (on-site and working hard) and management were actively reassuring the long line of customers, many visiting for the first time, that they didn’t need to stress about making it to the nearby arena with plenty of time to spare before Bruce and the E Street Band struck their first chords.

Advertise with us

They were correct. Moonlit excels in crowd management, and the line moved at a good clip. The trio of hot, freshly prepared burgers and crisp shoestring fries arrived at the table with remarkable speed, without missing a beat in quality from what I’d had previously at Moonlit’s Dormont location.

Oak Hill Post’s All-American Burger

While we’re talking hamburgers, I paid a long overdue visit to Oak Hill Post (600 Brookline Blvd.) in Brookline in August. If you haven’t been, owners Christian Schulz and Rebecca Nicholson crafted a small restaurant that sits comfortably in a space between classic old-school daytime dining and chef-driven cookery while maintaining a serene sense of place.

I’m always drawn to the All-American burger, which features smashburger-style beef patties with diner-style juiciness, gooey American cheese, lettuce, red onion, pickle and a good lacing of Tartar-style sauce. The second I took my first juicy bite, I regretted leaving so much time between burgers (and visits) to this terrific spot. Then, I demolished the rest of the burger in pure bliss.

Oak Hill Post is temporarily closed as the culinary team work toward a significant menu revamp. Expect a completely new menu when they reopen, likely in mid-September, for daytime service. The couple will expand hours as soon as late September to include dinner service for the first time since late 2021.

Alas, the All-American burger will be retired as part of the change. It’s a loss for Pittsburgh hamburger lovers as the Oak Hill Post version was a superstar in Pittsburgh’s burger world, but all things must change and that’s ok. If the gorgeous Elysian Fields braised lamb shank hash with a latke cooked in clarified butter, topped with a fried egg and served with mint chutney and hot-pepper jelly that Schulz was testing the other week is any indication of the direction the new menu is going, the restaurant will continue forward on the upswing with renewed energy.

Advertise with us

Alberta’s Pizzeria cotoletta

There was no urgent need for Alberta’s Pizzeria to have a face-sized portion of thin and crispy pork on the menu of its new location at 917 Western Ave., North Side. Beau Mitall's top-tier pizza would have been plenty of a draw on its own.

The seeming randomness of its inclusion is precisely why my pals and I ordered Mitall’s cotoletta (basically, an Italian take on schnitzel) during an early visit. What we got was a textbook terrific, crispy-crunchy cutlet, lightly seasoned and served with a wedge of juicy lemon. Like most of the items on the menu, it's a clear demonstration that a well-executed dish doesn’t need a lot of extra elements to be incredibly satisfying.

As for the pizza and the rest of the menu, keep an eye out next week for my story on Mitall’s move from mobile delight to destination restaurant.

Little Italy Days: The Warren, Brothmonger, Butterfat

Butterfat gelato was a hit at Little Italy Days. (Hal B. Klein / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Sure, there was an array of not-Italian carnival food like alligator tail tacos and turkey legs as well as trucks with steam tables full of spaghetti and meatballs getting gluey in mass batches and occasional hordes of wasted people walking six across a sidewalk at Bloomfield’s annual Little Italy Days.

Bashing of the festival is easy. Yet, as I kept telling people over the long weekend: Little Italy Days is what you make of it.

Advertise with us

Year by year, the food at the fest is getting better as Bloomfield restaurants and locally owned establishments from other neighborhoods play to their strengths. I had excellent bites as I wandered through the festival. Three stood out.

I had to stop myself from getting a second helping of the crispy, succulent pepperoni egg rolls served by The Warren. Here’s hoping the Downtown bar and restaurant (245 7th St.), where the kitchen stays open until midnight daily, adds this play on the Italian-American pepperoni roll as a special item on its menu.

As the PG reported earlier this month, Brothmonger is opening a brick-and-mortar establishment on Liberty Avenue later this year. In the meantime, I’ll be dreaming about the stunning mortadella sandwich dressed with an aggressive (in the best way) garlicky kale, pistachio pesto and creamy fresh mozzarella that owner Sarah Coppolo served from the Thyme Machine window as part of her Little Italy Days offerings.

Grab Coppolo’s line of Brothmonger soups at Bloomfield’s fantastic Linea Verde Green Market while we’re waiting for her storefront to open.

Butterfat, a new gelato business, is slated to open on the North Side late this year. I’ll be there on day one, even if it’s snowing. Lauren Brock is going shortcut-free when it comes to effort and quality ingredients, using two types of whole vanilla bean for her scratch-and-sniff experience vanilla gelato, freshly juiced lemons for a lemon sorbetto that made me feel like a happy child, and a lovely balance for the soft strawberry variety. Look for the Butterfat cart to pop up at events around town until its opening.

Advertise with us

Speckled Egg turmeric chicken salad sandwich

Turmeric chicken salad sandwich is a longstanding favorite at The Speckled Egg. (Hal B. Klein / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

There are a handful of beautifully balanced sandwiches in Pittsburgh that are now years-long go-tos that always hit the mark when I want a quick and delicious lunch.

One of them is the turmeric chicken salad sandwich from The Speckled Egg. I’ve adored this sandwich – a blend of warmly spiced pulled chicken, creamy lemon aioli, crunchy celery and onion, crisp lettuce and sweet raisins – since 2020 and come back to it fairly often.

It was an easy call to get one when dining at the lovely Downtown location at 501 Grant St. in July. I’ll probably get another next month when shopping for winter bike gear at the newer SouthSide Works location, too.

’77 Club’s panuzzo

You’ve perhaps already gathered that my brain is 95% pizza. I also quite enjoy when a business can pull off the rare feat of nailing a quirky and personal social media presence without feeling like its trying too hard. So count me in as a new fan of Brittani and Dustin Boutilier’s ’77 Club, which is making inroads at arts events and breweries around town.

The duo served panuozzo — basically, a sandwich made from a folded-over neo-Neapolitan pizza — at a street party celebrating nonprofit artist residency and gallery Bunker Projects having purchased its Penn Avenue building in Bloomfield.

They stuffed smoked porchetta, tomato-fennel jam, arugula and grated Grana Padano into a crispy, airy crust, packing heaps of big flavor into a surprisingly delicate bite.