Last week, we celebrated Pittsburgh’s best new restaurant openings of 2023. This week, we remember the ones that closed.
2023’s significant closings began before the year started. Toni Pais, the celebrated Portugal-born chef whose culinary career in Pittsburgh began in the late 1970s and took off in 1992 with the opening of his Baum Vivant restaurant, decided to retire due to ongoing complications from Parkinson’s disease.
Pais was one of the most influential voices in Pittsburgh restaurants during his nearly 50 years working in hospitality in the city. He and his wife, Becky Pais, shuttered Café Zinho at the end of 2022, but waited until February to announce that the Shadyside space wouldn’t reopen. The couple opened the restaurant, their third, in 1997 with Pais’ coastal-inspired menu and convivial atmosphere a through-line through its 25 year run.
Similarly, Two Sisters Vietnamese Restaurant, a hub for pho and plated Vietnamese dishes, announced on Dec. 31, 2022, that it wouldn’t return to its East Liberty location in 2023. Sisters Trinh Phan and Trang Somphomaphakdy helped open the restaurant in 2019, but decided to return to Atlantic City, New Jersey where they now operate Two Sisters Making Pho.
In February, big Burrito Restaurant Group finished up at the spot where it all began – its original Mad Mex location in Oakland. Founder Tom Baron and then business partner Juno Yoon opened the bar and restaurant in 1993, and it quickly became a hub for nearby university students and a training ground for the city’s hospitality industry.
The restaurant group now operates nine Mad Mex locations and a specialty restaurant portfolio that includes Kaya, Casbah, Soba, Umi, Eleven, Alta Via, Alta Via Pizzeria. And its alumni own, cook at, bartend and manage myriad establishments in Pittsburgh and beyond. It recently made its first foray into Downtown, opening a second Alta Via location in Market Square in November.
Vento’s Pizza, one of the oldest pizza shops in the city, closed in March when owner Al Vento Jr. decided to retire. His father, Al Vento Sr., opened Vento’s in East Liberty in 1956 and was celebrated for his pizzeria’s crunchy, Sicilian-style tray pies as it moved through several locations in the neighborhood throughout its 67 years in business.
Its everlasting claim to fame – and one that will live on – is as home to Franco’s Italian Army, which Vento Sr. founded in 1972 with his cousin Tony Stagno of Stagno’s Bakery. It reopened in December under new ownership, with the Vento family offering the naming rights and recipes as part of the sale.
Onion Maiden, one of Pittsburgh’s most beloved vegan eateries, wound down its restaurant operations in April. Owners Diana “Dingo” Ngo and Brooks Criswell founded the business along with Elyse Hoffman in 2015 as a plant-based pop-up at local DIY and punk shows and opened a brick-and-mortar in Allentown in 2017.
Ngo, the chef, offered a menu of dishes drawing from, but not limited to, Asian culinary components. Her dishes often had names such as Fistful of Curry (a curry noodle soup with potatoes, carrots, sprouts, bok choy) and Balls to the Wall (tofu croquettes with forbidden rice, ginger, soy caramel, kale and sesame), inspired by Ngo and Criswell’s love of heavy metal music. The duo said it was time to shut down the day-to-day of the restaurant to have a better work-life balance and continue to offer occasional pop-ups in the space and at farmers markets.
May brought a rash of closings, starting with Ladybird’s Luncheonette in Beaver. Chef/co-owner Jade Cageao opened Ladybird’s in Ellwood City in 2019, expanding to the second location in Beaver with business partner Alex Jordan in 2020. The owners went all in with the Beaver location in 2022, where Cageao continued to build a fan base for her farm-to-table, highly seasonal offerings of sandwiches, hand pies and pastries, all of which were among the best in the region.
Cageao felt that to remain financially viable, she would have to expand the size and scope of operation beyond what she was capable of doing, so she instead pivoted to events, workshops and pop-up orders for her fantastic culinary work.
Fuel and Fuddle, home to countless memories, hazy and otherwise, for 27 years, closed in May when owner Brandon Smith decided to end the run of the bar and restaurant as its lease was set to expire. The Oakland establishment was one of the first to bring craft beer to the forefront in Pittsburgh when it opened in 1996, and its casual bites powered nearby university students late into the night.
Casa Brasil and Duncan Street Sandwich Shop shuttered on May 31. Keyla Nogueira Cook transitioned her pop-up concept to a standalone space in Highland Park in 2018, offering a tasty menu of Brazilian dishes, including feijoada, regional takes on moqueca and canja de galinha, a bright and herby chicken soup. Cook and co-owner Tim Guthrie hosted popular live music and DJ nights in the restaurant’s basement events space. She continues to operate Mercearia, a Brazilian market in Allison Park.
Duncan Street Sandwich Shop also moved from pop-up to brick-and-mortar in 2015, with Kendall Ryan and Dan Rodriguez bringing terrific sandwiches and a small delicatessen to Millvale.
Con Alma transitioned its original Shadyside location into an events space in July. Owners Aimee Marshall, John Shannon and Josh Ross decided to focus all of their attention on Con Alma’s Downtown location, which is larger and more centrally located. The Shadyside space, opened in 2019, featured an intimate front room perfect for small jazz combos and, more recently, an all-vegan menu. The Ellsworth Avenue space has seen several establishments come and go over the past decade.
Back To The Foodture, another popular venture that expanded to a new location, closed its South Side location and rebranded its Uptown spot as “The Foodture” in August. Owners Angel and Eddie “Barnz” Magwood cited staffing issues and a potential copyright issue with Universal Studios (owners of the “Back To The Future” franchise) as reasons for the change.
Pittsburgh saw a trio of September shutterings. Blue Dust ended a 15-year run in Homestead in the middle of the month. The establishment was a draw for its extensive craft beer selection, house-infused spirits and scratch-made bar food.
Double Wide Grill, a South Side mainstay for 18 years, closed at the end of the month. Its vacancy, however, was short-lived as co-owner Steve Zumoff and new business partner Andrew Tepper of Spork (Double Wide co-founder Scott Kramer is no longer part of the business) announced that the space would become Spork Island Trading Co. The Caribbean-influenced restaurant and bar will open next year, but is already home to Tepper’s Spork Pit barbeque.
Beloved Oakland restaurant Spice Island Tea House also closed at the end of September. Owner Ron Lee said he felt like 28 years was a good run for a restaurant and that it was time to move on to new endeavors. Lee and chef Hai Jing Leong built a menu of Southeast Asian cuisine peppered with a strong showing of vegetarian and vegan dishes before either were commonplace in Pittsburgh. Lee, whose family has multi-generational roots in Myanmar, now offers occasional pop-ups in the space.
Frank Badolato, founder of Bado’s Pizza Grill & Ale House, retired in November after a nearly 40-year run offering pizza, hoagies and Italian-American classics to hungry Mt. Lebanon eaters. Badolato launched the business in 1984 as a small pizza shop known for its “cut and Coke” $1 special and later expanded into a larger location with a liquor license. His daughter Leah Badolato and her husband plan to continue to operate the Bado’s food truck.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.