Here we are again in peak ice cream season. Last year, we visited five of our favorite spots: Millie’s Homemade Ice Cream, Page’s, Antney’s, Hank’s Frozen Custard and Mexican Food, and Mitch’s BBQ.

This year, we’re adding another five to the list. You’ll find old and new, custard and gelato, as well as some frozen ice treats and, just for fun, a stellar hamburger to add to your roster.

Happy Day Dessert Factory

(Hal B. Klein / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Galen Moorer Jr. is Pittsburgh’s ice cream prodigy, having opened Happy Day Dessert Factory three years ago when he was just 20 years old. Over the past few years, he’s sharpened its 50-plus flavor lineup into a rotating selection of delightful treats while fashioning his parlor as a source of joy for his North Side neighborhood.

Advertise with us

You’re here for flavors such as Fruity Pebbles cheesecake, meant to be a one-time birthday surprise but now one of the shop’s most popular items. No wonder it stuck around; with a pop-tang of the beloved cereal and soft bites of sweet cake balanced by tangy cheesecake ice cream, it’s a shoo-in for a summer smile. Or, go for oats and honey, which shines with toasty back notes that hearken memories of a morning bowl of Honey Nut Cheerios.

Have any of the 12 flavors offered any given day in a crispy house-made waffle cone.

Happy Day’s water ices, which come in 10 flavors, are a smooth, fresh pick-me-up. Here, the apple doesn’t fall far from the tree – Moorer’s father, Galen Moorer Sr., operated a Rita’s Italian Ice franchise on East Ohio Street when Moorer was a kid.

Want it all? Get a stacker (water ice plus ice cream layers) or an ice shake (ice cream and water ice, blended).

Extra: Moorer Jr. isn’t stopping there. He just launched a Happy Day Dessert Factory ice cream bus. Look for it at events around town this summer.

Advertise with us

906 Western Ave., North Side; happydaydessertfactory.com

Tastyland

(Hal B. Klein / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

History is delicious at Tastyland on Rt. 66 in Greensburg; it’s the oldest ice cream shop still in its original location in Westmoreland County.

Jill Gunniers and her three sons, Ryan, Brandon and Austin, purchased the circa 1950 frozen treat stand in 2021 from its second owners, Bill and Mary Kuhns. The Kuhns had run the shop for nearly 48 years after taking over from its original owners, the Kemmerer family.

The Gunniers spruced up Tastyland’s signage and made a few small touches to the exterior while retaining all the nostalgic vibe that makes old-time roadside ice cream stands so memorable.

Advertise with us

One significant upgrade: brand-new, high-end Barilla Equipment Stolling SP ice cream machines.

Tastyland’s soft-serve, which begins with a 10% milkfat base from local dairies, eats super creamy. It’s everything you want in a classic without any of the fillers you find in some of the less well-made stuff.

For something just as nostalgic, go for the cookie sandwich, which will draw you back to summer evenings running for the ice cream truck. The chocolate chip cookies that sandwich vanilla ice cream are freshly baked, and the ring of milk chocolate chips adds an extra layer of bliss.

Extras: Ever have a moment when an ice cream story might turn into a hamburgers story? I did while reporting for this list.

The Gunniers family introduced a smashburger when they took over last year, and it may well be the best snack stand burger in the region.

Advertise with us

It’s made with an 87/13 blend of locally raised, freshly ground meat. Ryan Gunniers says the lower fat blend helps retain some meatiness when the patty is smashed, which means you get the lacy edges of a smashburger, but still have a snack stand burger texture in the middle.

The toppings are classic: iceberg lettuce, American cheese, tomato, ketchup and mayo (with other toppings available on request). And there’s always a fun burger of the week. At $7.99 for a standard burger, it’s a terrific deal, too.

1476 Business Route 66, Greensburg; tastyland66.com

LaScola’s Italian Ice and Custard

(Hal B. Klein / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Tish and Tom LaScola stripped an old Highland Park laundromat down to the studs to open LaScola’s Italian Ice and Custard in their favorite Pittsburgh neighborhood in 2017. They even had to file for a change of address, as the North Euclid Avenue-facing storefront was then listed as part of the Bryant Street building that houses, among other businesses, the tasty Thai restaurant Smiling Banana Leaf.

Advertise with us

Although it took longer than they’d hoped, the result is a just-around-the-corner gem where the LaScolas dish up some of the best frozen custard in town. (Frozen custard differs from ice cream in that it typically has a lower milkfat content and is enriched with egg yolks.)

Tom LaScola says the family has at least 29 flavors in their repertoire, and they offer eight at a time because it’s a small-batch operation. Lemon olive oil is the shop’s most popular flavor; it’s a sweet and savory combination balanced by a pinch of crunchy sea salt added prior to serving.

They don’t hold back on their attention to detail with the ingredients. For example, the LaScolas roast whole pecans in house for the butter-pecan flavor and toast shards of coconut for their coconut cream.

Frozen custard, introduced when they opened the shop in 2017 primarily because they enjoyed making and eating it, is a relatively new addition to the LaScola family’s contribution to Pittsburgh frozen delights.

Tom LaScola’s cousin, Chuck, operated a popular LaScola’s Italian Ice Cart in the 1970s. Tom joined the tradition in 2007, serving Italian ice at farmers markets and popular festivals such as the Pittsburgh Vintage Grand Prix. Those ices are spectacularly refreshing, and four to six flavors are rotated weekly from the dozen or so in the canon.

Advertise with us

Extras: LaScola’s offers soft custard – it’s not soft-serve. It’s the same mix they use for other custards – with vanilla, chocolate and a twist. Soft and hard “ice burgs” are soft and scooped custards topped with Italian ice.

1218 N. Euclid Ave., Highland Park

Mercurio's

(Hal B. Klein / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The case at the Shadyside location of Mercurio’s is a rainbow-hued dream with 30 varieties of brightly colored and enticing gelato and sorbetto. Most of those flavors are Italian go-to’s such as stracciatella, hazelnut and pistachio, but there are also some contemporary offerings like Colombian passion fruit and s’mores. Mercurio’s creamy hazelnut is a standout flavor.

Linda and Rick Mercurio first dipped into the ice cream trade in 1999 with Mulberry Street Creamery in Kittanning. In 2005, they opened a retail component of their gelateria in Shadyside above Girasole on Copeland Street. In 2011, along with two of their children, Anna Crucitt and Michael Mercurio, they moved the retail and manufacturing operations to its current location on Walnut Street. Brother Joe soon joined the business, and the three siblings took the whole operation over in 2016. They opened a second Mercurio’s in O’Hara in 2019, moving the gelato production to the larger space.

Advertise with us

Although the gelateria doesn’t offer free samples, it provides an alternative way to taste various flavors. Here, gelato is sold by the ounce. And at just 79 cents per ounce, it’s a terrific deal (a standard scoop of ice cream is 4 ounces.)

Extra: Mercurio’s offers some of the very best pizza in Pittsburgh. Both locations sing with outstanding Neapolitan pies from wood-fired ovens, a point of pride for the family. Don’t miss the well-balanced, gorgeously baked calzone, either.

5523 Walnut St., Shadyside, and 1335 Freeport Road #2, O’Hara; mercuriosgelatopizza.com

Treat Down the Street

(Hal B. Klein / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The Treat Down The Street motto is “Happiness in a scoop.” That’s precisely what you get at the charming new scoop shop in Aspinwall. It’s ’90s-themed and very kid-friendly with its brightly colored design and welcoming atmosphere.

Advertise with us

One standout flavor is the wildly delicious cookies and cream, where you’ll find an abundance of cookie bits perfectly balanced with a rich, creamy ice cream base. Each spoonful shines with a soft and satisfying cookie mouthfeel, reminiscent of indulging in a luxurious Oreo on a scorching summer day.

Christina Sharbaugh, whose background lies in real estate and architecture, opened Treat Down The Street because she felt there weren’t any delightful ice cream options in Aspinwall (though Farmer x Baker offers tasty vegan cones at nearby Aspinwall Riverfront Park). She also wanted to establish a teen-and-family-friendly business along the borough’s main thoroughfare.

Although Sharbaugh had significant home baking experience, her venture into the world of ice cream came during a January course at Penn State Creamery. She’s clearly a quick learner.

There are eight flavors available, all made in-house. Three are menu regulars: vanilla, chocolate and a coffee variation. The other five flavors change each Wednesday, and Sharbaugh includes seasonal influences, such as strawberry in June and peach cobbler in July.

There will always be child-friendly flavors, she says. For example, a vivid, yummy draw was an early July red, blue and yellow “Superman” variety. Suggestions from friends, neighbors and customers are always welcome.

Advertise with us

Extras: Community is the core here. Sharbaugh offers song and story time on Thursday mornings, as well as chess and other events. She plans to offer live music and even karaoke once the rhythm of the shop is more established. For the convenience of dog walkers, there’s a helpful QR code displayed on the shop’s window, allowing them to order ice cream and have it brought out to them.

231 Commercial Ave, Aspinwall; treatdownthestreet.com