Let’s call it destination gumbo, because, no matter where you live in this ole ’Burgh, this stew is worth the drive.
Chef Michael Blackwell serves up his worth-the-trip gumbo at Cafe on the Corner, the friendly spot nestled in the North Side’s Marshall-Shadeland neighborhood he owns with his wife, Lateresa.
Blackwell, who grew up in the Hill District, developed his recipe over years — he’s been in kitchens for four decades, he notes — and the result is one well-balanced bowl of comfort. There’s heat, sure, but it’s not overwhelming: Spice is just one of the many important notes in this symphonic stew.
The gumbo also builds on the salty brine of shrimp, which meets bits of tender crab and perfectly bite-sized pieces of chicken. Cooked across two hours, the traditional, roux-thickened stew also gets sweetness from the Creole Holy Trinity (celery, onions, bell peppers) and nice tang from tomatoes.
Proteins are front and center in this incredibly packed gumbo, and you’ll likely lose track of how many shrimp are in the mix.
At $10.95, including a moist, homemade cornbread muffin, it’s quite a bargain.
Read More

Crab in particular has been pricey throughout the pandemic (and, at times, difficult to find), but Blackwell has not raised the price, he says.
“Oh, my goodness, it is crazy,” Blackwell says of crab prices. “But I don’t want to take away from the flavor, so I just eat [the cost].”
Also on the menu: chicken wings, corned beef and turkey Reubens, and barbecue, with sides including greens and smoked turkey, mac and cheese, and yams. A dessert cooler is stocked with freshly made desserts, including carrot cake with a nicely tangy cream cheese frosting.
The gumbo had been sold at various spots around town pre-pandemic, including Giant Eagle in the East Hills. He hopes to get back to offering it around town in the near-future, but, for now, it’s Destination Gumbo Time.
Cafe on the Corner: 2700 Shadeland Ave., Marshall-Shadeland;Â cafeonthecornerpgh.org.

Polly Higgins: phiggins@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1960, Twitter @higginspolly, IG @pollyhig.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.