It started with the apple butter.

To build the new Porky Pie pizza, Threadbare Cider House chef Jahmai Suber traveled back in time to a kitchen full of it.
“As a kid, my grandmother would always have big jars of apple butter.” So, he thought, why not start there, and use it as a pizza sauce?
Apple butter makes perfect sense within the context of a cidery. And using it as the base of a pizza paired with candied pork and fresh arugula, well, one taste and the logic is clear there, too.
To make the apple butter, Mr. Suber first tends to the pork loin, letting it sit in a rub of salt, pepper and red pepper flakes for at least 24 hours. It’s rubbed with brown sugar, too, then cooked, its jus reserved ... for that apple butter. Apples are cooked down with fresh thyme and the pork jus, “to add a more savory note.”
The result is a subtle take on a barbecue sauce: mildly sweet, with well-developed caramel flavors balanced by that jus. It’s spread on a crunchy-but-chewy sourdough crust, topped with a cheese blend, thin slivers of the loin, sliced white onion and arugula. It’s dressed in a classic way, adventurously asymmetrical, so that each bite is its own micro-flavor combination — one creamier from a schmear of apple butter, another meltier with a piece of pork.
Mr. Suber’s rendition of the solid pork-apple pairing also nods to the drink list, full of Threadbare’s inventive ciders and meads. The 14% ABV Sweet Mead, aged for 24-plus months and reminiscent of a caramel apple, pairs well, and it’s just one of 20-some meads and ciders on the menu. Flights of four 3-ounce pours cost $10-$12. Local beers and Wigle spirits are available, too.
The Porky Pie ($18) is a limited special, and Suber says it will likely be gone by early February, replaced by another creation. But the regular pizza menu has six options (a veggie with roasted peppers and mushrooms, the Sweet Heat with pepperoni, pickled jalapeño and honey), and that aforementioned crunchy-chewy sourdough crust is so good, you know it’s always bringing its best. Brunch pizzas are available Sundays and range from sweet to savory.
If you’ve never been to Threadbare – the kitchen and dining area are atop the cidery – it’s pocketed in one of those wonderfully Pittsburghian nooks. In residential Spring Garden, your journey will involve:
1) pondering how Pittsburghers got around pre-personal GPS, as you turn onto an increasingly windy web of streets,
2) some travel time on a cobblestone road, and
3) ascending many steps from the parking lot to the dining room (handicapped parking is available on 1294 Voskamp St.).
Threadbare Cider House & Meadery: 1291 Spring Garden Ave., Spring Garden; threadbarecider.com
Polly Higgins: phiggins@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1960, Twitter @higginspolly, IG @pollyhig.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.