After cooking for nearly a decade in Shadyside, Chris Bonfili opened his South Side restaurant Bonfire Food & Drink because he wanted to do something completely different in a new setting.

While he loved the chalkboard cooking he did to rave reviews at the former BYOB Avenue B on Centre Avenue, “I wanted to creatively change it up,” he says, with more of a bar program and a less formal vibe that would appeal to a younger crowd.

He landed on East Carson Street three years ago, both because of its energy and because the building’s former tenants left behind a most amazing kitchen appliance: a wood-burning pizza oven.

“It was definitely a draw,” he says with a laugh.

Advertise with us

As befits the restaurant’s name, many of the chef’s modern American comfort foods are kissed by flames in that wood-burning oven, including a variety of flatbreads, sandwiches and a starter “snacks.” The one that keeps me coming back is the roasted carrot and shishito pepper appetizer ($10). Gluten-free, vegetarian and incredibly simple, it’s nothing short of sublime.

Bonfili near that wood-fired oven (Matt Freed / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The popularity of shishito peppers, a mildly spicy East Asian pepper with thin, wrinkled skin, has grown exponentially over the last decade. Bonfili’s preparation, which has been on the menu since day one, shows why.

The veggies are roasted separately in the oven in a cast-iron skillet until they’re dark and blistered. They’re then placed on a plate that’s been drizzled with wildflower honey and dusted with toasted curry powder for aromatics. It’s finished with some torn fresh mint, a dollop of Greek yogurt and sprinkle of sea salt. Toasted Marcona almonds add a lovely crunch.

“The flavor combo just kind of came to me,” he says. “I like how they all mingle together.”

The snack is not typically a fiery dish — most shishitos are sweet and slightly smoky — but every once in a while, someone bites into that one-in-10 that’s super hot. “That’s why it’s nice to have yogurt on the plate,” he says.

Advertise with us

Somehow it’s not Bonfire’s most popular dish. The vegetable world’s current darling — Brussels sprouts, which Bonfili roasts until crispy and serves with smoked grapes, hazelnuts and a brown butter aioli — remains the restaurant’s No. 1 seller. But the carrot and shishito dish is a “hidden gem” with a dedicated following that includes his own parents.

“It’s a sleeper.”

Bonfire Food & Drink: 2100 East Carson St., South Side; 412-481-3473

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay or IG @pgrecipes.