Lincoln Avenue Brewery had a pretty small menu when it opened for business in July 2019 — just salads and a couple of pressed sandwiches.

“We started with two panini presses in the back,” recalls Shane Saylor, an assistant brewer at the Bellevue brewery his parents, Grant and Lisa, co-own in what used to be a dentist’s office.

That all changed when the brewery upgraded its kitchen with a flat-top grill, allowing chef Victoria Jordan to offer a variety of appetizers, sides, hot sandwiches and even dessert. Passionate about giving patrons a reason to come back again (and again), she switches up its menu quarterly, and also offers weeknight specials that intrigue its small staff “or just sound good,” says Mr. Saylor.

“Even though our menu is still small, it’s very thoughtful,” says Ms. Jordan, 29, who earned her culinary degree 11 years ago from the Art Institute of Pittsburgh. “Everything is made from scratch or sourced locally.”

Advertise with us

One item that consistently hits it out of the park is the brewery’s Reuben Sandwich ($12.75). Available only on Tuesdays, it will make you wish it was available all day, every day.

Among the brewery’s original creations, it’s been a dinner special ever since customers were allowed back into the brewery this spring. “And it really flies off the menu,” says Ms. Jordan.

It starts with the homemade sauerkraut the chef and Grant Saylor make in the same ceramic crock his grandfather used back in the day, 20 pounds at a time, every three weeks.  Seasoned with salt and caraway, the cabbage is allowed to ferment for at least two weeks so the flavor is more mellow than sour.

“There’s a lot of history in that crock,” says Grant Saylor.

Sliced by hand, the corned beef is also made in-house, slow-roasted for six hours in enough pickle juice to cover along with pickling spices — peppercorns, bay leaves, mustard and dill seeds — to add warmth and robust flavor.

Advertise with us
The vegetarian Reuben, with kale. (Alexandra Wimley / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“We also make the Russian dressing,” says Ms. Jordan.

It’s a slightly spicy mix of chopped pickle, red onion, ketchup, mayo and paprika. Grilled on the flattop with Swiss cheese, the Reuben’s finishing touch is the envelope — two slices of BreadWorks rye. It comes with two sides.

The chef, who worked at Tamari, Casbah and the Fairmont before joining the brewery’s staff, also offers a vegetarian version of the hot sandwich ($10.95), which substitutes kale for the corned beef. The veggie is braised with onion and garlic for 3-4 hours until tender, in “a lot of red wine” with crushed red pepper and lemon.

Both are dishes customers look forward to, she says, because of the care the brewery puts into it.

“It feels like it’s made by family.”

Advertise with us

Lincoln Avenue Brewery: 538 Lincoln Ave., Bellevue, 412-212-6363; lincolnavenuebrewery.com

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay or IG @pgrecipes.