Luke Cypher is known for a global take on street food through his Blue Sparrow food truck, which he launched in 2016 to better connect with a hungry public. But he knows how to make a pretty mean wood-fired pizza, too.

Case in point: The Deutschlander pies he churned out by the dozens on Feb. 5 at Pizza Alley, his new takeaway pizza joint in Avalon.

Most wood-fired pizzas come out of the oven with at least a smidgen of tomato sauce on the crust. Not this 12-inch round of savory goodness, nor on the other specialty pizza also featured on opening night: the potato- and egg-topped Good Morning Pizza.

The Deutschlander pizza, topped with apples and kielbasa. (Alexandra Wimley / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Inspired by the food truck’s deep-rooted relationship with the North Side’s Deutschtown neighborhood — it’s a regular at the Deutschtown Music Festival and also frequently pops up at other spots in the neighborhood — the Deutschlander eschews the traditional marriage of tomato and fresh mozzarella for the unexpected combo of sliced Granny Smith apple, smoky kielbasa and the briny burn of pickled mustard seeds.

Advertise with us

The pizza begins its construction with a slather of homemade onion jam. It’s then topped with a blend of shredded mozzarella and sharp Cheddar cheeses before the fruit and sausage are added, along with thin slices of red onion.

“Being on this [north] side of the city, we felt it was an appropriate culinary direction,” says Cypher.

The Good Morning Pizza, conversely, pays homage to breakfast, everyone’s favorite meal. Meant to “warm your body and your soul,” it starts with a base of red eye gravy made from ham drippings and coffee. Mr. Cypher then adds sliced potato crisps and your choice of either sausage or mushroom chorizo, along with Parmesan cheese and a drippy egg.  A drizzle of maple syrup rounds out the perfect mix of sweet and spicy.

While the dedicated spot for takeaway is new (you pick up on the back porch of the building, at the end of a narrow alley), making pizza, for Mr. Cypher, is not: He spent three years working alongside many talented pizzaioli when he was the executive chef at Piccolo Forno in Lawrenceville, “and I worked in other pizza ovens in the past as part of my background,” he says.

Blue Sparrow owner Luke Cypher makes about 200 pies every Saturday in his commissary kitchen. (Alexandra Wimley / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

When the coronavirus pandemic shut down businesses and events across Pittsburgh in March 2020, Mr. Cypher lost almost 50 food jobs, including weddings and festivals. “So we had to pivot,” he says. Rather than add more locations to the food truck’s schedule, he decided instead to start offering the ultimate comfort food — pizza  — on Saturday nights out of the truck’s tiny commissary kitchen on California Avenue in Avalon.

Advertise with us

When the world reopened slightly in 2021, “we saw a change,” with people heading back into restaurants. It was back to trucking full time.

He decided to start making pizza again in December, after a couple of successful pop-ups reminded him and his staff how much fun it was to do something different.  They got “stomped” on their first try, completely selling all but four balls of dough.  “And we’re hoping it is something that gets its own identity and wings so we can continue.”

Now entering Pizza Alley. (Alexandra Wimley / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

In addition to two specialty pie options each week ($14), customers can choose from three core pizzas: the cheese McCallister ($8), Fungus Amongus featuring wild mushroom chorizo, pickled cabbage and miso garlic sauce ($11) and The Sparrow, topped with Parma Sausage pepperoni, fresh basil, pickled banana peppers and hot chili “moon sauce” ($11). You can view that week’s menu and order online.

“It’s the same global ingredients,” says Mr. Cypher, “only via a different vehicle.” Everything from the dough to the sauces to the pineapple kimchi on a recent “Moana”-inspired “Heart of Te Fiti” pizza with huli huli chicken is made in house.

Because Pizza Alley is only open from 4 to 8 p.m. Saturdays, and Mr. Cypher and his staff can only make four pies at a time, they’re limited to a maximum of 200 pizzas a night. But you can order in advance as soon as the menu is posted Wednesdays on Blue Sparrow’s website and Instagram. You get a text when it’s ready.

Advertise with us

Mr. Cypher had originally hoped to turn the Avalon space into a beer garden coming out of the pandemic, but the high cost of renovations has put those plans on hold; for now, it’s really just about takeout. But in warmer weather, customers are welcome to eat their pizzas on a small deck overlooking the Ohio River, he says.

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay or IG @pittsburghpgfood.