For small businesses — particularly food-centric ones — cheeky wordplay and puns have always made for memorable place names. Greater Pittsburgh has no shortage of them.

Right now in Allegheny County (among many others) there exists: Back to the Foodture, Burgatory, Butcher & the Rye, Coop de Ville, Crust Almighty, Mad Mex, Onion Maiden, Riley’s Pour House and Thai Me Up.

But when it comes to cleverly coined commercial turns-of-phrase, going forward it will be hard to beat the name of the new-ish little spot tucked on the corner sliver of the McKees Rocks Plaza. It’s A Pizza Cake Cafe opened in March by a couple taking a leap of faith to pursue a dream in what has become known as The Great Resignation.

“We have people come in just because of the name,” said co-owner Brandy Carroll, who dreamed it up. “We had a guy who was in town from Maryland and said he had to stop by after he heard about the name.”

Advertise with us
Brandy Carroll in her McKees Rocks restaurant. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

As suggested, it is indeed a cafe that specializes in big cuts of thin-crust pizzas and deep-dish Chicago-style pies, along with a bevy of baked goods — cookies, cupcakes, brownies, pies and cakes. It also serves breakfast calzones, and lunchtime paninis, soups and salads. Everything is made daily from scratch.

“We're here early, making dough, making the sauce. We're not just pulling it out of the can and, you know, popping it out of the freezer.”

Ms. Carroll, 44, and her husband, Leon, 46, are among millions of Americans who have reevaluated their working lives and made a bold change in the face of the COVID-19 pandemic. She worked in corporate America her entire adult life; he worked in food service for Aramark at Three Rivers Stadium and the Civic Arena and later for Parkhurst before becoming a steelworker.

“We were both at the same time, we were just done,” she said. “Right as the pandemic hit, it was just so much pressure at work for both of us. It was literally causing health issues, and just unbelievable stress. And we weren't being very nice to each other.

Order a thin-crust or deep-dish pie. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“We've always talked about opening a diner or something with food, because that is his happy space,” she continued. “And we thought there's never going to be a perfect time. Let's just do it. Now. Let's take this misery and turn it into something great.”

Advertise with us

They connected with developer Craig Rippole and Trinity Development, which is active in the Rocks. It’s a convenient spot with some personal connection. The Carrolls live nearby in Crafton, and she said when her grandmother came to Pittsburgh from Arkansas decades ago, she first lived in McKees Rocks.

They quit their jobs in July 2020, and spent the rest of the year developing their plan.

“We were initially thinking of a diner, but [Leon] loves making pizza,” she said, adding that she became an avid baker after their daughter was born.

“It's been years of just talking about it and talking about it. But we both reached a point in our careers where it was like, this is not healthy. When it gets to a point where you're just so frustrated every single day, then you have to figure out what makes you happy.

Pastries, including cupcakes, are also on the menu. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“Don't get me wrong. It’s not all strawberries and butterflies. It's absolutely scary, because we have an 11-year old to think about,” she said. “A couple of our friends were like, you legit stepped out on faith. I'm like, trust me. I know. There are days when, if you really think about it, the anxiety level can go through the roof.”

Advertise with us

But that is outweighed by the satisfaction of the work itself, and the business they’re building together.

“We enjoy it,” she said. “We come in and we're happy.”

Dan Gigler: gdgigler@post-gazette.com; @gigs412 on Instagram and Twitter.