One of the loveliest stories I heard this year was told to me while I was reporting a story about Point Breeze’s Frick Park Market, by Ron Fuchs, whose parents opened it in 1941 and who lived upstairs. On Christmas Eves, his mother Mary would treat grocery customers to pony bottles of cold Rolling Rock beer and plates of steaming hot fried smelts.

You might ask, What are smelts? (Ron adds the s, as some people do.) They’re an old-fashioned food, once hugely popular around the Great Lakes, especially in my native Michigan, where people still go “dipping” for them with nets when the fish run in the spring and angle for them with tiny hooks in winter, and in other coastal areas. They’re also favored by Southern Italian people at the holidays for their Feasts of the Seven Fishes.

Smelts are small fish that traditionally are served nearly whole, with the heads and guts removed, but with the fins and scales and bones. Don’t squirm — they can be delicious.

They’re just more scarce than they used to be. You have to look for them, but this is the time of year to have better luck. Wholey’s is serving them from its hot foods kitchen, and New Kensington’s Fazio's Pizza and Italian Foods was taking orders for customers’ Christmas dinners. I know of a few other places, such as the Crane Room Grill near New Castle and Italian Villa in Ambridge, that keep them on the menu. But I wanted to find them at a South Hills place that serves them with beer. I found smelts available, if not on the regular menu, at a couple appropriately old-school restaurants, including Dorido’s in South Park and Solomon’s Seafood & Grille in Washington, Pa. (If you know a great place that serves them, email me, especially if they’re fried by someone’s mom.)

Advertise with us

After confirming that it would have the smelts starting last week, I drove down to Solomon’s, which I’d just recently heard about, even though it’s been open for more than 32 years. It’s tucked away on the edge of Washington, across from the post office and the old Pennsylvania Railroad station. I immediately loved the taxidermied swordfish and other trophy ocean fish on the walls.

I told the server I was angling for a much smaller catch. No smelts, she said — those are only for the Christmas Eve dinners to go. Ask the kitchen, I pleaded. She returned and said the cook would make me an order — the first of the season. “Nobody tells me anything,” she said, and proceeded to tell me how the menu used to always have smelts. She made a face.

Soon, she brought a pound of them on a plate, with tartar and cocktail sauce — my preference — for $12.95, with a $3 side of slaw. They were missing their tails, which make for crunchy handles, and they weren’t breaded but rather battered, a little too much. But they were steaming hot and not too greasy, sweet mild-tasting and they hit the spot. Especially with a pint of Great Lakes Christmas Ale.

Try smelts with a good friend whom you haven’t seen in a while for a fishy, old-fashioned taste of holidays past.

Solomon’s Seafood & Grille: 222 Hall Ave. Washington, Pa., 724-222-0898; solomonseafood.com.

Advertise with us

Update: Findlay reader Marc Grandinetti, who says “I come from a family of full blooded Italians,” shares this Beaver County tip: “Lil Joe’s in Beaver Falls has the best smelts I’ve ever had.” They’re butterflied and they do look delicious on the Facebook page of the 7th Avenue bar & grille, which serves them by the half ($6.99) and full pound ($12.99).

Meanwhile, my South Side colleague Dan Gigler offers a word for the Buttermilk Fried Smelts with Calabrian chili aioli and lemon ($13) at Stagioni: “Fantastic.”

Bob Batz Jr.: bbatz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1930 and on Twitter @bobbatzjr.