It’s a Tuesday evening and Sophia Milinkovic is in full “maniac mode,” but that’s not a bad thing. In fact, it’s going to make quite a few people on the North Side happy.
She was making final preparations for the grand re-opening Wednesday of the Monterey Pub, the beloved “third place” for residents of the Mexican War Streets and surrounding neighborhoods.
“Man, we're moving. Definitely hustling. Trying to get everything up and ready,” she said, half exasperated, half excited.
The pub had closed during the pandemic and was sold over the summer. That sale fell through and Ms. Milinkovic, a long-tenured local bartender who previously worked at Federal Galley and Kaya, teamed with chef D.J. Hitchman (also of Kaya) and partners Monica Zmuda and Richard Krist to reopen it.
“We're all working together to kind of clean it up and give it a facelift. We’re trying to keep it moderately historic,” Ms. Milikovic said. “Because we do know that it means a lot to a lot of people. We did not change structural things. We just kind of gave it a nice clean and a paint job and some things here and there.”
As so many in the service industry have done, Ms. Milikovic thought hard about changing careers in the wake of the pandemic and having a “summer of Sophia,” she said, referencing a Seinfeld episode.
Read More
“I put my notice in with [the Galley Group] and took a step away because I thought honestly I was going to exit the industry. But then all of a sudden that ended abruptly because this came about,” she said, noting that she and Mr. Hitchman had talked for years about opening a place. “I mean, it's honestly an opportunity you can't really pass up.”
Set in the middle of a residential block of stately Victorian homes on Monterey Street, the Irish pub is the “living room of the neighborhood,” with wooden booths and antique fixtures, as described in a 2013 Post-Gazette feature. During Prohibition, it was a barbershop.
The Monterey was part of a trinity of historic eating and drinking spots in the neighborhood that closed in recent years. The James Street Tavern shut its doors in 2017 and the Park House closed last year.

But earlier this month, WESA reported that James Street building owner Jonathan Iams had secured a $500,000 loan from the Stadium and Exhibition Authority to bring live music back to the building next year, coupled with a planned restaurant. The Park House also will reopen in 2022, per posts on the business’ social media.
The return of those classics, plus a slew of highly regarded new restaurants including Fig & Ash, 40 North, Siempre Algo and The Coop, point toward a North Side resurgence a few decades in the making.
At Monterey Pub, Mr. Hitchman has a modest menu of appetizers ($7-$9), sandwiches ($12-$13), flatbreads ($12) and smashburgers ($11-$13). The pub’s fish and chips ($15) and shepherd’s pie ($16) will return, but Ms. Milinkovic said the menu will change frequently. As for drinks, expect everything from a pint of Guinness to craft beers, classic martinis and craft cocktails.
“We're trying to live up to and pay homage to a place that has meant so much to so many people for decades, if not a century,” Ms. Milinkovic said. “We're trying to keep the integrity [but] welcoming new and fun things.... The neighbors mean a lot, it means a lot to the neighbors. We want to make sure that that stays the same, and that we continue to be a part of this heritage and history and, you know, do it right.”
Monterey Pub: 1227 Monterey St., Mexican War Streets
Dan Gigler: gdgigler@post-gazette.com; @gigs412 on Instagram and Twitter.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.