Who doesn’t like a bonfire? Especially when it’s a punny play on a restaurant owner’s name, Chris Bonfili, who opened his South Side place, Bonfire Food & Drink, in late 2018.
Mr. Bonfili, whose longtime Shadyside restaurant, Avenue B, closed earlier last year, steered himself into an upgrade: A sleek two-story place with casual dining downstairs and a tailored restaurant on the second floor. It’s an ambitious expansion that builds on his Sewickley operation, B Gourmet and its catering arm.
For the purposes of this review, like other bi-level restaurants in town with different menus on each floor, I’m looking at the downstairs casual concept first.
The downstairs features a menu of super accessible dishes from snacks and flatbreads to salads, burgers and mains: It’s a conservative menu of crowd-pleasers — with language that’s less conservative, like the Basic AF mac and cheese ($14) or the Basic AF burger ($13).
I wish it were better: that service was less slack and dishes were more on point as far as execution. But restaurants are fluid, and Mr. Bonfili has a good reputation and knows what he’s doing. A couple visits from a critic don’t always point to how the place will be in the fall, with staff changes, more time to work out kinks, and to build a neighborhood clientele.
There are lots of tactics that critics use to assess a restaurant, one of them asking friends to serve as guinea pigs, whether it’s dining in the restaurant with us, at the same time at a different table, showing up early, or whatever. But what I’ve found is that we’re not in a super-tailored restaurant moment — I’d guess that most owners would say something like, “Take it or leave it; critics be damned.” The customers — especially those who are loyal to longtime hometown restaurateurs — are the judges who count.
Read More
Bonfire Food & Drink
2100 E. Carson St. South Side 412-481-3473

Hours: Downstairs, 11 a.m. to midnight, Monday to Thursday, 11 a.m. to 1 a.m. Friday, 3 p.m. to 1 a.m. Saturday, 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. brunch and regular service from 3 to 11 p.m. Sunday.
Prices: Snacks $9 to $15, salads $7 to $15, flatbreads $14 to $15, mac $14 to $16, sandwiches $13 to $15 and mains $21 to $25.
Sound level: Easy for conversation when it’s not crowded.
Details: Street parking, wheelchair accessible, OpenTable reservations.
Wild card: Daily specials include mac Mondays ($10 mac ’n’ cheese); Tuesday and Friday, half off snacks and flatbreads after 9 p.m.; wine Wednesdays for half-off select bottles; Thursday burgers for $10 and select beers for $3, and half price drafts from 3 to 5 p.m. Saturdays.
I appreciate that on lots of levels. Still, it’s telling when a pair of women are treated to surly service by waitstaff at the bar — until their friend, the critic, showed up. Whether the staff was having a bad day, or there was a gendered assumption that a pair of women equals overly demanding customers, who knows?
When customers come in to have a nice time and are made to feel they’re not wanted — when there are a dozen other restaurants to choose from — what’s the incentive to go back? Probably any restaurant across the city would say they’re struggling to find staff and this could happen just about anywhere right now. But that doesn’t mean customers should take it on the chin.
Tableside service with the same server was smoother, as you’d guess, along with the manager checking in often to see that things were going well.
On both my visits, as servers got the heads up, they were quick to ensure we were well hydrated — and those drinks won’t set you back too much, from the cocktail named in homage to Prince, like the Purple Rain with Bluecoat Gin, Creme de Violette and sparkling wine, or the Suffering Bastard with Bulleit, gin, lemon and ginger ($9). Wines by the glass fall in the $8 to $11 range, with a short list of beers from domestics for $4 to $8 for something like Hitchhiker or 11th Hour Brewing.
You can start with a flatbread like the White, with broccoli rabe, fennel, Taleggio cheese and fried garlic ($15), or opt for the Philly-inspired Cheesesteak, with lamb, cheddar, pepper and onions. With a cracker-like crust and a sheen of ingredients, it’s just the right ratios.
Among snacks, we gravitated to the shishito peppers with roasted carrots, curry, mint, almonds, and yogurt ($9) — which was a strange dish, mostly because that yogurt was vanilla instead of a more savory plain. At this point, we were trying to figure out how the wood-fire came in. Yes, the flatbread was kissed by fire. But the vegetables were bordering on raw. On another visit, crispy Brussels sprouts served with smoked grapes, hazelnuts and a brown butter aioli was much better than that yogurt concoction.
The mac was our favorite, coated with a fontina-Parmesan blend and served in cast-iron, garnished with a heavy helping of bread crumbs; it’s stick-to-your-ribs fare that I’d return for any day. Another go-to, the Basic AF burger, came with a well-dressed salad with ribbons of carrots. Thick and flavorful, the burger is better than most — even if it arrived looking a little squished — and a value on Thursday $10 burger nights.
The hanger steak was kind of a disaster. “I can’t eat this,” said my friend, one of the people who was ignored at the bar. None of us could, as it was a medium rare order of raw meat with overdressed arugula and soggy potatoes ($25). Yes, we should have sent it back; and if it happens to you, I’m telling you that you should. But with the spread before us, we decided to let it go.
The steak presentation goes back to the name and that wood-fired oven: You’d expect more lusty, roasted, dishes that, if you took them out of context, you could look at the plate and see signs from the fire: how it imparts flavor in vegetables and cooks meat. It’s not there yet.
I really want to like this restaurant. But for now, it has some work to do.
Melissa McCart: mmccart@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.