We’re at a crossroads in which every major city has welcomed with open arms corporate-owned concepts that introduce us to dishes-from-elsewhere, whether it’s Japanese ramen, Hawaiian poke, Nashville hot chicken, Texas barbecue or Mexi-Cali tacos.

Aside from what this is doing to the restaurant landscape, it’s worth asking whether any of these dishes will have staying power: When does a regional dish from another place resonate with locals for the long haul? What does it take for an outsider dish to be considered one of ours?

We can look to Buffalo wings, ubiquitous everywhere, for regional dishes that have precedent. And more specific to Pittsburgh, there’s the pepperoni roll, an Italian-American treat from the coal mines of West Virginia, that you’ll find at Jimmy and Nino Sunseri Co. and Mancini’s Bakery, both in the Strip — and beyond.

But there’s a lesser-known regional import that’s had a long, under-the-radar history in the area, even though it appears as if it just arrived. And it’s on the menu at DiAnoia’s Eatery that opened in the Strip nearly two years ago: It’s the Lebanon sweet bologna sandwich served during lunch.

Advertise with us

Back when chef-owner Dave Anoia rolled out the sandwich, he said customers hadn’t yet warmed up to Lebanon sweet bologna as a go-to.

Yet nearly a year later, it had become a favorite, from Dan Gigler writing about it for the Post-Gazette, to Bill Fuller of Big Burrito at DiAnoia’s for lunch, who pointed it out as a Pennsylvania regional specialty and asked if I’d had it yet: I hadn’t.

DiAnoia's Lebanon sweet bologna is a formidable sandwich but not unwieldy. The heart of it shows off a salami-like meat that some have called Pennsylvania Dutch-style summer sausage, pointing to its roots in Lebanon, Pa., nearly 250 miles away.

Made with 100 percent slightly fermented, smoked beef, the sandwich features thick slices stacked on a Kaiser roll, bedecked with tomato, a fried egg and provolone, then slathered with Calabrian chili mayo. With enough sandwich bling to seduce a skeptic, it’s not surprising that it’s now among the top five best-sellers at DiAnoia’s.

Lebanon sweet bologna also beckons with a seductive scent, a little sour and a hint of sweet and smoke — one of those sandwiches that, if you’re standing in line trying to figure out what to order, you’d smell it as a server walks through the dining room to deliver one, and you'd confirm your decision to order it right then.

Advertise with us

The thing is, Lebanon sweet bologna isn’t really a restaurant dish, Mr. Anoia says, citing his childhood, when he “rarely went out to eat.” Like deli ham or turkey, Lebanon sweet bologna was something you’d eat at home — with mustard and tomatoes, on white Italian bread. When I asked him if he remembers ever eating Lebanon sweet bologna out, he struggled to remember a place that might carry it.

Mr. Anoia has been getting his bologna from Central Pennsylvania by a local purveyor. But in fact, it’s been for sale at more than 50 Giant Eagle grocery stores since at least the early 2000s.

“It looks like we introduced the product in 2004,” says Giant Eagle spokesman Dick Roberts. Or at least that’s when it was entered in the Giant Eagle system, he says, and it’s currently available at most supermarkets, including 56 in the Pittsburgh area.

“While we don’t know exactly why the decision to carry the product was made back then, today Giant Eagle is dedicated to delivering customers unique, high-quality, delicious items, and Seltzer’s Lebanon Bologna is a great example of that which our customers have responded positively to," he wrote.

A local or two who grew in the area told me they also remember eating it at home in the ’70s and ’80s in Mt. Lebanon, as it was for sale at the now-closed Kroger.

Advertise with us

The brand at the Shadyside Giant Eagle is Seltzer’s from Palmyra — for $9.99 a pound. Mr. Anoia said the runner-up is Groff’s based in Elizabethtown, Lebanon County, a place that also offers poultry, pork and beef, as a more traditional butchering operation.

Seltzer’s, on the other hand, is a Lebanon sweet bologna specialty outfit, with variations that include original and sweet versions, smoke’n honey, double smoked and chipotle-laced.

The name and the craftsmanship, according to the site, is rooted in 19th century German foodways, with Pennsylvania Germans introducing their “Old World butchering, curing and sausage-making skills” in making the product, with a distinct taste, locals say, that comes from fermentation and old smokehouses.

Brad Thomas Parsons, who wrote about Lebanon sweet bologna for the online magazine Taste, took a tour of the place and confirms that, after the beef is coarsely cut, and laced with salt, sugar and “proprietary spices,” it ferments, then goes through another grind before it’s put into its form, then cold-smoked for up to three days.

Seltzer’s, he reports, is one of the only federally inspected meat plants in the country still using natural smoke as opposed to stainless steel smokehouses.

Advertise with us

Unlike that grocery store ham or turkey in the deli case, Lebanon sweet bologna is not as humble — in part because the elaborate process of its creation mirrors what you’d find among charcuterie on a salumi board. But like Italian mortadella, it’s more versatile.

“It’s great cold. It’s great fried. It’s great on a sandwich. We use it to stuff cornetti pasta with it for brunch,” says Mr. Anoia.

“You’re not gonna cut cubes of lunchmeat and serve it to somebody when they come over for dinner,” he says, “but I sure as hell would serve this.”

Melissa McCart: mmccart@post-gazette.com