A new generation of pizzaiolos is rising in Pittsburgh.
They are young, passionate perfectionists and stick to an artisanal script. For them, the ultimate pizza is about the dough and not so much about the topping.
Neil Blazin (Driftwood Oven), David Anoia (Pizzeria Davide), Kevin Konn (Romulus-al Taglio), Sara Boyer (Iron Born Pizza), Chris Bartko (Gabagool Pizzeria), Michael Mercurio (Mercurio’s) and Anthony Ambeliotis (Mediterra Bakehouse) will stretch and bake their signature pies and serve them oven-hot on June 23 at the PizzaFest — A Slice of Delish.
The 21-plus event, which is from 6 to 9 p.m. at The Pennsylvania Market in the Strip District, will feature demos on how to stretch dough and make mozzarella. Ole Smoky Whiskey Distillery and Arsenal Cider House will will pour whiskeys and hard ciders, and discuss how best to pair them with pizzas..
Tickets are $25 online or $35 at the door.
“We are always looking for something new and people here love their pizza,” says Dee Weinberg of Good Taste Pittsburgh, who is hosting the event. “So we wanted to show the high-end of pizzas.”
MEET THE ARTISANS

Kevin Konn, 38, Romulus Pizza al Taglio
The Mt. Lebanon native attended the now-closed Le Cordon Bleu but settled on making pizzas after going to Seattle. After learning to make Roman pizzas, known for their hydrated dough and slow fermentation, from Massimiliano Saieva at the Roman Pizza Academy in Miami, he opened shop at The Pennsylvania Market in the Strip District last November. He now holds classes on making Roman-style pizzas and helped in picking the participants for the festival.
Pizza for the fest.
“Justin Balla, my partner in crime, and I will have two kinds of Roman pizzas. One is a classic Margherita pizza topped with San Marzano tomatoes, housemade mozzarella and basil. The other is a deconstructed pierogi pizza with Yukon potato puree, cheddar cheese, caramelized onions and kielbasa.”
What sets apart a Roman pizza?
“It is rectangular but is not a Sicilian pizza, which is more dense. The very hydrated dough and fermentation process distinguishes a Roman pizza. The dough has less flour and more water — almost 90% water. I cold proof the dough for four days, then ball the dough and let it sit for eight days at room temp before stretching it out.”
And the crust?
“It looks like it is heavy but it is not because of the air pockets. It is light and crispy and won’t make you want to run a marathon. But it’s more than a snack. I don’t like to use treated flours.”

Are you about the dough or topping?
“I’m always about the dough, which is a great vessel to hold everything. You have to taste the extra-virgin olive oil and the flour. I was taught to make it by the best of the best — Massimiliano Saieva. Science and math are involved in making it.”
What is your beverage of choice with pizza?
“Coke. I will drink the beer afterwards.”
Your go-to pizza?
“It is a marinara pizza with San Marzano tomatoes, cherry tomatoes, fresh garlic, oregano and no cheese. It should not be overwhelmed with toppings.”
What’s your fave shop in town?
It’s Don Campiti’s Pizzeria in Dormont. The pizza is thin and crispy and I grew up on it. It tastes of memories and brings me home.”

Michael Mercurio, 33, Mercurio’s
When he was 8, Michael Mercurio started helping his parents at the Shadyside shop. Today, he and his sister, Anna Crucitt, are the co-owners and use traditional Italian techniques and ingredients. He visits Italy almost every year and seeks to reflect his experience in Pittsburgh. “Every day, I strive to make pizzas that are properly stretched and have the right hydration and fermentation.”
Pizza for the fest.
“I will be bringing gluten-free dough and some regular dough as well. I will be making our Del Re, which has a white truffle sauce, sauteed button mushrooms and prosciutto, and a red sauce pizza with Buffalo mozzarella. I will be sneaking in other things but I don’t know what they are at this point.”
Are you about the dough or toppings?
“I firmly believe in the dough. It can be of any style but I think it should have the least amount of toppings so that the dough is showcased. The dough should have the right amount of hydration to have good air pockets and should show healthy fermentation. It should have the right amount of aging. It cannot last too long as it will be too sour.”
What about the dough’s taste and texture?
“I make mine with water, yeast and salt. I am against adding sugar and don’t oil either. The crust should be soft, light and airy. When you bite into it, you should feel and hear that slight crunch.”

Do you like a thin or a thick crust?
By trade, I like a thin airy crust. But I really love eating a thicker style. I have heart for it as it reminds me of my childhood. I grew up in Kittanning and there was one in town that sold a thick, heavy, dense Sicilian pizza.
What’s your fave shop now?
“Iron Born. I have known Pete [Tolman] my whole life. He is my best buddy and has the best pizza.”
Are you a red or white sauce guy?
“I am about the red sauce because that reflects a true pizza.”
What’s the secret to a good red sauce?
“The tomatoes should be naturally sweet enough. I like to use the Ciao San Marzano tomatoes.”
What’s your beverage of choice for pizza?
“If I’m going for a flavor profile, it is water. But everyone loves a cold beer with pizza. They match.”
What do you think about flatbread pizzas?
“They go against what I try to do. They are more like a hard cracker, and a horror cracker in some situations.”

Anthony Ambeliotis, 33, Mediterra Bakehouse
Mediterra Bakehouse in Robinson has been making artisan bread since 2002 but it started selling artisan pizzas when it opened a cafe in Sewickly last June. Anthony Ambeliotis found that pizzas made with leftover bread dough were amazing and went with the Roman-style as it focused on the dough. “I am relatively new to the pizza world but my hands have been in bread dough my entire life.”
Pizza for the fest.
“I will be using a Roman-style dough drizzled with olive oil. The pizza will be crisp and airy. It won’t have anything on top but it will have a slice of mortadella inside. When you eat it hot, it will be the best thing you had.”
What defines your pizza?
“The amount of water in my dough is very high — it is 85% to 90% hydrated. So the dough makes a soft tender crust with a crisp bottom. I also leave it to ferment in the cooler for 96 hours then cut the dough into balls and leave it to ferment for another 24 hours at room temperature. The slow fermentation unlocks the flavors of the grains.”

What shouldn’t be in the dough?
“Never add sugar. That’s done when you don’t want to ferment the dough. I think it’s cheating to add sugar.”
What should be in a good sauce?
“It needs to have a good balance. It is not enough to have the best tomatoes. The sauce should be seasoned properly and you should keep the cooking time in mind. It is cooked when you first make it and cooked again on the crust in the oven. So remember you are double cooking it.”
Do you have a favorite pizza?
“It is the New York-style pizza. When you get a good one, everything is in balance — the crust, cheese, sauce and even the grease on top. I am also a huge pepperoni guy, and love extra red sauce.”
And your fave shop in town?
“Il Pizzaiolo in Mt. Lebanon. Their Neapolitan pizzas are the best there is.”
What do you drink with pizza?
“Peroni. It is made for pizza.”

Neil Blazin, 37, Driftwood Oven
What started off as a roving wood-fired pizza oven by Neil Blazin and Justin Vetter has been in a brick-and-mortar space in Lawrenceville for just over a year now. Chef Blazin is known for his sourdough pizzas and tops them with locally sourced vegetables and meats. “My pizzas are made with a lot of care, and everything is from scratch.”
Pizza for the fest.
“I will be making a sourdough pizza in the Neapolitan category. There will be a Margherita and I will probably do a bianca, too. I will be bringing a wood-fired oven.”
What makes a good crust?
“The formulas change depending on the style. The crust should be crispy with a crunch, but also have some chewiness.”

Do you like red or white sauce?
“My go-to-grab is a red. It is just the classic American pizza.”
Are you a thin or a thick crust guy?
“I prefer thicker crust pizzas as I enjoy eating bread.”
What do you think about toppings?
“Keep it simple and well sourced. Handmade mozzarella, tomatoes, basil and good olive oil is all you need for great pizza. I’d argue you don’t even need the cheese. Pizza has a wonderful ability to showcase ingredients in their simplest forms.”
How much topping is too much?
“When you are forced to use a fork and knife to eat a pizza because the toppings are sliding off a soggy crust.”
What’s your beverage of choice?
“Personally, I think wine pairs best. Wine generally provides a wide variety of flavors and pairs nicely with different styles of pizza and toppings.”
And your go-to pizza?
“One with pepperoni, mushroom and garlic.”
Do you have a fave shop in town?
“The last one I went to was Pizzeria Davide and had an Old World Style with pepperoni.”

Sara Boyer, 32, Iron Born Pizza
Iron Born is renowned for its Detroit-inspired pizza and its thick but airy crust and crispy cheese edge. Pete Tolman opened it at the Smallman Galley in June 2017 and a second location in Millvale last year. On June 2, Iron Born closed shop in Smallman and is opening one at 1808 Smallman St. in August. Sara Boyer has been the general manager at the business since December 2017.
Pizza for the fest.
“We have not yet decided. But it will be a twist on our two most popular pies — the red pie (pepperoni and garlic oil) and the spicy pie (soppressata, pepperoni, banana peppers and Mike’s Hot Honey).”
What makes a good dough?
“It should have a crisp bottom but still be chewy. It should not be too dense or too soggy.”

What kind of cheese do you use?
“I use a blend of mozzarella and provolone. A blended cheese covers the pizza better and has a nice pull. I also use a cheese at the tail end to give the pizza a good flavor. I use Swiss on a Cubano and Parmesan on a white.”
Do you like red or white sauce?
“It depends on my mood. I like both a red pie and a garlic cream pie.”
How much topping is too much topping?
“It is too much when it starts to overpower the cheese.”
Beverage of choice?
“It is a toss-up between beer and Coke. I like something with bubbles.”
Your go-to pizza?
“One with pepperoni and ricotta.”
What’s your fave shop in town?
“Driftwood Oven. I tend to go for their specialty one because of the unusual pairing.”

Dave Anoia, 35, Pizzeria Davide
In the beginning of May, Dave and Aimee Anoia opened a to-go shop, which is connected to their DiAnoia’s Eatery in the Strip District, when demand for their Old World pizzas started growing. The pie features a New York-style chewy crust, sliced provolone, Italian tomato sauce and is topped with Parmesan, oregano and basil.
Pizza for the fest.
“It will be an Old World pizza with a red sauce that is sweeter than an average pie. But I’m not sure about the toppings at this point.”

What defines a pizza — the crust or sauce?
“It’s more a ratio thing than any particular part of the pizza. Each one plays a role. My favorite is the crust because I have more control over it and can be creative with it. Most people are not making their cheese or growing their tomatoes.”
What is key about the dough?
“I think it is about the fermentation process. It is about how long you let it ferment before you ball it and after you form the dough balls. The dough should also be a little sweet.”
What about the toppings?
“I like to keep it simple and don’t like to put more than two on a pie. So it will be prosciutto and arugula or soppressata and mushrooms.”
When is it too much?
“If you put all four of them it will be too much. The bottom of the pizza will have no structure, get heavy and become soggy. It’s just not appealing.”
Red or white sauce?
“I’m a 100% red pie person. I think you need to have tomatoes. You need that red goodness because that’s what makes a pizza.”
What do you think about the flatbread pizza invasion?
“I don’t really like it. They should leave the word pizza out of it.”
Your go-to pizza?
“It should have a crisp crust. I like the New York style because it has a crisp crunch at the bottom.”
What’s your fave shop in town?
“Pizza Taglio in East Liberty. All the pizzas there are good, but I especially liked Pig Face, which has been taken off the menu. I’ve been telling [owner] Tony [Giamarita] to get it back.”

Chris Bartko, 31, Gabagool Pizzeria
The North Huntingdon native worked in pizzerias while in high school and college and now has a “gypsy food truck that goes anywhere and everywhere” but primarily pulls by breweries in Western Pennsylvania. He takes inspiration from the New York and Neapolitan styles and blends the two for a “semi-Neapolitan version and bakes the pies a little longer.”
Pizza for the fest.
“I will be making Threat Level Midnight,” which is a garlic-ricotta-cream cheese pie with mozzarella, Italian sausage and hot peppers. It is topped with green onions, grana padano cheese and honey. We break our own rule with this one as it has a ton of toppings. But the toppings are balanced and portioned appropriately, so it gets a pass.”
What’s the story behind the name of your truck and pies?
“They are all related to ‘The Office.’ Gagagool is from the episode when Michael Scott thinks he’s being shaken down by the mob. Prison Mike [for a pizza] comes from a joke in another episode.”
Does the crust or topping play a bigger role?
“I would say both. There needs to be an overall balance.”
What do you look for in a dough?
“It should be fermented pretty well. We view time as an ingredient in the dough. It should not have enriched or bleached flours.”
What about the toppings?
“I am not a chef by trade and don’t have a formal understanding of food. I learned to make pizzas when I was in high school and college. I’m not a fan of a ton of cheese and believe less is more when it comes to the number of ingredients.”
Your favorite kind of pizza?
“Even though I make thin-crusted ones, I like eating thick- and thin-crusted pizzas. My favorite is a Sicilian Grandma’s pie.”
What’s your fave shop in town?
“That’s tough; it’s like picking your favorite kid. I like Ianni’s Pizzeria in Delmont. [There also is a shop in New Derry.] I love Driftwood’s peach and summer corn pizza.”
Where will you be next?
“I will be at Stick City Brewing Co. in Mars on June 29 and Yellow Bridge Brewing in Delmont on July 6.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.