Augustine’s Pizza — the name behind the pies sold for $8.75 each at PNC Park — is back in the game.

Less than five years after a devastating fire wiped out the New Castle-based restaurant and factory, the owners say that the pizza remains the same, but their focus has shifted.

While wholesaling to grocery stores such as O’Hara-based Giant Eagle continues to make up a portion of the company’s revenue, Augustine’s now provides pizza and calzones for local fundraisers, boosting the bottom line and raising the company’s profile, all while supporting a community for which they feel unyielding gratitude.

“It's nice to help folks make money while you make money,” said CEO Frank J. Augustine, 31. “It just kind of makes you feel good about what you do.”

Advertise with us

Each pizza and calzone sold yields $2 for causes ranging from local Relay for Life charity walks to high school marching bands. So far, the company has helped local community groups raise tens of thousands of dollars, Mr. Augustine said.

The November 2014 fire left the company’s former storefront — its home since the early 1960s — in tatters, with just one machine and an off-site truckload of pizzas salvageable.

Even with insurance paying for damages and an “unbelievable” response from the community — according to Frank’s father and store co-owner, Frank R. Augustine — the fire produced a sense of anguish for the family.

Nonetheless, they soldiered on.

To avoid rationing the 1,800 pies that survived, Mr. Augustine said the company decided to sell them to community members for charity, ultimately donating roughly $11,000 to the local Toys for Tots.

Advertise with us

Just six months later, pizzas were back in the oven at a new, 11,000-square-foot facility in New Castle, capping off an anxiety-filled stretch that Mr. Augustine likened to a wartime footing.

“I thought I knew a lot about pizza,” he said. “I knew nothing about pizza.

“We kind of had to start from scratch with machinery, what we had to buy, our whole process.”

Along with the move came a new nitrogen-based machine that freezes pizzas significantly faster than a traditional freezer, giving them a fresher taste when they reach stadium-goers’ palates.

Some aspects of the business didn’t change, though — and likely won’t for the foreseeable future.

Advertise with us

Despite temporarily laying off all of its roughly two dozen employees after the fire, nearly every single one returned, helping to facilitate a smoother relaunch.

One of those employees, Mike Tanner — whose uncle Chuck managed the World Series-winning 1979 Pirates team — has mixed dough at the factory for three decades.

When asked how much longer he planned to stay in that role, Mr. Tanner chuckled and glanced toward Mr. Augustine.

‘‘Till I’m gone,” he said. “You’ve got to deal with me till I’m gone.”

The family’s pizza recipe has remained virtually unaltered from the one used when Augustine’s first opened its doors to customers in the ’50s. The thick, fluffy dough and seemingly overflowing quantity of tomato sauce remain the company’s signature, despite the drawbacks.

Advertise with us

“When you take a bite out of your pizza, you better watch your pants, you better watch your shoes, because there’s going to be some sauce coming out,” says the elder Mr. Augustine, whose business card refers to him as “special agent,” having ceded executive duties to his son before the fire.

“It's just our thing, it’s our niche, it’s what people love,” the younger Mr. Augustine added.

Augustine’s had sold its frozen pizzas to PNC Park since 2011, but after the 2014 fire, had trouble producing the roughly 20,000 7-inch pies per season that are consumed during ballgames and other events.

When the Pirates approached the company about renewing the relationship for the 2019 season, the Augustines jumped at the opportunity, knowing their facility — which uses upward of 5,500 pounds of flour and 2,000 pounds of cheese each week — could fully handle the workload.

In addition to the revenue and name recognition that comes with the deal, a sense of pride seems to play a role as well.

Advertise with us

“It's neat to go to a Pirates game and see people eating your family’s pizza, your name on the box,” said the younger Mr. Augustine. “We’d be lying if we said it also wasn’t a lot of fun.”

The company’s renewed partnership with PNC Park and increased focus on fundraisers is part of a concerted strategy to expand brand recognition beyond the confines of the New Castle area.

“We’re the number one frozen item sold in Walmart in New Castle,” Mr. Augustine said. “Walmart literally has said to us, ‘How do you guys do this at that store?’”

Jonah S. Berger: jberger@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.