According to a menu framed on the wall, on Aug. 23, 1933, the lunch special at Mitchell’s was a cup of Navy bean soup, and a choice of ham and cabbage, cold sardines, English beef stew or breaded veal chop with a side of potatoes, a beet salad, bread pudding for dessert and a drink, all for the peak-Depression era price of 25 cents. On Thursday — a few months shy of 85 years later — it was still a bargain: roast chicken, stuffing, potatoes and corn for a mere $8.75.
Food has been served for more than a century at this Pittsburgh icon, but after Friday, there will be one less place in Downtown for politicos and plain folks to get a hearty but inexpensive meal.
Third-generation owner James G. “Jimmy” Mitchell Jr. announced Wednesday that today would be the final lunch service for the venerable 112-year old tavern, which is a perennial favorite of Pittsburgh politicians, judges, attorneys, police and city and county government workers. It will remain open as a watering hole — Mr. Mitchell and his staff stressed that — and he said he intends to grow his catering business, but the banquet room upstairs will be converted to office space, and the existing downstairs dining area will fold into the bar.
“I’m re-engineering my business,” he said.
During Thursday’s lunch rush, the place was jammed, as per usual. At the downstairs bar, the scene was something of a throwback: blue- and white-collar workers sat shoulder to shoulder. Their work boots and wingtips, Carhartt jackets and Brooks Brothers blazers, union T-shirts and neckties contrasted but their appetites didn’t. Platters of Judge Caufield’s Hot Meatloaf, a 100-year-old recipe, Joey Diven’s Hot Turkey open-faced sandwich, named for the legendary local political boss and street fighter, and fried fish sandwiches came out as fast as Tammy Mendez, a waitress there since 2000, could bring them.
Tall with broad shoulders and long arms on a lean frame like a boxer, Mr. Mitchell wore a button-down work shirt with a patch that read “Your Lunch is Our Job” and greeted customers with hugs, backslaps and even a John Wayne impression.
‘Hey little Greek girl, c’mere!” Mr. Mitchell said in his gravelly baritone before giving a hug to Stacey Kavalis of West View, an at-least-twice-a-week lunch regular since the early 1980s when she worked at the Allegheny County Courthouse.
“A lot of memories in this place,” she said. “I used to come down and talk with his father because we both spoke Greek.”
Indeed, the Mitchell family has operated a tavern in Pittsburgh since 1906 when family patriarch and Greek immigrant Constantinos Michalopoulos opened the original location at 100 Wylie Ave. in the Hill District at age 23. According to family lore, “a Greek painter couldn’t fit the entire name ‘Michalopoulos’ Dining Room’ on the storefront window, so Constantinos went to the phone book and picked out a more American-sounding, shorter name” and thus, “Mitchell’s was born.”
It moved Downtown to Court Place in 1945, and to its current spot on at 304 Ross St. in 1980. That’s when Mr. Mitchell took over operations from his father, James Sr.
City mayoral spokesman Tim McNulty has visited the tavern for two decades, first as a political observer during a 16-year career as a Post-Gazette reporter, then as a member of the political establishment.
“When I started covering City Hall in 1997, I would go down to Mitchell's and see City Council members and other government people drinking beer at lunch. Not getting wasted but having lunch ‘Mad Men’ style,” Mr. McNulty said. “Those days are long gone. Everybody eats at their desks now and drinks water.”
Ms. Mendez of Mt. Lebanon said that she first came to Mitchell’s for lunch in the 1970s when she was a legal secretary in the Grant Building. She came to work there 18 years ago and has always been enamored of her customers.
“It was a mix — you’d never know. We’d have construction workers, office workers, other restaurant people. It’s like ‘Cheers,’” she said.
Bar manager Sarah Dougherty of the South Side concurred. “We have people straight out of jail — all walks of life here,” she said, laughing.
For her part, she’s excited to expand the bar’s business.
Mr. Mitchell, who will turn 60 in September, said that the lion’s share of what has been routinely a 70-hour work week has been spent in the kitchen, preparing for lunch. He was frank in noting that his devotion to the bar and restaurant put a strain on his 30-year marriage, which ended two years ago.
Shortly after, in a “Casablanca” “of all the gin joints in all the world” moment, Krista Dietrich, a former employee whom he had fired 15 years prior popped into the restaurant for lunch on a whim, after picking up a building permit at the John P. Robin Civic Building across the street. They’ve since started dating and Mr. Mitchell made it clear he wasn’t interested in making the same mistake again, particularly after having a Ghost-of-Christmas future dream about meeting his demise in the restaurant’s walk-in cooler.
“It sounds corny, but I figure I’m not going to have to worry about the grim reaper getting me with that sickle,” he laughed.
Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.