Mitchell’s, a Pittsburgh institution for more than a century, will close the restaurant portion of its tavern business on Friday, owner James G. “Jimmy” Mitchell Jr. announced Wednesday.

“From Prohibition to the Depression to the Great Flood (in Downtown Pittsburgh in 1936) to the drink tax we never stopped serving lunches,” Mr. Mitchell said, “But, it’s time.”

The Mitchell family has operated a tavern in Pittsburgh since 1906 when family patriarch and Greek immigrant Constantinos Michalopoulos opened the original location at 100 Wylie Ave. in the Hill District at age 23. According to family lore, “a Greek painter couldn’t fit the entire name “Michalopoulos’ Dining Room” on the storefront window, so Constantinos went to the phone book and picked out a more American sounding, shorter name” and thus, “Mitchell’s was born.”

It moved Downtown to Court Place in 1945, and to its current spot on at 304 Ross St. in 1980. That’s when Mr. Mitchell took over operations from his father.

Advertise with us

“For 38 years I’ve opened that door every morning,” he said. “It’s time to slow down a little bit. I have a terrific bar staff and a good solid bar business.”

Mr. Mitchell, who will turn 60 in September, said that the lion’s share of what’s been routinely a 70-hour work week has been spent in the kitchen, preparing lunches that include Caufield’s Hot Meatloaf, a 100-year old recipe, and Joey Diven’s Hot Turkey sandwich, named for the legendary local Political boss, street fighter and friend to Art Rooney Sr. and Billy Conn.

The stately tavern is a perennial favorite of Pittsburgh politicians, judges, attorneys, police and city and county government workers.

Attorney Matt Logue has been a Mitchell’s regular for more than a decade and once had his office space in the building floors above the bar.

“This is a sad day for anyone who works in the corridors of Grant St.,” Mr. Logue said.

Advertise with us

It is a hub of activity in the run up to and on the annual Pittsburgh St. Patrick’s Day Parade – they routinely host the “Button Party” for parade sponsors and participants.

Mr. Mitchell said that Mitchell’s catering business will continue, but will discontinue banquet service on the second floor. That will eventually be converted to office space, and the restaurant space will be absorbed into the existing bar.

“I’ll semi retire by going down to only 40 hours a week,” he laughed before adding that he plans to “catch up on some lost years. It’s bittersweet, but I need to learn how to slow down and smell the roses.”

Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412