Spice Affair in Aspinwall may be one of the only places in the region to offer moilly on the menu. Though fish is often the star ingredient, here it’s a vegetarian dish: tofu served with a slurry of coconut milk and curry leaves spiked with chiles, garlic and vinegar, tinted gold from turmeric and slightly red from tomato, laced with fragrant spices like cinnamon and cloves.
Moilly ($11.00) originates in Kerala in Southwest India, a state that has been influenced by people of various backgrounds and religions, with the spice trade attracting those from the Middle East, Portugal, China and Britain at its ports along the Arabian Sea. (This diversity means it’s one of the few places in India that you might find a plate that contains beef, which is rare considering that cow is sacred for Hindus.)
I didn’t know the dish until I worked on a story with Eater critic Robert Sietsema who found Taste of Cochin, a Queens, New York, restaurant named for the Keralan port city (that usually goes by Kochi). When he wrote about it last summer he conveyed how psyched he was to find that cuisine from a region that’s often underrepresented.
It’s an unusual cuisine in Pittsburgh, too, but especially at Spice Affair because the restaurant serves mostly Northern Indian classics like butter chicken (chicken makhani) and variations on vindaloo. And while those dishes can be really satisfying, moilly on the menu points to a staff that’s excited about variations on Indian cuisine. I like that.
How did the dish end up here? Owner Barinder Singh had it at a restaurant when he was visiting Canada.
“I couldn’t stop thinking about it,” he says, so he asked his chef to make it.
Read More
The chef at Spice Affair, Tamilselvan Thangadurai, is one of my favorites in the area. Originally from Southern India, his cooking repertoire is wide in part because of his range of experience and training. He learned how to cook Southern Indian fare well from his family and left home for a several-year pastry gig on cruise ships that traveled around the world.
Over the course of nearly a decade, since he married his now wife who is a Pittsburgh native, he has touched down in the kitchens of perhaps half a dozen restaurants in the area in the past few years, and he opened and closed a place in Monroeville called Kohinoor. Then, having fled for a job in Montclair, New Jersey, he was recruited back to Pittsburgh to work at Spice Affair about a month after it opened.
“He’s a very good chef,” Harpreet Pabla, co-owner of Spice Affair, told me in November. Indeed he is.
Spice Affair
8 Brilliant Ave.
Aspinwall
412-847-7423
Spiceaffairpgh.com
Overall:

- Hours: Lunch, 11 a.m. to 2:30 p.m., Monday to Saturday; dinner, 5 to 10 p.m. Closed Sunday.
- Prices: Appetizers $4 to $10; chaat $4 to $5; soup, sides and breads $2 to $8; tandoori specialties $11 to $20; vegetarian dishes $10 to $12; chicken dishes $11 to $12; seafood $14 to $15; lamb and mutton $13 to $15; rice $4 to $15.
- Wild card: Halal, 10 percent discount for nearby St. Margaret orders; the restaurant delivers in a six-mile radius. There is a $10.99 lunch buffet.
- Details: Street parking; outdoor dining is available.
- Noise level: Relaxed.
Members of the family behind People’s Indian Restaurant in Garfield that’s been there since the mid-1990s, Mr. Singh and Mr. Pabla started the 120-seat BYOB Aspinwall restaurant in December 2016. That Mr. Thangadurai has been here for more than a year makes it seem like he’s here for the long haul, which is why I’m telling you to go there now, past the honeymoon period.
The first time I went when I moved back to town in the fall, I didn’t know Mr. Thangadurai was head of the kitchen, though I should have because the cooking was great. However, it’s far more conservative than the bold flavors and unusual ingredients in his take on regional Indian dishes at his Monroeville restaurant — and that’s fine.
On a vast menu of Indian classics, a chana chaat starter ($5) was spot-on, dotted with chickpeas and potatoes, brightened with cucumber and red onions, and dolloped with green and tamarind chutneys. Among vegetarian plates, the gobi Manchurian cauliflower ($8) with soy and chile sauce is delightful in that mid-century retro way that crab rangoon is pleasing on an Americanized Chinese menu.
In other vegetables, the eggplant in baingan bhartha ($10) is nearly iridescent, a soupy roasted stew studded with onions and tomatoes. The housemade cheese in palak paneer ($11) is as you’d hope, too: pillowy squares with seasoned spinach served, a dish that’s filling on its own or over batsmati rice.
Though the menu is more than friendly for a vegetarian, there’s a laundry list of meat options. A friend ordered a mild version tandoor chicken ($11 half-chicken, $20 whole), delivered fragrant and juicy, its reddened skin on display. And that butter chicken ($12) is the comfort food of Indian fare, with its creamy tomato sauce.
Another ordering strategy is to commit to breads, variations on naan, roti and paratha, served warm, glistening with ghee in some cases, each round ideal for scooping up chutneys, raita and various sauces.
Spice Affair is that neighborhood Indian restaurant that’s far better than an average go-to Indian spot, thanks to the partnership between the skilled Mr. Thangadurai and the owners.
But beyond classics here, there’s nothing quite like visiting a restaurant and discovering gems like moilly on a menu. And once you start looking, they are hidden in plain sight — everywhere.
Melissa McCart: mmccart@post-gazette.com; Instagram @postgazettefood; Facebook @postgazettefood



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.