As a chef for more than a decade in Chicago, Scott Walton knew the ins and outs of the Windy City’s restaurant scene. He was chef for four years at Markethouse, followed by Howells & Hood.

Restaurant critics such as Mike Sula of Chicago Reader cited his “thoughtful preparations” and wrote that “Walton should be taken seriously.”

In September he opened Acorn in Shadyside, and we should heed the Chicago critic’s advice as well as give the place some time to break in.

Acorn

Advertise with us

5528 Walnut St.

Shadyside

412-530-5950

acornpgh.com

Overall:

Advertise with us
  • Hours: Dinner, Sunday through Thursday, 5 to 10 p.m. and until 11 p.m. Friday and Saturday; lunch, Wednesday through Sunday starting at 11 a.m.
  • Prices: Lunch, starters $12 to $14, mains and share plates, $12 to $25; dinner, starters $11 to $16, mains $26 to $35, share plates $74 to $77.
  • Wild card: Scott Walton will cook at the James Beard House in New York on March 21 at 7 p.m., serving a seven-course spring menu. Tickets run $175 for nonmembers. Call 1-212-627-2308 for reservations.
  • Details: Street parking, dining room is wheelchair accessible.
  • Noise level: Lively.

Mr. Walton moved here when his wife, Maggie, a Steel City native, took a new job. She’s delighted to be back, and her husband is hooked, albeit still getting to know the mysteries of Pittsburgh, a place that is both incredibly warm and loving but at times can be tribal and standoffish for an outsider.

At first, he got a job as the executive chef at Heinz Field for a couple of years before he opened Acorn, but I’m guessing it’s different to experience the city as an independent restaurant owner.

There have been hiccups, apparently. I missed some early ones because I also just returned to Pittsburgh. Shadyside is an unusual location for an ambitious chef new to the city: This neighborhood has become pretty conservative. As I understand it, it’s not as freewheeling as it was in the ’90s — or even as much as Downtown restaurants have been.

As Mr. Walton gets to know what Pittsburghers want and who’s coming to the restaurant, he’s turning out some very good and often creative cooking that’s worth exploring.

Acorn contrasts its lean decor with dishes that, if they were songs, would be on your stomp-clap playlist featuring Spoon and the Lumineers: They’re percussive, catchy and generally harmonious, with a bevy of ingredients, that, on the plate displays a fluency in technique.

Advertise with us

In the dining room, an array of blues, whites and browns frame a room with a modest bar, some cushy banquettes, nearly naked walls and candlelit accents. Randy Wright oversees service that usually balances out warmth and attentiveness without being chummy. He makes solo diners feel welcome at the bar without holding them captive in conversation. And by my third visit the restaurant had a nice crew of repeat visitors.

The food menu is a mix of smallish plates, a few entree-sized options and two large format dishes — a fish cassoulet and steak Diane that, at more than $70 an order, are clearly meant for sharing. I’d recommend touring the menu — and don’t forget it’s going to change somewhat dependent on the season and on what’s available.

Vegetables that elsewhere could be dowdy are pretty lively here, like the smoked beets ($13) with goat cheese gremolata and walnuts, for a composition that tastes like barbecue potato chips. The charred cauliflower ($14) is nearly seductive, with apricot, lemon, walnuts and toasted breadcrumbs. A goat sausage ($16) — three cheers for goat, although at other times the dish features veal — is plated in cast iron, with mustard seeds that sidle up to meat dressed with celery and chives, coddled by a layer of spatzle and cabbage confit. It’s a luscious dish.

More straightforward options fall in the Italian family, including the salt cod ($15) — baccala mantecato — with potatoes that are smooth and creamy with a near crust slightly charred, served with toast. Pasta like rigatoni ($26) sheathed with stravecchio is scented by truffle, veering off-genre with nori — and probably does not need pine nuts. Duck lasagna ($26) riffs on Greek pastichio so it’s layers of bucatini with mushroom ragout, bechamel and egg. I liked it but didn’t read the fine print and was expecting tomato. Even with my adjusted expectations, it is pillowy from the bucatini center — but, alas, a bit dry.

You may think you don’t need dessert, but you should get the baked Alaska, a little mound that includes chocolate cake, cremeux, caramel and foie gras ice cream. Granted, we may not covet this particular ice cream flavor, but it’s not a deal breaker for a dessert that’s sweet and satisfying. But that’s only half of it. The show should drive your order — it’s flambeed tableside.

Advertise with us

Who doesn’t like a bit of pyrotechnics to wrap up the meal? Notes of toasted caramel and meringue that scent the table are an added bonus. It’s a wonderful detail.

Melissa McCart: mmccart@post-gazette.com Instagram @postgazettefood; Facebook @postgazettefood.