Price key

$: Under $15 per person without alcohol

$$: Under $35 per person without alcohol

$$$: $35 and up per person without alcohol

Advertise with us

As the Post-Gazette’s dining critic, I’m asked for restaurant recommendations dozens of times a week. The requests are only more frequent as the holidays near.

You’d think people would want to know what’s “the best” of Pittsburgh, but usually their questions are much more specific.

For the fall dining guide, I share and answer some readers’ questions about where to take ’tween nieces and the grandparents, food-snob friends and wine geeks.

Bartender Patrick Madden, left, takes care of Alison Kaelin, Stacy Miller and her brother, Glenn Miller, all of Observatory Hill, at Max's Allegheny Tavern on the North Side. (Bill Wade / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Where do I take someone who wants a taste of old Pittsburgh?

With a labyrinth of rooms, a working fireplace, a stately bar and a player piano, Max’s Allegheny Tavern on the North Side retains the feel of its past as a hotel and speakeasy.

Advertise with us

It’s still a memorable place for a Saturday afternoon lunch or early dinner that starts with a draft of Spaten or Warsteiner and continues with bratwurst on a bun with a side of spatzle. Or go with a Rust Belt classic: a tall braunschweiger sandwich.

Max’s is special to me because it’s where I was offered my job at the Post-Gazette, whose executive editor implored me to order the schnitzel a la Holstein, served with anchovies and capers and topped with a fried egg. You should order it, too.

• $-$$ • 537 Suismon St., North Side • 412-231-1899 • maxsalleghenytavern.com •

Walleye pike with bok choy, winter squash, radish yuzu and sesame rice cake by chef Derek Stevens of Eleven in the Strip District. (Lake Fong / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Where do I take someone for a birthday dinner on a Sunday night when so many places are closed?

Even on a Sunday, you want to ensure that service is tight and that the evening is special. At Eleven in the Strip District, you’re sure to have an experience that is elegant and polished, especially when you note the occasion when you make a reservation.

Advertise with us

Start with a dozen oysters or, at this time of the year, the coveted Nantucket Bay scallops served atop red-flannel (corned beef and beet) hash, with a side of greens dressed in black garlic-and-bacon vinaigrette.

Move on to an entree of housemade strozzapreti dressed with arugula pesto, served with white-bean toast or rapini and burrata.

And save room for dessert, because this is one of the few restaurants that still employs a dedicated pastry chef. Eleven excels in seasonal crostada, banana cream pie and a take on a candy bar with chocolate-olive oil cake, peanut butter cream and chocolate malt ice cream.

• $$$ • 1150 Smallman St., Strip District • 412-201-5656 • elevenck.com •

Tuna mojama with marcona almond and chili oil at Cure in Lawrenceville. (Lake Fong / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Where do I take my food-snob friends who are visiting from New York/Portland, Ore./San Francisco?

Advertise with us

Justin Severino has garnered national attention, having been a two-time semifinalist for a James Beard award and nominee and winner of Food & Wine magazine’s “People’s Choice: Best New Chef.” With this kind of recognition, it’s natural that Cure in Lawrenceville has become a foodie destination.

The energy makes it an exciting place to visit right now, as staff prepares for the opening of sister restaurant Morcilla during the holiday season. Yes, you can plan a multi-course tour de force that includes a snack such as the porcini-and-roasted onion soup, followed by burnt-wheat tagliatelle and a duck confit with beer-braised ’kraut, meat caramel apples and an herb ravigote.

Or in the spirit of Morcilla, the Spanish restaurant that Mr. Severino is opening down the street, go with a friend. Order a bottle of verdejo or tempranillo. Pair it with two courses: the salumi di mare — cured fish like the sockeye salmon ’nduja with pickled peppers and chives — and the big salumi board. Share, compare and enjoy.

• $$$ • 5336 Butler St., Lawrenceville • 412-252-2595 • curepittsburgh.com •

A fully equipped cheeseburger, plated with home fries and pickles, at Tessaro's in Bloomfield. (Larry Roberts / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Where do I take my relatives who used to love Kings?

Advertise with us

This is a question I get often, now that Kings Family Restaurant is no longer locally owned. Where does one go when looking for a place with easy access for a wheelchair or walker, is not too “foodie” nor too expensive, serves dinner early, and has a full bar for the “kids”?

Now that its expansion is complete, I’d recommend Tessaro’s in Bloomfield.

This past summer, the restaurant had finished renovations, nearly doubling its seating and more space between tables, as well as an outdoor patio.

Consider chops and N.Y strip, but also check the chalkboard specials, which usually include two soups and a couple of hearty entrees. And, yes, bartender Debbie will pour just what you’re craving to take the edge off.

Another reason to visit? It’s the restaurant’s 30th anniversary year.

Advertise with us

• $$ • 4601 Liberty Ave., Bloomfield • 412-682-6809 • tessaros.com •

Summer roll by chef Ling Robinson at Asiatique Thai Bistro in East Liberty. (Steve Mellon / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Where do I take my ’tween nieces for a Saturday lunch?

I’d recommend Asiatique Thai Bistro in Bakery Square for a relaxed leisurely lunch that can be healthy, bright and flavorful. And it’s close to shopping.

When “the high-heeled chef” Ling Robinson arrived from Chiang Mai in 1991 and opened Green Mango, she was among the first native Thais to introduce Pittsburghers to pad thai, curries and spicy salads.

Asiatique offers lunch and dinner for reasonable prices, with a menu that’s focused on smaller zingy dishes such as the super-fresh summer rolls. This time of year is just right for the pattaya chicken noodle soup, with baby bok choy, fried garlic, mixed vegetables and fresh local chicken served with egg, rice or glass noodles. Don’t miss the drinks, such as an intense ginger tea or a papaya smoothie.

Advertise with us

• $-$$ • 120 Bakery Square Blvd., Larimer • 412-441-1212 • asiatiquethaibistro.com •

Lauren Davis, Jenn Bree and Rob Nungesser at the bar in Poros in Market Square. (Dominique Hildebrand / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Where do I go for of-the-moment cocktails and food?

Poros Aegean Estiatorio is the splashiest place in Market Square right now.

The newest restaurant from Big Y Restaurant Group features a spacious round bar marked by a dramatic chandelier that looks like a school of iridescent sea creatures. Past the bar you’ll find the bright open kitchen beside the display of whole fish, which might include Dover sole and dorade next to giant beautiful garides, a type of prawn.

For those who don’t care for seafood, the menu also features homemade spanikopita and a knockout roasted cauliflower dish, along with a handful of lamb specialties, with meat from Pennsylvania-based Elysian Fields and Jamison Farms.

Advertise with us

Carrie Clayton has put together an alluring cocktail menu, including ouzo-based drinks with housemade tonics. Or keep it simple with vermouth on tap.

• $$$ • PPG 2 Market Square, Downtown • 412-904-2051 • porospgh.com •

Dan Bartow of Legends of the North Shore: where “Mama’s gravy” rules (Larry Roberts / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Where should I go for classic red sauce?

Yes, there are a handful of red-sauce restaurants that Pittsburghers swear by, including Tambellini’s in Highland Park and Alla Famiglia in Allentown, both of which are good.

But for someone in search of a casual, affordable spaghetti-and-meatball experience, I’d recommend Legends of the North Shore.

Advertise with us

The interior displays a faded charm, with a pastiche of Steelers and Pirates photos and stained-glass wall hangings. In the open kitchen, you’ll find Dan Bartow, while his wife, Zoe, runs the dining room, with the help of their grown children, Kristopher and Danyelle.

Order the greens and beans, followed by veal Parmesan or spaghetti and meatballs smothered with “Mama’s gravy,” his grandmother's sauce recipe.

Speaking of greens and beans, Legends also has a food truck that specializes in the dish: @coolbeanstruck on Twitter.

• $$ • 500 E. North Ave., North Side • 412-321-8000 • legendsatthenorthshore.com •

The Spirit espresso machine from Holland, one of six in the U.S., at 4121 Main coffee shop in Bloomfield. (Lake Fong / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

My friend is really into design and interiors. Where should I take her?

Advertise with us

A good place to start is the coffee shop at 4121 Main, a bright little nook that the designer/artist Thommy Conroy and Kira Hoeg opened earlier this year at that address in Bloomfield.

The partners have done a lot with a tiny space, decorating it with Mr. Conroy’s stunning floral designs and seasonal displays in the bay windows. (He also styles magazine shoots, parties and pop-ups in Manhattan.)

Start with conversation and a coffee made from Heart Roasters beans out of Portland, Ore. Ms. Hoeg has built a following on cappuccinos and lattes with bright, floral notes and velvety milk that’s the perfect temperature.

Also check out the Spirit, a looker of an espresso machine designed by Kees van der Westen. One of only a few in the United States, it has more horsepower than most and a very consistent pour.

• $ • 4121 Main St., Bloomfield • 412-708-4500 • 4121main.com •

Advertise with us
Udipi owner Manjunath Sherigar delivers paper masala dosa, a rice cake filled with potatoes and onions. (John Heller / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Where can I go where I won’t run into people I know?

This is a tough question, because it depends on who’s asking. But provided you’re not going out for a meal after a service at Sri Venkateswara Temple down the road, I’d recommend Udipi in Monroeville. Arrive with a hearty appetite, and if you’re so inclined, a couple of beers or wine, because it’s BYOB.

You can try many dishes at this 20-year-old restaurant, with an extensive menu that includes vada (savory doughnuts), uthappam and an assortment of dishes called a thali. But at this place that sells up to 500 dosas a day, be sure you order those, in one of the infinite variations. A type of pancake with omelet-like consistency toward the center and a crispy crepe texture at the edges, dosas can be rolled and stuffed with vegetables such as potatoes or dressed with a simple layer of hot chutney.

• $ • 4141 Old William Penn Highway, Monroeville • 412-373-5581 • udipicafepittsburgh.net •

Sommelier John Wabeck st Spoon in East Liberty. (Nate Guidry / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Where should I take someone who’s really into wine? 

Advertise with us

With a growing number of certified sommeliers in the region, there are more places than ever where you can try interesting wines. But the evergreen is Spoon. Yes, you’ll find wines from the classic super Tuscan to a beautiful white Burgundy, and even an interesting French cider. But what leads me to suggest Spoon is sommelier John Wabeck’s encyclopedic knowledge and his ability to introduce diners to something new that appeals to their palates.

He’s also very passionate about gin, and he hosts a Thursday night gin club that features an array of compelling gin-based cocktails and the city’s most comprehensive selection of the spirit.

• $$$ • 134 S. Highland Ave., East Liberty • 412-362-6001 • spoonpgh.com •

Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart.