A few Pittsburgh restaurants are cited as tour-of-duty kitchens for ambitious young cooks hungry for experience, such as The Duquesne Club, Downtown, and Hyeholde in Moon.
Even though it’s more casual than either restaurant, Casbah in Shadyside is up there with them. Just past its 20th anniversary, the restaurant has played a role in shaping the careers of many Pittsburgh chefs.
Now the corporate chef for Big Burrito, Bill Fuller headed up the kitchen when the restaurant opened in late October 1995. He’s a native Pittsburgher who was back from stints in Washington, D.C., and California.
Casbah also brought up a young Henry Dewey, now a partner in Penn Ave. Fish Company; Alan Peet, now at Oakmont Country Club, formerly at the now-closed Isabela on Grandview; Chris Bonfili of Avenue B; Dan Carlton at Butcher and the Rye; and Chad Townsend, former chef at the now-closed Salt of the Earth who recently started Millie’s Ice Cream.
That’s not counting people who are still working for Big Burrito, such as Dustin Gardner, now the head chef at Soba in Shadyside, and, of course, Eli Wahl, who has been executive chef at Casbah for six years.
Derek Stevens — head chef at Big Burrito’s Eleven in the Strip District since 2006 — worked at Casbah “at least twice” in his career before Eleven opened. The first time was in 1999, when he spent 2½ years as a sous chef. He started just a few weeks before Justin Severino, who now runs Cure in Lawrenceville and is about to open Morcilla down the street.
Read More
Mr. Stevens pointed to today’s differences between Eleven and Casbah, which has become a high-volume restaurant.
“It’s three times as busy today than it was when it opened,” Mr. Fuller said about Casbah.
Casbah opened as a boundary pusher and has settled in as a comfortable and consistent spot that draws a crowd for its low-lit dining room, outdoor seating, a dynamic wine list and price points to suit many budgets. Today’s menu includes a slew of dishes that change with the season, as well as a few crowd pleasers such as short rib ravioli and ricotta cavatelli with sausage and spinach that are always available.
“Guests know what to expect and what they’re going to get in terms of food and service,” said Mr. Wahl.
“It’s a lot less weird for Pittsburgh than it used to be,” Mr. Stevens said. Steak, for example, wasn’t even on the menu. It is today.
“It was seafood and lamb from Elysian Fields [in Waynesburg],” he said, noting that, back then, local lamb was relatively novel for the market. “And it was a lot more traditional North African or Mediterranean, less contemporary than the menu is now.”
In 1996, the Post-Gazette cited a menu with garlic in cream, lamb hash or striped bass with chanterelles. The critic at the time, Woodene Merriman, called out unusual ingredients, which prompted Herky Pollock, now the executive vice president at CBRE, and a partner in Burgatory restaurants, to write a letter to the editor in support of the restaurant.
“For years in Pittsburgh, consumers have been crying out for something different, something more adventurous,” he wrote to the Post-Gazette, citing the architecture and the quality of the food as “superb.”
By 1999, the menu was still introducing what some would consider unusual ingredients, such as a dish with lamb merguez with flageolet beans, or an arugula salad with cremini mushrooms, roasted potatoes and pancetta. Both the mushrooms and the merguez, a Northern African lamb or beef-based sausage, are more common today.
“That was back when Chef’s Garden used to deliver to Pittsburgh once a week,” Mr. Stevens said. That company’s farmer, Lee Jones in Huron, Ohio, sells fine produce to the top-of-the-top chefs, with Pittsburgh chefs occasionally getting ingredients from a source that used to be in a regular rotation.
Today, Mr. Fuller relies on more local farms such as One Woman Farm in Richland, Clarion River Organics and Grow Pittsburgh through Penn’s Corner Alliance.
As Casbah wraps up a month of looking back on its milestone anniversary, many Pittsburghers share Mr. Fuller’s sentiments about the restaurant.
“I have a soft spot for Casbah,” Mr. Fuller said. “It’s the restaurant that’s closest to my heart.”
Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.