We all want what we can’t have, right?

Multimillion-dollar homes around the region had Post-Gazette.com readers oohing and ahhing each week, enamored by the history, the elegance, the designs — and the price tags.

But it wasn’t just mansions most of us can’t afford that captivated readers. Log cabins and neighborhood homes we’ve seen but didn’t know the stories behind also caught readers’ attention.

Here’s a look at the homes in the PG’s “Buying Here” section that captured the most attention among Post-Gazette.com readers in 2023, in order of when they were published.

Advertise with us

(Note: The houses listed below may have since been sold or taken off the market.)

Updated 1939 estate in Fox Chapel priced at nearly $3 million

Published Jan. 27

Towering over Fox Chapel Road, perched atop a perfectly manicured lawn, with a commanding view of the Fox Chapel Golf Club’s golf course, 825 Fox Chapel Road is the definition of a stately home.

Two-story columns supporting the covered entrance off the front terrace announce the grandeur of the property. Inside, a travertine marble foyer hints at the attention to detail and the easy elegance of the interior design.

Read the full story here.

Advertise with us

Stone house with 2 centuries of history priced at $80,000

Published Feb. 3

Sitting near the banks of the Monongahela River is an old stone house that has watched over 220 years of Washington County history flow by.

It is an imposing house, with three stories. It is also a part of Bonnie Hall’s family history.

“The plaque on the parsonage says 1803, but it was actually built in 1797,” said Hall, who said the original land owner was Major Frederick Wise, Fredericktown’s namesake.

Read the full story here.

Advertise with us

Sauers' carriage house in Aspinwall priced at $235,000

Published Feb. 17

A strange enclave of stone buildings along Center Avenue in Aspinwall has been ignored by some, forgotten by others and revered by historians of architecture around the world.

Built in the early 20th century by German immigrant and architect Fredrick Sauer, the six buildings, all considered historic landmarks, are being sold individually for the first time since they were built.

Sauer is best known for the churches he designed in Pittsburgh such as St. Mary of the Mount on Mount Washington and St. Stanislaus Kostka in the Strip District, but his work is known across the globe.

Read the full story here.

Advertise with us

1792 Greene County house with log addition priced under $635,000

Published March 24

From the Revolutionary War to the American frontier to a takeover by coal mines, this house in Greene County has stood through 230 years of U.S. history.

“I love history and always wanted to live in an old house,” said Gil Sanchez.

He and his wife Patty’s dream came true when they found a house of stone and logs built in 1792 by Revolutionary War soldier William Cree.

“To put it in perspective, George Washington was president,” said Mr. Sanchez. 

Advertise with us

After nearly a decade of living the dream at 117 Havers Hill Road in Jefferson, the couple are ready to downsize.

Read the full story here.

Byhams' Mt. Lebanon estate priced at $2.95 million

Published June 23

The stately Tudor at 1440 Pueblo Drive in Mt. Lebanon was originally a wedding gift to the McClarens, costing $25,000 in 1929.

Most recently it has been the cherished home base of Carolyn and Bill Byham, founder of DDI, a human resource training and consulting company. 

Advertise with us

Read the full story here.

Never-lived-in modern house in Fox Chapel priced at nearly $4 million

Published July 7

There is some California dreaming going on in the heart of Fox Chapel. The vibe is coming from a bold contemporary at 409 Fox Chapel Road. 

It was to be the forever family home of Los Angeles-based business owner Jeremy Cohen, his wife, Rebecca Witt, and their two daughters. The couple bought a vacant lot  in 2018 and rented a house down the road so they could oversee every detail of the build.

Things didn’t go as planned.

Advertise with us

Read the full story here.

‘Glenna’s House’ in the Mexican War Streets listed for $869,000

Published July 21

Glenna’s House at 1301 Sherman Ave. in the Mexican War Streets would not be recognized by the woman it was named for — especially on the inside. 

“In 2002 there was an article in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette about Glenna [Zendarsky] ... and my historical restoration of this lovely property has been inspired by her heritage and her social style with neighbors,” explained Mahmoud Zalloum, the current owner. 

“So, Rema, my wife, and I decided to name the house ‘Glenna’s House,’” he added.

Advertise with us

Read the full story here.

Log home in Ligonier offers lush isolation for $2.75 million

Published Aug. 5

He didn’t necessarily set out to be a conservationist, but Paul Kovacs ended up preserving and enhancing 121 acres in Ligonier for his own enjoyment and that of the natural inhabitants.   

A mile-long driveway through a pristine forest leads to the log home he shares with his wife, Judy, at 1390 State Route 271. 

Read the full story here.

Advertise with us

Historic Shadyside mansion priced at $2.645 million

Published Sept. 8

With 10,000 plus square feet of living space, including six bedrooms and seven bathrooms, 5135 Ellsworth Ave. in Shadyside qualifies as a mansion in the truest sense of the word. 

Built to impress for William Penn Snyder, the home is reminiscent of the White House with its Greek Revival style and two-story columns at the entrance.

Like the White House, it has had the distinction of hosting various dignitaries including Princess Grace of Monaco (Grace Kelly), Nobel Prize winner Marie Curie as well as U.S. Presidents Calvin Coolidge and William Taft, among others.

Read the full story here.

Advertise with us

Oakwood house with a chef's kitchen sells in 4 days for more than $250,000

Published Oct. 13

Some homes genuinely reflect their owners, and 2416 Durbin St. in Oakwood is one of them.

The two-story brick home with steeply pitched roof is home to two chefs, Clare and Andrew Lise, with a passion for the original details of this nearly century-old home.

Read the full story here.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.