There are many words to describe 323 Lincoln Ave. in Bellevue: a diamond in the rough, a grand old lady, or with a little imagination, a great opportunity. That was what owner John Robinson was looking for when he purchased the house in 2019.

Now with a desire for a quieter life in a more suburban setting, Robinson put the house on the market for $189,000 with Kristi and Taylor DeLorenzo of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices (www.thepreferredrealty.com or 412-528-6290). The property is now under contract.

Robinson, an architect, grew up in a family of contractors in the South Hills. His uncle owned a construction business.

“I went on jobs with him and as I got older he would have me do more,” he said. “Started doing that full time after high school.”

Advertise with us

But he didn’t take to the daily grind, so he decided to become an architect. A few years ago, while Robinson was working elsewhere, he started thinking about what he really wanted.

“I said a prayer. I wanted a house in the North Hills, specifically in Bellevue, a multifamily, preferably a fixer-upper with stained-glass windows, fireplaces and built-in cabinetry,” he said. “About a month after I put this little prayer out, I get an email. … Here’s this little house in Bellevue.”

The next day he was on a plane home.

“I called the agent, went over, breezed through, knew what I was getting into and I knew it was for me.”

Built in 1911, the three-story house has street-facing sunrooms on the first two floors. It’s an imposing structure that has seen a few additions made in the back. The line of the mansard roof is broken by dormers and four towering chimneys that served six fireplaces.

Advertise with us

The house is currently divided into three units, two with two bedrooms and sunrooms and a one-bedroom apartment on the third floor. That’s where Robinson started his grand rehab adventure. He did all the demolition himself, stripping old plaster to expose some knob-and-tube wiring and the house’s beautiful bare bones.

“The house, in my opinion, has a naturally perfect, beautiful layout,” said the architect. “Not a single thing I would change. Perfect.”

The large open room on the first floor looks like a construction site, but it’s impossible to miss its potential. It has large windows and an imposing fireplace with a columned mantel. The hearth and fireplace feature white rectangular tile and a second-floor fireplace has beautiful blue and white tile.

“On the second floor there are four fireplaces,” Robinson said. “Not the quality of the first floor, but beautiful.”

Originally set up as gas fireplaces, they work but their chimneys are not lined.

Advertise with us

Robinson feels the place is “chock-full of charm, character, everything you would want.”

Over the sunroom door off the living room is a leaded-glass transom that resembles one over the front door.

The dining room has a fireplace with brownish green fire-glazed tiles on the surround and hearth. One wall bows out with two very large windows and there is a built-in china cabinet next to the fireplace.

The layout of the second floor is slightly different. In the living room, the fireplace was sadly given a stone veneer in the 1970s. Robinson said brick remains underneath the stone. The sunroom opens to the living room and there is a second open-air porch with an original beadboard ceiling on one side.

All but the sun porch got dropped ceilings in the ’70s. One of the bedrooms is linked to the living room by a pair of French doors. The dining room walls are covered with wood paneling and the fireplace is surrounded by more glazed tile.

Advertise with us

The three kitchens in the house are in varying stages of redevelopment. The first floor kitchen has been gutted and has a few sections of exposed brick. All three have wood floors like the rest of the house.

“The floors are all original,” Robinson said. “For the most part, the wood species is old-growth pine — nice, tight, hard-grain pine.”

He said each is at least 3/8 inch thick and could be refinished.

The third floor is a wide-open space with a bathroom, kitchen, living room and bedroom.

“I took all those walls down, opened it all up, made it bigger, airy,” Robinson said.

Advertise with us

New wiring has been installed and connected to new circuit breakers on the second floor; he figures all the space needs is drywall.

At the rear of the third floor is a door to nowhere.

“On the back end of the house is a door that opens to the fire escape. he said. There is a 15- by- 15-foot flat roof above the kitchen below. I was planning on putting on a deck,” he said.

There is a bathroom on each floor. The one on the second floor has original subway tile on the wall and black-and-white basket-weave tile on the floor. The first floor has the same setup but with white penny-tile flooring. There is the beginning of a new bathroom on the third floor along with a powder blue bathroom suite.

Most of the front windows are original but the others have been replaced through the years. The older boiler that feeds the radiators will have to be replaced.

Advertise with us

There is a two-car garage with electricity in the backyard. The property is currently permitted as a bed and breakfast.

Its Allegheny County assessment is $171,900. Over the last three years, two residential properties have sold in the 300 block of Lincoln Avenue: this house for $150,000 in January 2019 and a three-unit house for $251,800 in February 2021 (www2.alleghenycounty.us/RealEstate/GeneralInfo.aspx?).

Lizabeth Gray: lgray@post-gazette.com 

Correction, posted July 16, 2022: In an earlier version of this story, the thickness of the wood flooring was misstated.